Supernatural mafia - Mafia team wins!!!!!

[Benmage]

Haha. You just don't want me to kill you in OMGUS-rage. Don't worry, I'm not an idiot.

But now there's a high chance I might be blocked or redirected tonight if not

killed outright.

You being killed at night instead of lynched if town is better than a simple mislynch. SO embrace it, plus your kill unless blocked would go through.

[ReaperCharlie]

*mentally resigns himself to his fate*

*makes a mental note to take down farside with him, like in Star Wars Mafia*

[Nero Cain]

Ultimitly I'm gonna buy Reapers claim 'cause Bobby is a big part of the show and if he were lying wouldn't the real Bobby come forward?

That's not right. That process doesn't make sense to me. What would we gain from outting the actual power role?

Alright, okay

HUNT: NERO CAIN

for pretty much saying: "No, Reaper's clear, unless the real guy wants to step up and put himself on the line."

None of this stuff is really making sense to me right now; usually we learn people's alignments when they die.

There is so much wrong with this. First of all, if we went ahead and lynched him it'll be DAYS before we see him flip so its not like we'd know if it was a mislynch. I get it, you don't buy Reaper's claim so why are you voting for me when its HIS claim you don't buy? MEH. Is this what you guys call chainsaw defense?

[TheLonging]

I still stand by my tubby vote, but I'd have no problems with a ani or LMP lynch.

BTW, I think I didn't answer this back then, but RC just gives out town vibes to me. It may not be 100% pro-town, but it sure as hell ain't that scummy (most of the time not even scummy).

Oh and congrats RC

[ReaperCharlie]

Benmage for some reason my browser is not letting me reply by PM. Not sure what's wrong but it's been happening for a few weeks on this comp.

We named her Ariel Genevieve. My wife picked out Ariel (it means 'lioness of God' in Hebrew) and I picked out Genevieve (it sounds very pretty and sophisticated).

And thanks TL

[Lowell]

prod avoidance. If we can't get a majority for RC then we need to come up with an alternative because we're a bit stuck.

[TheLonging]

prod avoidance. If we can't get a majority for RC then we need to come up with an alternative because we're a bit stuck.

tubby
ani

Those two, take your pick.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

@Ythan: You've been awfully quiet recently. Who are your suspects and why?

@TheLonging: Tubby216 and animorpherv1 are good lynch candidates and all, but I think the best lynch candidate for ToDay is Midnight's Sorrow. He already has two votes on him, why isn't he a viable lynch candidate?

[animorpherv1]

It was because she was making no sense. I interperetted it as trying to mislead the town. Otherwise, I just started actually paying enough attention to start getting reads about then.

Since you said you're starting to gain reads around the time you voted Midnight's Sorrow, do you have any scum reads? Additionally, are you still suspicious of Midnight's Sorrow?

To put it this way I'm suspicious of

everyone

untill I am proven otherwise.

Also, with farside's most recent post, mayb there is a Forensic Cop. Just a thought. Link is a wiki link.

[Lowell]

Fine.

unvote, vote tubby

[SpyreX]

I'd let RC walk the gallows before I let MS today. However, again, neither of those are a good idea at the moment.

The kitten defense doesn't give me those not lynching feelings and call me a skeptic but seeing the "well, I like an ani lynch but WOOOSH" in other directions as one of those classic "bullets go here" when ani flips scum.

[ReaperCharlie]

Fine.

unvote, vote tubby

yooooo! common sense rocks.

but I still have yet to see you add much to the topic.

[TheLonging]

Well I wouldn't be surprised ani. Also ani I can't see how that would work out, being suspicious of everyone.

SSBF: I have a slight town read on MS.

[ReaperCharlie]

I just ISO'd farside (page 2 only), and my initial reaction was "huh?"... here's why.

Tubbyscum wagon grows (led by me, a shining bastion of pro-town awesomeness).

Suspicion (track results) get thrown on me by possible-tubby-co-conspirator Magna.

SIX VOTES get thrown on me magically (begun by Tubbyscum).

Tubby unvotes as soon as it seems the pressure is off him...



Yeah, that seems pretty biased, but that's the way I am seeing it.

And that is why my vote is still on Tubby and will likely not leave.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

To put it this way I'm suspicious of everyone untill I am proven otherwise.

In that case, here's a better question. Who are your top suspects and why? Name at least two.

[animorpherv1]

I'm just digging myself farther into this neat little hole, ain't I?

SSBF:

I have nothing solid yet

@TheLonging:

You've never met anyone who considers all players scum untill they get some town reads?

[Sawyer]

I'm just digging myself farther into this neat little hole, ain't I?

SSBF:

I have nothing solid yet

You know who're digging yourself farther into a hole and yet you continue to say you have nothing solid yet. It's been almost 40 pages, so I fail to see how any town player has no top suspect(s).

[Nero Cain]

I'm just digging myself farther into this neat little hole, ain't I?

SSBF:

I have nothing solid yet

@TheLonging:

You've never met anyone who considers all players scum untill they get some town reads?

Its page 38 on day 2 and you have nothing?!? Even my noob ass posts his opinions.

[TheLonging]

ani: No, as they seem to be stuck on calling most people scum (from experience). Yes be suspicious of everyone, but don't assume everyone is one giant scum team but you.

In about 5 seconds my hunt will switch to ani.

[Kmd4390]

Hi. Not sure if blaze said anything but the flavor in my role makes me think I may be a miller even though I'm not specifically told that.

Might be a few days before I have a chance to read up.

Let's see. Oh, spy is in this game. Spy, who should I vote?

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Its a fair point but then again Sam and Dean aren't squeaky clean either. Their main source of income is credit card scams. That's not exactly pro-town.

Yes but the difference between Sam/Dean and Zachariah is that Sam/Dean are the main protagonist of the story while Zachariah is more of an antagonistic character. That's enough to call even more bullshit on Midnight's Sorrow claim.

SSBF:

I have nothing solid yet

Considering that you're suspicious of everyone, this is absolutely ridiculous. How can you possibly not have any solid scum reads after 900 posts when I just replaced in yesterday and already have seven people I wouldn't mind lynching? Especially since you've been in the game from the very start?

I see no acceptable excuse for this. Litterally, none. You are not scum hunting, you are not taking part in the game, and your behavior has been very scummy. If not for Midnight's Sorrow being near-confirmed scum IMO, I would switch my hunt immediately.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Ok Magna, so you know flavor and MS doesn't. Yippee. I don't know any either. This proves nothing.

Yet more non-scum hunting fluff.

And there's no use trying to push my wagon there's obviously no steam because I'm obviously not scum.

If my play/claim didn't have SOME merit, I have no doubt I'd have been lynched by now. Right?

P.S. What case is there on me besides your mason buddy's tracker result?

Now that your buddies have WIFOMed it up you are feeling more confident,huh. But since you are SOOOO confident I think I’ll go back this weekend and see what I can find. Of course you know it’s much easier to make these kind of ‘bold’ statements when we have exactly one flip.

P.S – Being tracked to a corpse usually is a sign of scum, you know.

Suspicion (track results) get thrown on me by possible-tubby-co-conspirator Magna.

SIX VOTES get thrown on me magically (begun by Tubbyscum).

I love the part where you forget to leave out that you admit to taking a Night action against Mole. So you are attempting to slime me as scum for publicly outing the correct track result on you. Which you admitted to. Yes, the grand conspiracy to out the accurate results of Sam's track on you

And votes to tend to fly to the person who ADMITTED TO BEING TRACKED TO A DEAD GUY.

Though I can see how you and others don't think I'm scum hunting since I don't agree with most of the big suspects you've all had (one of which I was already proven right about).

Nice straw-man here. I never mentioned you were not scum-hunting because you didn’t agree with my suspects. I said you were not scum-hunting because you spend all your time attacking other’s cases. But please, other than their attacks on RC, illustrate how Benmage and LMP are scum? I’d really like to see an actual case and not what amounts to ‘gut’.

Spy is right about RC.

If he can prove himself with a kill, that would be optimal.

So you know RC is Town because you are scum? Thanks for the insight.

And as stated before RC claiming a kill tonight proves that he can kill. Which ONCE AGAIN proves nothing of his alignment.

This is why I asked weather angels were third party or what would they be. And with 3 nk's last night an angel group could account for the third kill. (A demon group, angel group and then a town vig.) Zachariah is an angel? At the very least MS should get a FOS.

So you are postulating that Angels are a third party / non-Town group. MS has claimed a member of that group. But instead you vote for a lurker? Scummy.

FOS- Nero.

I’d hunt you but I’m already on said Angel.

Further we'll have a handful of results and

mole not being VT

is damning in and of itself.

Did I miss where mole flipped and it wasn’t VT? Otherwise this doesn’t necessarily look good Mr. Reaper is Town.

[Ythan]

Dense thread. Needs a good ISOing on my part.

[Nero Cain]

Its a fair point but then again Sam and Dean aren't squeaky clean either. Their main source of income is credit card scams. That's not exactly pro-town.

Yes but the difference between Sam/Dean and Zachariah is that Sam/Dean are the main protagonist of the story while Zachariah is more of an antagonistic character. That's enough to call even more bullshit on Midnight's Sorrow claim.

That part was a joke. Its not like I consider Sam/Dean scummy.

Also unhunt hunt: Ani

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Thats easy ben.

We already have three kill flavors. Slashed, Shot, and turned to ash.

If there's a different one from these three, we'll know. Or two different ones, in the case of scum choosing a different person to send in the kill(Cause theme games usually have scum members with different MOs) to confuse the issue.

Of course, it would really help to know who got what done to them when they flip, so we have some kind of clue in that direction.

ok so where are these kill flavors of wich you speak??

In the post that has the three deaths in it.