It's his dodginess and constant misrepresentation that irks me. Also, what Toto said, although I can think of one instance, is if you were cop and you got a guilty one night. However, there's no Cop in this game and it's day one.In post 722, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:Why are you scum reading Hiraki again? I don't think not explaining reads makes him scum.
Makes scum job easier. Giving reads list and explaining town reads helps scum figure out who to night kill.In post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
Because if he is town he is an easy mislynch. If he is scum he won't die.In post 729, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:How do you know he won't?
That's basically the MS version of "i like you because you good". No actual substance, just purported substance.In post 730, Toto wrote:Ok, I'm going to assume "making good arguments" is the only reason he is townreading Nebula. Hikari, if you are town and this is wrong please enlighten me.
VOTE: Nebula
Why would scum not want to do normal town things like explaining reads I don't see why scum would draw attention to themselves like thatIn post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
Good point, but to what benefit as town?In post 734, Elena Fisher wrote:Why would scum not want to do normal town things like explaining reads I don't see why scum would draw attention to themselves like thatIn post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
The attitude feels forced to me. He is a logical player, and he is being illogical.In post 734, Elena Fisher wrote:Why would scum not want to do normal town things like explaining reads I don't see why scum would draw attention to themselves like thatIn post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
I mean, most people who are logical are prone to being illogical from time to time, such as myself, but what I'm seeing more from him is dodgy and intentionally misleading behavior, or in some cases logic that seems to come from batshit nowhere, mainly in his first two big posts.In post 739, Toto wrote:The attitude feels forced to me. He is a logical player, and he is being illogical.In post 734, Elena Fisher wrote:Why would scum not want to do normal town things like explaining reads I don't see why scum would draw attention to themselves like thatIn post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
That said there are many reasons why Scum hikari could behave like he is doing.In post 734, Elena Fisher wrote:Why would scum not want to do normal town things like explaining reads I don't see why scum would draw attention to themselves like thatIn post 723, Toto wrote:Why wouldnt he want to explain reads as town though?
Why is he wrong, and why are his beliefs scary?In post 742, Elena Fisher wrote:I honestly think you're wrong but you believe you're right and that's scary. I have a lot more to re read ( I did catch up but a lot of it was me just glazing the thread) so I'll take another look at him but I do think you're wring
This isn't actually answering the question.In post 744, Elena Fisher wrote:Someone who is doing wrong but believes there in the right is without a doubt one of the most scary things
Because your scumread is wrong simple.
That was answering part of your question just because you don't get an answer you're happy with doesn't mean it's a dodge. I think he's wrong on the scumread because I think there town use common sense it's not a hard thing to fill in the blanksIn post 746, Sesq wrote:This isn't actually answering the question.In post 744, Elena Fisher wrote:Someone who is doing wrong but believes there in the right is without a doubt one of the most scary things
What is it with people and dodging questions
Actually no, you didn't answer my question (unless there was confusion over what you were answering which seems unlikely, if so feel free to correct.) I asked this: "Why is he wrong, and why are his beliefs scary?" and you answered with "Someone who is doing wrong but believes there in the right is without a doubt one of the most scary things". This doesn't answer why he is wrong about his scumread of Hiraki, but it does kind of answer the latter, but not really, as your fear is over him thinking what you believe to be incorrect things, not over what those thoughts are, which is... confusing.In post 748, Elena Fisher wrote:That was answering part of your question just because you don't get an answer you're happy with doesn't mean it's a dodge. I think he's wrong on the scumread because I think there town use common sense it's not a hard thing to fill in the blanksIn post 746, Sesq wrote:This isn't actually answering the question.In post 744, Elena Fisher wrote:Someone who is doing wrong but believes there in the right is without a doubt one of the most scary things
What is it with people and dodging questions