Mini 1446, Generic Mafia (Game Over)

[JacobSavage]

Votecount 3.3

BeastCharizard [2]

- Fegelein, Palmar

Palmar [2]

- Bacde, Zhero

Infinity 324 [1]

- BeastCharizard

roflcopter [1]

- Infinity 324

Not Voting [2]

- roflcopter, T S O

With 8 alive, it takes

5

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2013-05-31 16:23:01)[/i][/area]

[Infinity 324]

Beast still remains the best lynch. Just because Horus called Beast obv-Town doesn't make him not scum. In fact, that's a WIFOM defence of Beast's actions, which is therefore a paradox, therefore equalling a null tell.

But that's what it felt like to me. ISO beast+ank+horus please

[roflcopter]

can we have everyone claim vig or not vig in their next post? not vig -

tso - not vig
rofl - not vig

[roflcopter]

Roflcopter has used bad logic throughout the game.

hey look a bold statement with absolutely no supporting evidence

[Infinity 324]

Not vig

Roflcopter has used bad logic throughout the game.

hey look a bold statement with absolutely no supporting evidence

Red toads = reaction test

I thought I actually had evidence to support it

I don't like this CES case and here's why: It makes no sense that you're calling out CES for the naked vote when he could have just been reacting to TSO's overreaction. I don't think it's scummy to appeal to scumhunting and not scumhunt if you're only using it as a towntell. The other linked post is a reasonable argument. Ad homs also aren't scummy.

Also your response is weird since you imply I'm scummy but don't say it.

Do you still think zhero is scum?

[roflcopter]

Also your response is weird since you imply I'm scummy but don't say it.

Do you still think zhero is scum?

check out my reads list to open this day for my current stance on zhero. and no i'm not implying you're scummy i'm implying that was a bad point.

tso - not vig
rofl - not vig
infinity - not vig

[Fegelein]

Beast still remains the best lynch. Just because Horus called Beast obv-Town doesn't make him not scum. In fact, that's a WIFOM defence of Beast's actions, which is therefore a paradox, therefore equalling a null tell.

But that's what it felt like to me. ISO beast+ank+horus please

I've had first hand experience of Beast being scum and fooling me in LYLO. It correlates with his current gameplay.

Also, I'll throw my hat in and say I am not Vigi.

[Infinity 324]

@Mod There are only 2 people not voting.

TSO, who do you think is scum?

rofl's above post looks really lazy & towny, especially since he ignored my entire argument.

@rofl Why did your read on zhero change? Is it because of horus? My case?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: palmar

[Infinity 324]

Fegel, I'd like links to beast's meta.

[JacobSavage]

Fixed, Thanks.

[Infinity 324]

Ok I iso'd Horus+Palmar+ank and I can't read palmar. He's been really weird this game, going from really wall-posty and explaining to really lazy. He could be trying to buddy me. Palmar, why specifically am I town?

Next up is fegel+horus+ank.

I feel like one of {fegelein, beastcharizard} are scum because meta/gut says fegel is town but beast is scum, but fegel is aligned with ank/horus while beast is not.

[Infinity 324]

A fegel+ank+horus team has things going for it, like fegel backing up horus's potential buddying of beast, but it doesn't

exactly

click into place. Hmm...this makes me more confident that either fegelein or beastcharizard is scum. I want those links, fegel.

Palmar or fegelein could be disinterested in the game because two of their scumbuddies are dead. Fegel appears suddenly reinterested, maybe because he has a chance of winning? I dunno, food for thought.

I'd be really surprised if scum was someone other than fegelein, beastcharizard, or palmar. I'm keeping my vote where it is until I get beast meta from fegel.

[T S O]

Hey, this is the scumgame of Beast.

http://pokemon-online.eu/forums/showthr ... pls/page10

I'm the partner of page 10 who came in and fakeclaimed. Still think my fakeclaim could have worked were it not for my cataclysmic mistake in not giving results. >_>
The guy who was the actual Cop, TIWSS, is possibly the best player I've ever played with in terms of not knowing his alignment. His town meta is the exact same as his Mafia one
Anyway, it went to LyLo and Fegelein (yeah, this current Mafia had 3 or 4 playing in that one) hammered the guy (braveswin) who I, when knowing I'd be lynched, breadcrumbed that he was Town, which when I flipped made him seem like my partner. Fun game.

[Palmar]

I'm at L-2 so it's 1 more vote and scum can hammer.

I'm JOAT. My abilities are Track, protect and roleblock

n1 I tracked Bacde. He visited ank.
n2 I protected infinity

[beastcharizard]

not vigi

That was sure a fun game and gosh is TIWSS a great player in that regard.

If palmar is telling the truth we should probably not lynch him. Just an idea.

TSO, why are you answering questions for Feg? You want me to get lynched that badly?

[T S O]

Well, the good news either Bacde or Palmar should be scum/SK, as Bacde has said he's not Vigi.
Bad news is now we have to 50/50.
Was Infinity targeted last night?

Oh Beast, where was I answering for Feg?

[Palmar]

as Bacde has said he's not Vigi.

oh I missed that.

[T S O]

actually I presumed that

let me check

[beastcharizard]

The whole giving the link to my awesome scum play when Feg was supposed to do it.

[Palmar]

eh, no he didn't. T S O... where did he say he's not a vigi?

[T S O]

TSO is town. Read his ISO and tell me that's noob scum.

Scum is in {palmar, Rofl, beast}.

Should we just massclaim? If there's an SK they will just claim vig and the info about whether there's a doc will help us determine if there's a vig or an SK.

If the vig claims, then yes we should massclaim

if not, then probably not, because that would indicate an SK OR that the vig doesn't want to out

the tone this is wrote in certainly suggests that he's not Vigi.

[T S O]

The whole giving the link to my awesome scum play when Feg was supposed to do it.

Well, it was just being helpful. I didn't say it was good or bad, I simply gave a link so Infinity could see it faster.

[Palmar]

TSO is town. Read his ISO and tell me that's noob scum.

Scum is in {palmar, Rofl, beast}.

Should we just massclaim? If there's an SK they will just claim vig and the info about whether there's a doc will help us determine if there's a vig or an SK.

If the vig claims, then yes we should massclaim

if not, then probably not, because that would indicate an SK OR that the vig doesn't want to out

the tone this is wrote in certainly suggests that he's not Vigi.

The tone suggests that he may be a vig that doesn't want to out, he even mentions that possibility

[roflcopter]

good news everyone i just won us the game

i am an even night watcher and last night palmar visited

bacde

so palmar is the last scum and bacde is a kill immune serial killer

you're welcome

unvote, vote: palmar

[roflcopter]

(also palmar could successfully claim that bacde visited ank because he knew bacde was sk as soon as the kill on him didn't go through)