Peabody wrote:Really quick random question: Is Suffer really going to be replaced? Bahh. I hate that this thread isn't massively active.
I certainly hope not. I haven't been the most active person here by far, but I am here.
AlmasterGM wrote:Seriously, if we could just lynch Flareonage, this game could get rolling.
This.
Flareonage, I don't know how you expect people to think you're town when the extent of your cases on anybody now is a feeble appeal to emotion on AlmasterGM for supposedly tunneling on you. Read through the game and provide some analysis of each player.
As for the case on Peabody, it seems like the crux of why he's suspicious is that he jumps on to the Raskol wagon that Flareonage started without giving reasoning and without voicing suspicion of Raskol previously. After looking it over, I'm just not seeing it as scummy.
He jumped onto a bad bandwagon early on providing no reasoning. There are three possible scenarios: Peabody is scum and Raskol is town, Peabody is scum and Raskol is scum, or Peabody is town and is unaware of Raskol's alignment. The first makes absolutely zero sense to me. If he was trying to push a townie lynch, he scores in the negative for effort. Bad case, and he jumps on early providing no additional information to sway other people to vote for Raskol. The second scenario is more interesting. If Peabody thinks the wagon will fail, he could jump on it, knowing it wouldn't really put Raskol in danger, with the added effect of distancing themselves from each other. The third scenario looks the most likely to me. He wanted to add pressure to Raskol, saw a vote on him, and joined in on it.
