Mafia 22: Singled Out - Game over!

[PeaceBringer]

OK-- massive is around-- just may need a prod

unvote BB then--

he could hardly get a kill in if not around

same goes for THoth.

Not sure what to make of everything then.

[massive]

I've got nothing to add. Same as the previous night, the killer is being meticulous, which I am interpreting as the godfather (which is undoubtably all we have left) is doing the killing. Actually, some discussion about whether we think we have one mafia or two left would do some good to my theories, but I'd like to hear the bulk of opinions on that topic.

Limited access until Friday. Will post when I can.

[NanookTheWolf]

I know that Banana Bob hasn't really been around, but I Mr. Gnome it all's results are all that we really have to go on for this day. I wish I had chosen Banana Bob over Massive, but I can't change that.

Vote: Banana Bob

... Better then nothing I suppose.

[Dirge]

Vote Count:

Banana Bob 3

: (Mr. Gnome it all, Fuldu, Nanook the Wolf)

Not voting: Banana Bob, Massive, Peace Bringer, Thoth, Sinister Overlord, Otaku

5 to lynch.

I will be looking for a replacement for Banana Bob.

[Thoth]

I'm also leaning to vote BananaBob. I've only read the posts this day sofar, so I'll have to reread the rest of the thread just to make sure I don't miss anything.
From what I read and remember from earlier there are several things pointing towards BB and the only reason he has not been lynched is that he was attacked by IS. That is of course a good reason, but when other evidence is building up we have to consider that it could also have been caused by something weird in the reporter role or by whatever mechanic the mod build in.

[NanookTheWolf]

Well, I think that if we are going to do the Banana Bob lynch we better do it before he is replaced. This way we don't have to wait around for the replacement to read the thread, and so someone doesn't replace and suddenly be lynched.

[PeaceBringer]

well a thought occurred to me-- if there are 2 bad guys left then BB wouldn't have to be around--

vote Banana Bob

[Dirge]

Well, I think that if we are going to do the Banana Bob lynch we better do it before he is replaced.

Too late. Mastermind of Sin will be replacing Banana Bob.

Vote Count

Mastermind of Sin aka Banana Bob 4

: (Mr. Gnome it all, Fuldu, Nanook the Wolf, Peace Bringer)

Not voting: Mastermind of Sin, Massive, Thoth, Sinister Overlord, Otaku

5 to lynch.

[Fuldu]

Well, now that he's here, he'll get a temporary reprieve while I await his night results.

unvote: Mastermind of Sin

[Mastermind of Sin]

Hello all, as you can see, I'm replacing Banana Bob here. I'll be reading through the thread, and I'm about halfway right now. Would it be possible for one or more of you to list the reasons you are trying to lynch me other than the fact that BB was inactive? If you still wish to lynch me after you've seen my response, that's fine, but I want to have a chance to say something for myself first.

[PeaceBringer]

because you/bob ate spaghetti

[Mastermind of Sin]

I'm not sure I see the relevence. Just because one person ate spaghetti and was a gangster, does not mean that all people who eat spaghetti are gangsters.


Also, about my last night choice. My investigation turned up a not gangster result. Would it be wise at this point for me to reveal it, or not? I can post it if you guys want me to.

[NanookTheWolf]

You probably should post it ...

[massive]

I don't think it will matter. It's obvious that Banana Bob got away with disguising his anti-town role as a pro-town role. Now that I think about it, that's probably why he was getting "non-gangster/gangster" results ... he's really looking for the gangsters so he can share his information with them.

The "eating alone" part of MGIA's result seems to point to the fact that BB/MoS was estranged from the group at the start -- that would also explain why IS would take a potshot at him (knowing him only to be investigative, and believing him to be pro-town).

I don't believe, however, that BB/MoS can kill ... so while today may be easy, there's still more coming.

vote Mastermind of Sin

... and huge "I Told You So"s.

[Mastermind of Sin]

i'm eating alone because I'm a peeping tom, and I'm not generally liked around town. So I keep to myself most of the time. Anyways, just in case you do lynch me, I investigated Thoth last night, and he is not a gangster. However, if you feel that you must go through with it and lynch me, just know that you are letting the mafia go free for another night, and it's likely another one of the investigative roles will die tonight, meaning we will be down two investigators in one span of day and night. This will severely hurt the town. Personally, I believe there are other people here who have been acting more suspiciously and have been contributing less to the town than I/BB have. These are the people we need to look to before we decide to end the day. I'm just asking you to consider this. It seems to me that all you've done today is bandwagon me, while the true mafia are escaping your notice by lying low and not drawing attention.

[Otaku376]

Well, I am still unconvinced entirely of MoS's guilt. ID came up as popcorn under MGIA's results and I still find that IS shooting at BB pretty hard ignore. I AM curious how MoS got a result last night.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Well, I am still unconvinced entirely of MoS's guilt. ID came up as popcorn under MGIA's results and I still find that IS shooting at BB pretty hard ignore. I AM curious how MoS got a result last night.

because BB investigated someone...at least, that's what the mod told me...

[Otaku376]

that I find hard to believe, in resepct to the time frame.

vote: Mastermind of Sin

[Mastermind of Sin]

how am i supposed to know? I only know what the mod told me...are you suggesting that the mod lied? He told me that I investigated Thoth last night and got a non-ganster result...that's all i know...if you don't think that's possible, take it up with the mod

[Mastermind of Sin]

anyways, it's twilight now, so I will start my haunting

I suggest you all look to Otaku tommorow, because he lynched me for no other reason than the fact that BB sent in his night choice quickly last night. I don't no if he is mafia, but he seems very suspicious to me...

[NanookTheWolf]

Well, we'll see what happens after the death post.

[Dirge]

Vote Count:

Mastermind of Sin -5- (Mr. Gnome it all, massive, Nanook the Wolf, Otaku376, Peacebringer, )

Not voting -3- (Thoth, Fuldu, Mastermind of Sin)

It was a quick day even by "Singled Out" Standards. And even though everyone was grateful to Mastemind for taking over for Banana Bob they lynched him anyway.

Mastermind of Sin - Lonnie, Gangster wanna'be

is dead. (yes, he was scum)

Night Falls

Get your choices in and I will get this bad boy back in business ASAP.

[Dirge]

Day breaks...

If you made catering plans with Monica you need to find another, caterer that is.

Mr._Gnome_it_all, Monica the caterer

is dead, shot in the head.

7 alive, that's 4 to lynch.

[Fuldu]

Results, anyone?

[Otaku376]

Massive didn't go out last night. Which is interesting because when I checked morpheus/peacebringer the night before, it clearly stated that I saw him and that he isn't a gangster. I don't know how I want to interpret that result.