Open 397: Pick Your Poison! Game Over!

[Om of the Nom]

Blargh

[TheFool]

Presumably that means glowball-scum.

Honestly, I can't feel too bad about this. You played a good game, glowball.

[Om of the Nom]

Oh well, gg glowball. You genuinely had me fooled.

I am dissapointed in my play this game :P

[drmyshotgun]

why are you so concerned with what PRs we would choose?

How is that helping you scumhunt? This whole thing is bad. No matter how you phrase the question the purpose is the same and it does town as whole no good to sit down and hypo which roles could've been picked. Honestly, this discussion seems more scum motivated than town motivated for the fact that scum want to talk about PRs they are fishing and if you aren't fishing and if you are town then just stop. Well, no do whatever you want to do. Maybe someone else wants to answer but I'm sitting this one out....

[Om of the Nom]

Although I actually kinda did have this super duper slight gut feeling about glowy-scum.
Which I guess means my gut was right again.

PEDIT: omg, how could I have not seen that.

[Om of the Nom]

Gunny why didn't you point that out earlier?

[TheFool]

Should've unvoted in 920, Om, 919 should indicate town-Fool to you.

glowball, why Kass over LS?

[glowball]

actually that quote is taken out of context. Drmyshotgun asked "if you were scum which PR would you have chosen?" so when I said we I genuinely meant us a whole but thanks anyway.

[drmyshotgun]

Noticed it when I died. QQ
Plus, TheFool posted without hammering you Om, that should have been the que.

[drmyshotgun]

actually that quote is taken out of context. Drmyshotgun asked "if you were scum which PR would you have chosen?" so when I said we I genuinely meant us a whole but thanks anyway.

Oh yeah *Scratches his head*

[Om of the Nom]

Yeah, by the time I realized he didn't hammer it was too late.

[Om of the Nom]

Willing to bet glowwy chose Kass over LS to maybe try and incriminate me.

[glowball]

Should've unvoted in 920, Om, 919 should indicate town-Fool to you.

glowball, why Kass over LS?

LastSurvivor wasn't a threat. He used his ability and I picked up on the same soft claim Om did. Kass virtually outed himself if he hadn't LS would have probably died instead.

actually that quote is taken out of context. Drmyshotgun asked "if you were scum which PR would you have chosen?" so when I said we I genuinely meant us a whole but thanks anyway.

Oh yeah *Scratches his head*

I just said I'm not fishing.

Just put yourself in Mafia's shoes.
Who do you wanna pick? One shot Cop? Jailkeeper? Innocent Child?

[glowball]

Really I knew LastSurvivor thought I was town and that could only work in my favor. When Kass soft claimed and then accused me he had to die.

[Om of the Nom]

The softclaim was actually really obvious and I'm surprised you guys didn't pick up on it sooner.

[drmyshotgun]

Sigh, nicely played Glowball. You are on another level from your partners.
You guys were too quick in every lynches you made. Thomith's death was the most tragic.

[glowball]

Especially when you consider that among all of the people who soft claimed vanilla. If I was town I would have been so pissed at you guys. You basically killed yourselves by constantly talking about PRs it was easy to tell who was just a townie.

[TheFool]

Really I knew LastSurvivor thought I was town and that could only work in my favor. When Kass soft claimed and then accused me he had to die.

Ah, makes sense. Get rid of the loose cannon first.

Especially when you consider that among all of the people who soft claimed vanilla. If I was town I would have been so pissed at you guys. You basically killed yourselves by constantly talking about PRs it was easy to tell who was just a townie.

I was probably guilty of it myself at some point, but seriously, town in this game needed to learn that telling the vig who to shoot makes it more obvious that you're not the vig.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Flips after work.

[Om of the Nom]

I claim super secret SK.

HAHAHAHAHAHHA I SECRETLY WON BITCHES.

[glowball]

Really I knew LastSurvivor thought I was town and that could only work in my favor. When Kass soft claimed and then accused me he had to die.

Ah, makes sense. Get rid of the loose cannon first.

Especially when you consider that among all of the people who soft claimed vanilla. If I was town I would have been so pissed at you guys. You basically killed yourselves by constantly talking about PRs it was easy to tell who was just a townie.

I was probably guilty of it myself at some point, but seriously, town in this game needed to learn that telling the vig who to shoot makes it more obvious that you're not the vig.

There's a way to do this without fully outing yourself. It's called hypo claiming/vigging. It requires every single player to list who they would want the vig to shoot during the night this way the vig participates and since everyone is doing it you can't read too much into it. There's a way to talk about PRs but a townies job, which I think you guys missed, really is to be the shield for the PRs stop trying to save yourself. Scumhunt and try not to give away too much about yourself. Scum already have an advantage of information you are just giving them more. Drmyshotgun's innocent child claim was the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen though. I'm happy he did it because I was scum and I killed him before it could be dangerous but that could have changed this whole game if he just kept his mouth shut he wasn't even about to be lynched.

[BK201]

I wish I remembered that mafia picks our roles, thus claiming to save yourself as T&P did should have resulted in his lynch anyways. Since there can be no counter-claim to a role you didn't put in the game.

Was fun though, gg.

[BK201]

Dead thread
http://www.quicktopic.com/47/H/6dbRhpejRVZf

[drmyshotgun]

So it's my fault that the Town lost?
The Cop outed himself, and that turned the tables against T&P.
You were just stapled as Town in people's minds. I'd say I contributed.

[glowball]

Tbh we probably still wouldn't have lynched him although he was destined to die sooner or later. Just know that if scum fake claiims in an Open game they'll die before end game like 99% of the time it's too easy to figure it out.