Newbie 1910: Aerial Photography [Game Over!]

[GrandWazoo]

but you first have to believe that scum townread both TW and Junk,

could you clarify this please

Bad word choice, by townread I meant "most threatening to scum."

[GrandWazoo]

IOW scum would have to believe Junk had a PR worth blocking. I think they NK'd TW because he was IC and was scumreading Junk's predecessor already.

[u r a person 2]

Just to clarify, I'm scum reading Junk

But I'm still confused.

In the world where Junk is the doctor, don't you think scum believed his D1 doctor claim?

[GrandWazoo]

Yes. But then why not NK him? Unless they had a strong Cop vibe on TW, which I don't believe they did, or feared TW would continue to push that slot after Junk replaced.

[u r a person 2]

because in the world that junk is the doctor, we're in the first setup column. Scum wouldn't have known if there was a cop or a jail keeper, so they wouldn't risk having the jailkeeper save the claimed doctor.

instead, they would roleblock and kill outside

GW is town here. especially if you believe junk's claim

[YellowSnow]

now that Junk has ragequit, that leads me to believe he might be the type of player to fakeclaim doctor as scum.

VOTE: Junk

[YellowSnow]

I mean I really don't see a viable reason why he would have quit if he was town. No one was really voting for him.

[JunkoChan]

because in the world that junk is the doctor, we're in the first setup column. Scum wouldn't have known if there was a cop or a jail keeper, so they wouldn't risk having the jailkeeper save the claimed doctor.

instead, they would roleblock and kill outside

GW is town here. especially if you believe junk's claim

Couldn't find the post I was looking for. Maybe I'm missremembering

[JunkoChan]

missclicked before editing, could you elaborate on this URAP2?

"GW is town here specially if you believe junk's claim"

[GrandWazoo]

because in the world that junk is the doctor, we're in the first setup column. Scum wouldn't have known if there was a cop or a jail keeper, so they wouldn't risk having the jailkeeper save the claimed doctor.

Ok, you've got a good point there. But this just gets back to the other issue: If town!Junk he will be useless to us since he'll be RB'd every night. If scum!Junk he'll claim RB every night. Until he gets dead we'll never know which.

[YellowSnow]

Well townjunk still has his vote he wouldn't be useless.

[GrandWazoo]

But his PR would be. Town!Junk is effectively VT from here on out.

[YellowSnow]

You wouldn't lynch a VT because they are VT though. You only lynch Junk if you think he is scum(which I do).

[GrandWazoo]

Correct-a-mundo.

[u r a person 2]

missclicked before editing, could you elaborate on this URAP2?

"GW is town here specially if you believe junk's claim"

I'm not buying scum!GW and his partner correctly reading the setup chart and making the correct nk and rb and then coming into the thread and forcefully and repeatedly arguing his recent position on junk even through others discussion of this very point.

I'm also not buying that scum!GW acts this way in relation to his partner scum!junk after having correctly made the fake claim.

So I wasn't thinking right when I said "especially if you believe junk's claim" because I just think GW is town here regardless.

[u r a person 2]

What is the case against GW again?

[YellowSnow]

BH is white knighting him.

[brassherald]

BH is white knighting him.

Only I'm not, I haven't mentioned the dude in a while.

But, I do think its fucking weird that you scum read GrandWazoo because I'm WKing him, so the main read is apparently on me, but what? You're too scared to vote me, you decide to vote the secondary extension scum read?

This makes no sense. I think Junk is right here.

VOTE: YellowSnow

[YellowSnow]

I'm not obligated to vote you. It's called having more than one scum read and the only ones attacking me are OMGUSers. So that means absolutely nothing. The fact that you're not denying white knighting GW speaks volumes as well.

[YellowSnow]

Scum is in GL/Junk/BH for sure.

[brassherald]

I'm not obligated to vote you. It's called having more than one scum read and the only ones attacking me are OMGUSers. So that means absolutely nothing. The fact that you're not denying white knighting GW speaks volumes as well.

BH is white knighting him.

Only I'm not, I haven't mentioned the dude in a while.

Emphasis added and the rest removed.

Let me explain this to you simply. You have a SR on me. Let's call me Patient 0 here. I'll say I'm infected according to you.

You infer, through my interactions with GW, which are wrong and denied twice now, that GW is scum. So, I supposedly infect GW in your eyes.

So, if your entire case on GW is that I'm scum and GW is my partner through interactions, the only logical way to approach it is to find out my alignment, not GW's.

Because, and here's the best thing, when I flip town, your entire "case" on GW falls apart, so, a town player would then decide to remove me first, because if Patient 0 is not actually infected, then GW would not be infected, right?

Yet, you are voting GW. So, really, the logical explanation is that you are voting the infected rather than the Patient 0 in this scenario because my green flip will eliminate GW from your fake scum pool tomorrow, but his will not eliminate me from your scum pool. The order of lynching here is so you can argue for a second mislynch.

[brassherald]

Oh, shit, I should have used vampires instead of AIDs patients. Vampire biting would have been so much better!

[YellowSnow]

I'm actually voting GL not WH.

[YellowSnow]

You're entire townBH argument is that you will flip green and we'll be sorry.

[northsidegal]

-