How two and a half friends banged your mother - Cancelled

[penguin_alien]

EBWOP: Aside from yourself, obviously.

I like Antagon, PP, and TD right now, myself of course. I can't give a fifth.

Peregrine is probscum too.

So that leaves chkflip, PeregrineV, Mac, Rubicon, Pilobolus, and me as scum by PoE, Your PoE has only eliminated one-third of the player list. And one of those three is confirmed by day actions.

Whether chkflip is town or scum role cop, he's marked Pilobolus as not a threat for today. The possibility of a tandem SK team gives us the hope that there are only three Mafia left. At the risk of descending into the pit of set-up spec, would scum have a Watcher and a Tracker? On a four-man scum team with a flipped Tracker, likely minimum one vanilla goon, and a very likely role cop, I don't see the team having a Watcher and a Tracker. Plus I still think scum-Rubicon would have covered his bases better than that.

I'll go with Antagon and Rubicon as town reads for now. Pilobolus is in today's do-not-lynch pile. I like TD's posting overall, and only that some of his agreement with me feels like buddying makes me leery of putting him as firm town.

chkflip seems like he has high chances of being scum. Town with a full cop and a role-cop? I do find it likely that he didn't fake his result on Mac. From what I've seen, scum get lots of mileage out of giving some honest town results. But I don't buy that Baby Spice didn't send in an action Night One. She was involved with the game, and if she was scum, she was likely active in the QT discussing who was a good choice to role-cop. Having played scum with her before, I don't buy that she flaked. More likely she investigated someone else who was town, and chkflip doesn't want to have to confirm multiple townies.

Oh, and here:

I see Rubiscum, not Pilo or Mac though.

Is the only mention of Pilobolus I find in chkflip's ISO before his claim today. Why sit on it for ten days? Seems more likely he was hoping to come up with that info tomorrow instead when killing Pilobolus would forestall his odd night kill. Could have just fingered Pilobolus as an SK then.

Recap: Pilobolus and chkflip as SK and Mafia scum respectively. Assume a teammate for Pilobolus and two for chkflip. PeregrineV, DGB, and Princess Proton are left. I don't love Princess Proton as a scum read. Not sure who I'd boot from the town list of Mac, Antagon, Rubicon, and TiphaineDeath. Probably Rubicon, push comes to shove, but I don't feel strongly enough to want him lynched today.

My lynch preference would be chkflip, followed by DGB.

[DrippingGoofball]

Whether chkflip is town or scum role cop, he's marked Pilobolus as not a threat for today.

More importantly, scum, he has marked him for a NK.

[DrippingGoofball]

Is the only mention of Pilobolus I find in chkflip's ISO before his claim today. Why sit on it for ten days? Seems more likely he was hoping to come up with that info tomorrow instead when killing Pilobolus would forestall his odd night kill. Could have just fingered Pilobolus as an SK then.

That is interesting.

[Pilobolus]

- Someone is faking info on me

WHAT EXACTLY are they faking?

In other words.... CLAIM TIME FOR YOU

READ MY SIG

He's faking that I have a role pm.

No he's faking the same thing I've said he's been faking for the past few days: I ain't no SK. As I said I'll claim if I must but not just because scum wants to fake info on me. If the sk thinks this means I have an important role they can come right the hell at me.

Is the only mention of Pilobolus I find in chkflip's ISO before his claim today. Why sit on it for ten days? Seems more likely he was hoping to come up with that info tomorrow instead when killing Pilobolus would forestall his odd night kill. Could have just fingered Pilobolus as an SK then.

That is interesting.

It is interesting and further proves he's full of it.

Christ why would scum have any need to keep this info to themselves if I was the sk? They're at a point where a not-them lynch basically means they've won. If he was planning on faking info from the beginning of day he would've done it right away to secure their last mislynch: sitting on it for 20 days and then besmirching jason's good name by saying he forgot for a month to send results just looks bad.

[PeregrineV]

Back from camping! Super stoked to find obvious scum waiting for me!

My night actions:
N1 - Yates - No one targeted Yates.

This is where Nero claimed he had investigated Yates on Night 1.

I'm Charlie Harper. Town JOAT. One of my powers allows me to check to see if a player has a quicktopic, I investigated Yates last night and he does so unless he's a mason, a nieghborizer or got nieghborizer/masonized then he's scum.

This is where Rubicon Watcher would have sided with Yates and called Nero a liar.

Nero claimed JOAT with a "QT investigation" power, and a positive result on Yates having a QT, which Yates denies. Some people think Nero is lying.

People are voting AA9 because obviously, since we have one player who fake claimed cop, and another player who claimed JOAT with a scum result on the player who fake claimed cop, the optimal play is to let them both live, and lynch a random lurker.

This was the wagon he was on after Nero's fake investigation when Rubicon fake investigated Yates as well.

Yates was Howard Wolowitz, Vanilla Town lynched Day 2

Woops. That was not as thought out as it could have been.

VOTE: Rubicon

Verified through ISOs. Which leaves us with new claims.

[PeregrineV]

EBWOP:

Vewified thwough ISOs. Which weaves us with new cwaims.

[PeregrineV]

Wubicon cwaims and then acts contwawy to cwaim.

As Wubicon is caught, chkfwip has “wesuwts” on Phiw that say he is SK. He awso cwaims wesuwts on Mac, which Mac confiwms, which incwudes awignment, making him bettew than a cop. This is stwongew than town cop, making me wean scum. Unwess Mac is awso scum, but don't want to go to faw down the WIFOM woad.

Sticking point is cwaiming Phiw is odd-night SK, which gives us the option to not feaw his kiww night4, when scum wouwd want SK wynched ovew one of theiw own, so why not just say he’s weguwaw SK?

[Princess Proton]

So we lynch Rubicon today and Chk tomorrow. And EVERYONE is happy.

[penguin_alien]

Wubicon cwaims and then acts contwawy to cwaim.

As Wubicon is caught, chkfwip has “wesuwts” on Phiw that say he is SK. He awso cwaims wesuwts on Mac, which Mac confiwms, which incwudes awignment, making him bettew than a cop. This is stwongew than town cop, making me wean scum. Unwess Mac is awso scum, but don't want to go to faw down the WIFOM woad.

Sticking point is cwaiming Phiw is odd-night SK, which gives us the option to not feaw his kiww night4, when scum wouwd want SK wynched ovew one of theiw own, so why not just say he’s weguwaw SK?

Off the top of my head, to gauge his reaction and that of others to narrow down his partner? Maybe he's really a full SK and they're setting up for tomorrow?

Do you think then that chkflip is intentionally distracting from Rubicon's error in a buddy way?

[PeregrineV]

Off the top of my head, to gauge his reaction and that of others to narrow down his partner? Maybe he's really a full SK and they're setting up for tomorrow?

Pawtnew: Then why out Piwo at aww? Why not kiww him?
Fuww SK: Then why name him an odd-night SK at aww? Without the extwa kiww, Piwo can wait, so not seeing scum motivation for that cwaim of odd-night if weawwy fuww. Unwess it was to distwact from Wubi.

Do you think then that chkflip is intentionally distracting from Rubicon's error in a buddy way?

I don't know, but it's stawting to wook wikewy. It's weally hawd to bewieve that Wubicon had that additionaw knowwedge as town but fowgot it whiwe "scumhunting". Wewe nowmawwy weduced to specuawtion based off the info we have, so not using info you WEAWWY posses is not wikewy. The onwy thing that stopped him from being wynched wight away was chkfwps cwaim.

[PeregrineV]

Town

PewegwineV
Antagon
Mac
Pwincess Pwoton
TiphaineDeath

The West

chkfwip- cwaimed rowecop
penguin_awien
DwippingGoofbaww
Wubicon-claimed watchew
Piwobowus- tagged as odd-night SK by chkfwip

Setup spec time
21 pwayers, nowmawwy 5 scum
Odd SK with qwints kill means even SK
This weaves mafiascum at 3-4, 5 if town is power heavy. Cuwwent town is dayvig, cop, doc. Cuwwent mafia is twacker. Don't feew town is powew heavy. Weaves 3-4 scum.
15:4:2 or 16:3:2 (smaww outside chance of 14:5:2)
means 4:4:2 or 5:3:2 (outside 3:5:2)

@Pwincess- how many mafia? who is even SK?

@Penguin- who is the even SK? how many mafia?

pedit: The post above, happened whiwe I was making this one.

[TiphaineDeath]

PV, one of the scum is dead, so your theory actually looks like.

5:3:2 or 6:2:2 (Outside 4:4:2)

Also, townslip.

[Yates]

@Pwincess- how many mafia? who is even SK?

I'm not keeping score. I just know that Rubicon and Chk are some flavor of scum.

[PeregrineV]

Rose (from 2 1/2 men) - Role Cop

N2 Spice chose Mac - who is Chandler Bing, town X (I shant reveal more, simply that he's cleared town)

N3 Spice chose Pilo - who is The Captain (George Van Smoot) Odd-Night SK

Chk is a rolecop at least, which side he is on is yet to be determined.

Yeah I believe chk.

ONE of TD or Mac is scum.

So you beweive him whiwe simuwataneouswy not bewieving him?

I don't think it is possibwe for someone to be as singularwy unhewpfuw as you've been not onwy aww game, but esp. at this criticaw point in the the game.

Vote: DGB

Alternate plan: Lynch DGB, and let the PRs PR.
Thoughts?

[PeregrineV]

EBWOP:

Rose (from 2 1/2 men) - Role Cop

N2 Spice chose Mac - who is Chandler Bing, town X (I shant reveal more, simply that he's cleared town)

N3 Spice chose Pilo - who is The Captain (George Van Smoot) Odd-Night SK

Chk is a rolecop at least, which side he is on is yet to be determined.

Yeah I believe chk.

ONE of TD or Mac is scum.

So you beweive him whiwe simuwataneouswy not bewieving him?

I don't think it is possibwe for someone to be as singularwy unhewpfuw as you've been not onwy aww game, but esp. at this criticaw point in the the game.

Vote: DGB

Alternate plan: Lynch DGB, and let the PRs PR.
Thoughts?

Vote: DGB

Awtewnate pwan: Wynch DGB, and wet the PWs PW.
Thoughts?

[PeregrineV]

PV, one of the scum is dead, so your theory actually looks like.

5:3:2 or 6:2:2 (Outside 4:4:2)

Also, townslip.

Thoughts on my town wist?
As for the west- most wikely to be town? Ow, IOW, who fwom the West shouwd be in the town piwe?

[Mac]

Princess could be even night SK. Cant see PP pushing her possible buddy Rubi so hard.

[penguin_alien]

@Pwincess- how many mafia? who is even SK?

I'm not keeping score. I just know that Rubicon and Chk are some flavor of scum.

...the hell?

PeregrineV, killing Pilobolus outright removes the chance for his partner to react to the reveal in addition to the eventual likely NK. I don't know who a likely partner is right now, but I'd assume a scum team that can narrow the options down to six (with three Mafia in play) vs. eight is closer. Knock one off both those assuming Mac is town as chkflip says.

[PeregrineV]

Princess could be even night SK. Cant see PP pushing her possible buddy Rubi so hard.

It's possibwe. My favowites fow it wewe Boniface/Penguin and Venmaw/Pwincess, but that's mostwy based on skimming.

[Pilobolus]

....Or the more likely possibility is that there is no even/odd night SK. Scum have 4 left which means if they got me mislynched today (which chkflip is still pushing for, if everyone he says is the truth why would he want the even/odd sk dead anyway over mafia right now) and with that last mislynch they've basically won.

Why would he not have pushed this lynch all along? And I'm not buying for a second that jason forgot his results.

Rubicon? Maybe scum maybe not and regardless, the real sk/scum can't take the chance of a watcher being around. I will say I could see that slip PP pointed out a more likely one to make as scum than town but would rather keep him around when there's confirmed mafia in chkflip.

[Rubicon]

Princess Proton - if you're a Yates alt, you should probably fess up now.

Everyone else: I'm a likely NK target one way or another, so I propose we not lynch me today.

[TiphaineDeath]

PV, I think the town is probably you/me/mac/Ant/PA. I might be wrong about PA here, if I am the fifth townie is probably Rubs. I am pretty confident on the other four though.

Whatever the case, CHK is the right play today.

On further consideration his claim, and results, on pilo at least, are probably true. He's just the scum rolecop, he slipped and called mac town, a town rolecop wouldn't know that. He probably investigated AJ night one, and thus the doctor was doomed.

A DGB lynch will still hit scum, but chk is better.

[Rubicon]

So we lynch Rubicon today and Chk tomorrow. And EVERYONE is happy.

@Pwincess- how many mafia? who is even SK?

I'm not keeping score. I just know that Rubicon and Chk are some flavor of scum.

Yates responds to a question directed at Princess Proton, and uses the same (kind of unusual) capitalization "Chk".

I deleted Yates post, and DGB reply to Yates. Yates accidently posted in this game, when meaning to post in another.

I could accept this the first time Yates posted here after being lynched, but I'm not in any of Yates' other games, so how does he have a scum read on me in one of them?

[TiphaineDeath]

Seriously.... compromised game?

Yates?

[PeregrineV]

PV, I think the town is probably you/me/mac/Ant/PA. I might be wrong about PA here, if I am the fifth townie is probably Rubs. I am pretty confident on the other four though.

Whatever the case, CHK is the right play today.

On further consideration his claim, and results, on pilo at least, are probably true. He's just the scum rolecop, he slipped and called mac town, a town rolecop wouldn't know that. He probably investigated AJ night one, and thus the doctor was doomed.

A DGB lynch will still hit scum, but chk is better.

::sigh::
Youw pwobabwy wight, but I want mowe out of the day, esp. fwom town-chkfwp and town-DGB.

Unvote.

Whewe is youw Pwincess Pwoton scumwead coming fwom? I feew 3717 is so exact because if you have inside info youw pway shouwd wefwect that inside info if you awe sincewewy twying to catch scum. "Fowgetting" youw wesuwts when posting and wesponding is awmost inconceivabwe.