- Best Mafia CatcherSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: MattP First: chkflip Second: mastin2
Nominated: AngryPidgeon First: mastin2 Second: Venmar
Nominated: Llamarble First: Empire Second: Human Destroyer
Nominated: F-16 Fighting Falcon First: Nachomamma8 Second: Nexus
- Nominated: MattP First: chkflip Second: mastin2
- Most Cunning ManipulatorSpoiler: Description
- First:
Nominated: AngryPidgeon First: mastin2 Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: Malakittens First: Ms Marangal Second: None
Nominated: Yates First: Aj the Epice Second: Human Destroyer
Nominated: Glork First: Oversoul Second: mikeburnfire
Nominated: JasonWazza First: mastin2 Second: penguin_alien
Nominated: Oversoul First: Human Destroyer Second: Cheery Dog
Nominated: Generic First: Alduskkel Second: N
Nominated: BROseidon First: Cabd Second: AngryPidgeon
Nominated: Lady Lambdadelta First: Matias Second: Cabd
Nominated: Matias First: Oversoul Second: None
Nominated: zMuffinMan First: Mac Second: Nachomamma8
Nominated: Penguin_Alien First: mastin2 Second: Arcangel9
Nominated: Katsuki for Don Corleone First: mastin2 Second: kuribo
Nominated: Nachomamma8 First: Varsoon Second: Nexus
Nominated: Cephrir First:Cabd Second: Nachomamma8
- First:
- Rising Star
Spoiler: Description- Nominated: Bumi First: Mehdi2277 Second: Sir Arthur Dayne
Nominated: AngryPidgeon First: mastin2 Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: ActionDan First: MattP Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: ArcAngel9 First: mastin2 Second: JacobSavage
Nominated: Empire First: Tierce Second: VoidedMafia
Nominated: Pieguyn First: mastin2 Second: Nachomamma8
Nominated: F-16 Fighting Falcon First: Nachomamma8 Second: Nexus
Nominated: Kagami First: Gedak Second: EspeciallytheLies
Nominated:Cabd First: BROseidon Second: Venmar
Nominated:fferyllt First: BROseidon Second: Venmar
Nominated:GuyinFreezer First: BROseidon Second: Nachomamma8
Nominated: BROseidon First: mastin2 Second: Nachomamma8
- Nominated: Bumi First: Mehdi2277 Second: Sir Arthur Dayne
- Best ReplacementSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Sanjay First: CheeryDog Second: Working Manju
Nominated: mikeburnfire First: Oversoul Second: mastin2
Nominated: qwints First: Angrypidgeon Second: Cabd
Nominated: Cabd First: Nachomamma8 Second: 1baldeagle1
Nominated: Magua First: Tierce Second: Faraday
- Nominated: Sanjay First: CheeryDog Second: Working Manju
- Best ICSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Mastin2First: Pieguyn Second: Nachomamma8
Nominated:Thor665First: Nachomamma8 Second: notscience
- Nominated:
- Funniest or Most Enjoyable PlayerSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Vifam First: Sanjay Second: quadz08
Nominated: Faraday First: SleepyKrew Second: mastin2
Nominated: Varsoon First: Skullduggery Second: Does Bo Know
Nominated: zMuffinMan First: Faraday Second: Empire
Nominated: Tammy First: F-16 Fighting Falcon Second: Marquis
Nominated: Magua First: Tierce Second: Faraday
Nominated: Majiffy First: Venmar Second: Who
- Nominated: Vifam First: Sanjay Second: quadz08
- Best Performance Pro-Town TeamSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Town of Happy Tree Friends First: mastin2 Second: Tammy
Nominated: Town of Author Mafia First: HP Lovecraft Second: xReckonerX
Nominated: Town of Meta Playstyle Mafia First: VoidedMafia Second: Venmar
Nominated: Town of Storm of Songs First: xReckonerx Second: d3x
Nominated: Town of The Inheritance Cycle First: TracyLyn11 Second: guille2015
Nominated: Town of First Time Mafia First: mastin2 Second: Uberninja
Nominated: Town of /in-vitational 15 First: mastin2 Second: quadz08
Nominated: Town of State Farm Mafia First: Jake from State Farm Second: None
Nominated: Town of Micro 180 First: bacde Second: mastin2
Nominated: Town of WWE Shield Mafia First: mastin2 Second: ferretlover
Nominated: Town of HunterXHunter Mafia: Yorknew City First: hitogoroshi Second: Empire
Nominated: Town of Perpetual Mylo First: Wickedestjr Second: Mr Flay
Nominated: Town of Xenogears Mafia First: mastin2 Second: fferyllt
Nominated: Town of Fire Emblem First: Natirasha Second: None
Nominated: Town of NY 166 First: Cabd Second: Marquis
Nominated: Open 512 First: Titus
- Nominated: Town of Happy Tree Friends First: mastin2 Second: Tammy
- Best Performance Scum GroupSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Mafia of Newbie 1329 First: Majiffy Second: Aj The Epic
Nominated: Scum of NY161 First: AngryPidgeon Second: mastin2
Nominated: The Simpsons Mafia First: qwints Second: Arcangel9
Nominated: Scum of Switch Mafia First: Ms Marangal Second: None
Nominated: Scum of You Could Be Anyone Mafia First: Oversoul Second: None
Nominated: Scum team of Calvin and Hobbes First: Varsoon Second: mastin2
Nominated: Scum Team of Pikmin Mafia First: mastin2 Second: none
Nominated: Scum team of Mini 1453 First: mastin2 Second: none
Nominated: The Scum team of Mini 1462 First: Mr Ree Second: serrapaldin
Nominated: Scum team of Antihero Reboot First: Antihero Second: Guyett
Nominated: Scum Team of Sabotage Mafia First: xRECKONERx Second: mastin2
Nominated: Scum team of Scummies Invitational First: Nachomamma8 Second: mastin2
- Nominated: Mafia of Newbie 1329 First: Majiffy Second: Aj The Epic
- Best Performance Third PartySpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Empking First: N Second: Chevre
Nominated: Penguin_Alien First: VoidedMafia Second: Malakittens
Nominated: Dripping Goofball First: xReckonerx Second: UntrodTripod
Nominated: Nuwen First: xReckonerx Second: Oversoul
Nominated: Empking First: Robbnva Second: chkflip
ToastyToast for Breaking Bad First: Venmar Second: Bacde
Bulbazak for Donner Party First: fferyllt Second: Nachomamma8
- Nominated: Empking First: N Second: Chevre
- Most Memorable EventSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Nachomamma8 for HEYYAAYAAE First: xReckonerx Second: UntrodTripod
Nominated: Quilford for Unvote: a complete history of my unvotes without revotes, first edition First: xReckonerx Second: Faraday
Nominated: Alduskkel for Freaking Out First: N Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: Channeldelibird for his video First: Generic Second Faraday
Nominated: xRECKONERx for his HAMMAH First: Amrun Second: none
Nominated: Mr Ree for his Claim in Mini 1462 First: serrapaldin Second: Doctorpepper
Nominated: Saki for his failed hammer First: Guyett Second: ferretlover
Nominated: Jake from State farm for his timely unvote First: Mr Flay Second: notscience
Nominated: Varsoon for quote changing! First: IceGuy Second: Does Bo Know
Nominated: Magua for use of his Ability First: Tierce Second: Matias
- Nominated: Nachomamma8 for HEYYAAYAAE First: xReckonerx Second: UntrodTripod
- Most Enjoyable Game- Awarded to Both Moderator and Players of a GameSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Gorrad and Players of Mafiastruck First: Sanjay Second: ActionDan
Nominated: Untrod Tripod and Players of Author Mafia First: Ser Arthur Dayne Second: xReckonerX
Nominated: PeregrineV and Players of The Agency First: Empking Second: saulres
Nominated: NY161 First: UberNinja Second: Aj the Epic
Nominated: /in-vitational 15 First: mastin2 Second: UberNinja
Nominated: Borkerkfin for Xenoblade Mafia First: pirate mollie Second: Cabd
Nominated: Borkjerkin for Xenogears Mafia First: mastin2 Second: fferyllt
Nominated: Antihero for Antihero REBOOT First: EspeciallytheLies Second: Jingle
Nominated: Magua for Marketplace 3 First: N Second: Mina
- Nominated: Gorrad and Players of Mafiastruck First: Sanjay Second: ActionDan
- Best SetupSpoiler: Description
-
Nominated: AngryPidgeon for Sabotage Mafia First: EspeciallyTheLies Second: Shos
Nominated: Nexus for Harry Potter First: Faraday Second: Penguin Alien
Nominated: OhGodMyLife for Mind Reader Mafia First: Nachomamma8 Second: mastin2
Meme Mafia First: Guyett
Meme Mafia 2 First: Guyett
The Walking Dead First: Thor665 Second: Cabd
-
- Best Role(new or adaptation)Spoiler: Description
- Nominated: David Bowie, Mod Mason First: Sanjay Second: None
Nominated: N for "Babysitter First: Nachomamma8 Second: Faraday
- Nominated: David Bowie, Mod Mason First: Sanjay Second: None
- Best Flavor TextSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Gorradd for Mafiastruck First: Sanjay Second: quadz08
Nominated: saulres for Zombie Attack! First: Rob13 Second: CheeryDog
Nominated: Zar for Welcome to Castle Zar First: Empire Second: Tammy
Nominated: Untrod Tripod for Author Mafia First: Ser Arthur Dayne Second: xReckonerX
Nominated: Sir Hercules Elton John (UT & Reck) for Gay Mafia II First: DrippingGoofball Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: Nachomamma8 for Terrible Music Mafia First: Human Destroyer Second: SoraAdvent
Nominated: killerjester for Playing with Fire First: mastin2 Second: Xalxe
Nominated: Breaking Bad Mafia First: Nexus Second: ToastyToast
Nominated: 4nxi3ty for The Tenements First: Zoidberg Second: ArcAngel9
Nominated: Venmar for Gears of War Mafia First: Rubicon Second: Mac
Nominated: Nexus for WWE Shield Mafia First: ferretlover Second: mastin2
Nominated: Ucitron00 for Open 507 First: Nachomamma8 Second: Saulres
Nominated: Borkjerkin for Xenogears Mafia First: Ghostlin Second: mastin2
Nominated: kanyeknowsbest for Fast and Fiurious First: Marquis Second: Natirasha
Nominated: mastin2 for Ny 164 First: CrashTextDummie Second: Oversoul
Nominated: Meme Mafia 2 First: Varsoon Second: notscience
- Nominated: Gorradd for Mafiastruck First: Sanjay Second: quadz08
- Best Mechanic/MutationSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: saulres for Micro 176 First: ArcAngel9 Second: AngryPidgeon
Nominated: AurorusVox for Paradox Prime Mafia First: pieceofpecanpie Second: mastin2
Nominated: Serrapaldin for Con Mafia First: kuribo Second: Voidedmafia
Cephrir for Fire Emblem First: Nachomamma8 Second: mastin2
Nominated: Meme Mafia 2 First: Varsoon Second: notscience
- Nominated: saulres for Micro 176 First: ArcAngel9 Second: AngryPidgeon
- Excellent Moderation
This is now a Body of Work awardSpoiler: Description- Nominated: Equinox First: EspeciallyTheLies Second: DoctorPepper
Nominated: borkerjerkfin First: fferyllt Second: Nachomamma8
Nominated: Magua First:Oversoul Second: Quilford
- Nominated: Equinox First: EspeciallyTheLies Second: DoctorPepper
- Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wikiSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: hitogoroshi First: mastin2 Second: fferyllt
Nominated: mastin2 First: Faraday, Second: chkflip
- Nominated: hitogoroshi First: mastin2 Second: fferyllt
- Behind the ScenesSpoiler: Description
- Outstanding MishMash GameSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Ether for Telephone Pictionary First: izakthegoomba Second: xReckonerx
Nominated: Sky Pillar First: Chevre Second: Cybele
Nominated: Pokemon RPG First: JasonWazza Second:
- Nominated: Ether for Telephone Pictionary First: izakthegoomba Second: xReckonerx
- The Community Contributor AwardSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: zoraster First: DrippingGoofball Second: AngryPidgeon
Nominated: Quilford First: quadz08 Second: Guy_Named_Riggs
Nominated: DrippingGoofball First: xRECKONERx Second: None
- Nominated: zoraster First: DrippingGoofball Second: AngryPidgeon
- In order to be considered by the scummy judging committee, a nomination must be seconded.
- Self-nominations are allowed. However, they are generally frowned upon, particularly where the sole winner will be the nominator. It is expected that Most Enjoyable Game will be a self-nomination
- Nominations with LINKS and descriptions of why you wish to nominate a player or group of players are greatly appreciated.
- Please boldwho you are nominating and for what award.
- Please note these are the preliminary categories for the 2013 season. There may be changes.