Time Travel Mafia (Game Over)

[Kcdaspot]

ISO on EXE:

1: AMRUN IS SCUM LOLRVSLOL
2: LOL @KCDA AMRUN IS STILL SCUM.
3 and 4: fluff and fluff
5: questions and fluff
6: KCDA IS SCUM.

do you see the progression here? because i don't.

[GhostWriter]

What I don't see is the alleged buddying.

[Kcdaspot]

see 2.

[Kcdaspot]

if that joke was as shady as amrun says it is why didn't EXE react in the same way?

[GhostWriter]

I went back to read it in context. That isn't buddying. You made a reference, he recognized it BEFORE MOST OF THE PLAYERS HAD CONFIRMED IN A 'CONFIRM IN THREAD' GAME.

[GhostWriter]

Oh, he was supposed to take it the same way Amrun did despite getting the reference? You're grasping.

[Kcdaspot]

.... you're acting like i'm 100% positive...

read more. i put a FOmS: finger of minor suspicion on him.

Do think he is absolute scum? no.

do i think he shady? yes.

sooo... what am I grasping on?

[Kcdaspot]

srsly supercool chainsaw brah

[GreyICE]

Ranger of the North. Page 4. Bookmark it.

[GhostWriter]

I'm attacking you for a shoddy OMGUS, and you've desolved into calling it chainsawing. You're not grasping, this is closer to flailing. Your vote/FomS/whatever was based on him pointing at you. Nothing more, it would seem.

[Kcdaspot]

*shrugs*

w/e

page 5 and no one else commenting on things. i'd have a better read but this game needs activity.

I'd like to hear more from smargret, RC, DB9 and the others.

I'm probably not gonna end up with the slight scum read I have on exe currently.

plenty of game to go.

[Kcdaspot]

append to the 2nd to last phrase: at the end of the day phase.

[Kcdaspot]

the RC town read came from his quote striping post.

he paying attention and asking questions.

[Amrun]

Doombunny: it is true that no town member would make the joke if he/she thought about the implications.

I am forced to consider the idea that kcda just didn't think about it, esp with his more recent posts.

At present, that joke was still the shadiest thing to happen all game and I'll stick with my FoS on himM

[RedCoyote]

That no one gets Doctor Who references.

You know what? I actually can accept this. 99% of the time I'm a big supporter of the "you can't explain a joke" philosophy, but I guess this is one of the few exceptions to that rule. I don't watch the show, but I know enough about it to understand the joke here now. I hereby retract my criticism.

---

1. As soon as deadline of a day hits, the game enters nomination phase.

Sorry to be a stickler about this, Mod, but I'm still confused. Even if we vote not to lynch, we'll still go into the nomination phase as usual? I just don't quite understand. If you can elaborate, what would happen in such a scenario? Would there still be a lynch phase?

I understand all the other clarifications though. Thanks.

---

Exe...

Did you not finish this sentence?

---

Joking=scum? What is this I don't even...

Well, Amrun is not looking to hot right now. She just admitted that she understood Kcda's joke, but in the quote you just pointed out, it doesn't seem like she does. I don't know, if she would've got the reference, why wouldn't she have just brought it up earlier with something like, "So, I take it this is a Doctor Who joke, Kcda? You know, that's not funny, seriously. That's not a thing to joke about".

Obviously not verbatim, but something along those lines.

[Amrun]

I didn't get it immediately but I eventually figured it out.

I knew it was some sort of joke, but that means nothing to what I am actually saying, if anyone would care to actually read it.

[RedCoyote]

Well, obviously he wasn't being serious.

I don't think you're being completely honest with us, Amrun.

First you say you had to read the rules over multiple times, then you criticized Grey for clarifying the rules.
Then you say you understood the Doctor Who reference before Kcda brought it up, but, when pressed, you now just admitted you "didn't get it immediately, but eventually figured it out".

[Amrun]

I figured it out before he brought it up, obviously...

And when did I criticize grey for clarifying the rules...?

I have read the rules several times, but to fiz them in my memory will take awhile.

[RedCoyote]

I didn't get the reference, but that's what I'm saying. You're being vague for no reason. Okay, look, here's a timeline:

Kcda: I'm the doctor.
Amrun: Rolefish!
Kcda: Lol, just messing around.
Amrun: Nope. Vote to lynch.
Amrun: Kcda's joke was anti-town and definitely uncalled for.
RC: Uh, Kcda, this joke crap... explain it.
Kcda: ...it's a Doctor Who reference.
Amrun: I got that part but you still didn't need to joke about your role.
Doombunny: Eh? Amrun, what?
Amrun: Learn to read, Doombunny. What Kcda did was scummy.
RC: So, wait, Amrun, did you know about the reference or not?
Amrun: I got it, but not immediately.

Something's not right here. You're not being upfront.

And you criticized Grey here. I say Grey because he took point about going easy on the voting to move to the next phase, but you kind of give us all a bratty attitude about that.

[GhostWriter]

Look, I'd like a post, by Amrun, that concisely explains to me why that specifically was scummy.

[GreyICE]

Lemme help everyone else out.

Ranger of the North is scum.

WTF is this town-on-town shit?

[Amrun]

RC: it took me a COUPLE OF MINUTES to get the joke. There was considerably more time between that and the post you're bawwing about.

Ghostwriter: Why can't you just iso me? I have already explained it. By saying he is some sort of doctor (because someone with the namclaim of doctor would likely also have a doctor role) he has told everyone, including scum, that he is NOT the doctor, because no real dopctor would do that. Scum often go doctor-hunting, and now they know that kcda isn't a doctor.

Additionally, he could have been fishing for a counterclaim even if a doctor would be dumb to CC.

I think those were his intentions and he purposefully cloaked it in a joke.

Why is this so difficult to understand after I have previously spelled it out?

[GreyICE]

Because you're wrong, and kcdaspot is town

NYAH!

[Amrun]

Also, Grey, please elaborate on ranger.

P-edit: he could be. But it was a scummy thing to do. I'm not totally sold on kcda-scum, but that action itself was scummy. Period.

[GreyICE]

I do think we should avoid lynching until we have someone we want to lynch. That means random voting is probably not a great idea.

I'm fairly suspicious of Amrun and KCD who apparently read the rules, but are still ok with going to the nomination phase this early in the game.

Have you read the rules, Tragedy?
Nominations are submitted by PM to the mod.

Maybe that's what you're talking about, but that clearly wasn't what Mist was talking about

ME: Insert Obligatory Refusal To Answer Pointless Questions Here
GROUP A: Vote: Ranger for refusing to answer pointless questions
GROUP B: Vote: Group A for thinking not answering questions is scummy

There, now that's done with. Can we get on with the game now?

I just quoted you all his posts.

In order.

So yeah.