NY 142: Rolling in the Deep, WAIT WAT? PARTY OVER?!

[vijay2vasandani]

Gonna assume you were jked then. Also explains the lack of a third kill

@ pine: rev is cop confirmed innocent.

I think that makes sorgster more likely to be scum. But I could wrong. Just don't ask me why.

[Beck]

Funkybike was a good kill, though surprisingly in error. It should not be a surprise, as many, probably most of us have expressed strong suspicion of him in the past.

Mods: You gave an affiliation flip on TheAm. May I ask that you clarify Pop's affiliation in the same way?

Multiple players have asked about this. Rest assured, it is on our radar and will be addressed. Thanks. -DY

Haven't decided who to vote for. Leaning towards Rev again, or maybe sorgster.

Beck, what do you think my alignment is? I'm simply curious at this point, because the degree to which you're tunnelled on me seems to be impairing your ability to see reason, or really even do much else.

I think your alignment is "not town" which is good enough for me.

your play has been extremely bad this game and just cause you can write your own flavor doesn't mean you are clear, like you think it does.

what reason should I be seeing anyway? right now I have to take your word you aren't scum, sorry your word isn't a good "reason" to believe you

I look at the evidence in front of me and there is no way you actions are pro-town

[Beck]

I'm lynching pine for the following reasons.

1. I beleive amateur when he says pine is bulletproof scum
2. He thinks he is clear cause he can write his own flavor
3. We have only had 2 kills each night, never having 3 and it's confirned we have 2 bad guy groups
4. Pine said he would use the flavor of "LSD bear" and that didn't happen
5. The only kill with flavor was Funkybike, and if pine is claiming that kill, he killed an obvtownie

I'm sure I can provide more, but that's enough.

[Beck]

Are we ever going to know if pops was the same allignment as amateur or not?

[DrippingGoofball]

The last time Pine mentioned Funkybike.

NOVEMBER 1.

What do these numbers mean anyway?

Hiraki-7
Slandaar-6.5*
Vijay-6
Revenus-4
Pops-4
ScreamingHawk-4
Shattered Viewpoint-3
Ze1ink-3
ThAd-3
Zdenek-3
Soda/Toxic-3
Funkybike-3
Pine-2.5*
theamateur-2
Beck-2
Sword_of_omens/Maxous-2
Everyone Else-1**

*.5 due to Hiraki's Pine/Slandaar dichotomy
**Zelink willing to lynch anyone but himself.

Updated through 1996, does not include Toxic's ambiguous list.

[Beck]

@ DGB, are you posting false information on purpose? Pine mentions funky many times after the 1st of november. Even listing him as a scum read.

That list was some stupid thing pine was doing to guage who everyone thought was scummy.


@ pine, that funky kill was bad and you should know better. If you are town, shame on you.


Now, let's think about something here. If mafia does have a rolecop like amateur claimed and is telling the truth, clearly we need to lynch pine. However how much can you trust his story? Dying scum attempting to throw a townie under the bus is possible.

But let's assume this is true, and pine is really scum who can't be NK'd

How does the other mafia group cast doubt on him and get him lynched?

Would the rolecop fake claim cop or maybe even 1 shot cop and hope that gets him lynched?

TheAmateur came out of nowhere, if him and DGB were working together, amateur ruined dgb's gambit.

I think a good lynch today would be DGB, if he flips mafia with the same one as amateur, we know that pine is scum.

If he flips town, well than idk what we learn.

DGB's actions definitely seem scummy and he avoided the lynch of amateur.

This could be good.

vote: DGB

[Beck]

Not to mention, dgb's stunt forced the cop to CC.

[DrippingGoofball]

@ DGB, are you posting false information on purpose? Pine mentions funky many times after the 1st of november. Even listing him as a scum read.

Yeah I think I didn't notice he has a second page to his iso. I'll re-check.

[Beck]

Pine (6): theamatuer, Beck, DrippingGoofball, smargaret, sorgster, Maxous

^ just a reminder... that wagon was poison

this is one of those cases where thad's 3-5 analysis is likely to net scum.

and i don't care how many people say dgb is 'obvtown' - her play so far is atrocious and this 'lolgambit' doesn't make her town.

that's not to say there weren't scum also voting theam or not voting either, but that pine wagon was abominable and every townie on it should feel ashamed.

This post shouldn't be forgotten either. Just cause I'm advocating dgb, don't ignore that I wasn't the only one.

[DrippingGoofball]

Indeed.

...or good compromise lynches like sorgster, funkybike, or vijay.

His most recent evaluation of funkybike was "a good compromise lynch." I don't know why he's saying funkybike;'s town flip was surprising.

[Beck]

Compromise lynch means he would be ok with them cause they are scummy too. so you dont know why he was surprised he flipped town?

[DrippingGoofball]

Compromise lynch means he would be ok with them cause they are scummy too. so you dont know why he was surprised he flipped town?

Because he's soft-claiming funkybike as his NK target.

[Beck]

@ pine, what do you mean the funky kill was in error?

[Shattered Viewpoint]

I assume he meant there's a busdriver.

[Beck]

I assume he meant there's a busdriver.

Seriously? Can we let the man answer without people giving him ideas...

[DrippingGoofball]

I assume he meant there's a busdriver.

In a normal?

[sorgster]

Why did zelink claim inventor and that he gave pine bulletproof when he was a jailkeeper?

I'm pretty sure a jk is not normal I'll check that.

rev being town means I'm scum vijay? Are you saying this because I had attacked revenus earlier? I wasn't the only one to if I recall.

[sorgster]

EBWOP: Busdriver not jk.

[vijay2vasandani]

Why did zelink claim inventor and that he gave pine bulletproof when he was a jailkeeper?

I'm pretty sure a jk is not normal I'll check that.

rev being town means I'm scum vijay? Are you saying this because I had attacked revenus earlier? I wasn't the only one to if I recall.

Nope. I think I attacked rev as well before the result.

[sorgster]

so how does revenus being town make me scum? Makes no logical sense. You have also lurked your way after there was a bit of suspicion on you day 1.

[sorgster]

Are we ever going to know if pops was the same allignment as amateur or not?

Since they are shown the same colour they should be. Why are you thinking otherwise?

[Pine]

Gonna assume you were jked then. Also explains the lack of a third kill

@ pine: rev is cop confirmed innocent.

Thanks for the reminder. I knew there was a reason I'd wanted to hold back on him, but my laptop is broken and it's hard to scroll back in the archives on a phone at 4AM or whenever it was.

Beck...I'll deal with you when I have a laptop and can writte a wallpost about you.

DGB, dear, you're tunnelling so hard that you didn't even notice there's more than one page to my ISO. Shit, I even mentioned him on my short list of suspects near the end of the day.

I mentioned the Pulp Fiction quote after I decided LSD bear was too farfetched. It's in the thread.

Busdriver is definitely not Normal, Jailkeeper definitely is.

Vote: Sorgster

Case when I get home from work.

Funky's kill was "in error" because he surprisingly ended up being Town.

[Revenus]

I for one am curious how the cop lived the night with a doc down. Whatever. Lets get that scan.


And is Pine seriously claiming to be an infinite shot vig?

[Beck]

I've been infinite shot vig in a mini normal, so not to far fetched to have one in a large.

And pineypoo, I need good bathroom reading material, so I eagerly await your wall towards me.

[Beck]

And cop claimed RB'd, so that would explain him not dying.

The thing that bugs me is not knowing what mafia group the doctor is part of...

The fact the mods aren't releasing it, worries me.