NY 166: Knight-Errant 18p - Game Over!

[Matias]

Fair enough.

Waiting on others

[The Knight-Errant]

Vote Count 4.6

KX (4) - Evil Regals, Shattered Viewpoint, Metal Sonic, Matias
notscience (1) - zMuffinMan

Not Voting (6) - dopog, notscience, Marquis, meeps, KX, CrashTextDummie

Countdown:
(expired on 2013-10-03 15:00:00)

11 alive, 6 to lynch.

[dopog]

js I still think eddie KNEW beast was scum

Will catch up with new stuff later today.

Bye!

[meeps]

school sux sorry for inactivity

i'll post more in a bit

[Evil Regals]

I already think my pick for the final scum is also Dopoq or Marquis.

SV, MS, NS are really town in my opinion.

Meeps I don't like, but I'm kinda unsure on her. Part of me thinks the Feg N1 kill was drawn from someone whom he played with on another site.

Matias & CTD have been giving me good feels since they replaced in. ZMuffinMan kinda bounced off my reads list, but I want to keep an eye on him.

KX is most certainly scum whether or not it be via SK or mafia. He's not in a townwincondition.

[meeps]

im a guy js

[meeps]

ok kx is probably not mafia considering he participated in both mafia lynches so sk is fairly plausible

post 829 kinda irks me as it seems he does not really care who is lynched, and he accuses sv and notscience (with sv being confirmed town now and notscience being a town read of mine).

a thing to keep in mind with dopog is he did hammer hd. considering there is no plurality, mafia hammering their own teammate would be a fairly risky play, and marquis was also 2nd last to vote

anyways, not sure if i mentioned this and cba to look back but i did look through eddie's previously played games, and his scumplay really stood out from his town play, so his slot is prob town, along with ctd's play he is extremely strong town

right now i feel other scum may be zmuffinman or matias, i'll look over the play of who them so far and who've they subbed in to later

[The Knight-Errant]

I'm going to be V/LA for the 19th and 20th, and I believe Venmar's out of town too, so vote counts might be a bit slow. Activity seems fine right now though, so delayed prods shouldn't be an issue.

[Matias]

Okay, I still need to hear from Metal Sonic, SV and notscience. I read CTD as he replaced in as well.

[Evil Regals]

ok kx is probably not mafia considering he participated in both mafia lynches so sk is fairly plausible

post 829 kinda irks me as it seems he does not really care who is lynched, and he accuses sv and notscience (with sv being confirmed town now and notscience being a town read of mine).

a thing to keep in mind with dopog is he did hammer hd. considering there is no plurality, mafia hammering their own teammate would be a fairly risky play, and marquis was also 2nd last to vote

anyways, not sure if i mentioned this and cba to look back but i did look through eddie's previously played games, and his scumplay really stood out from his town play, so his slot is prob town, along with ctd's play he is extremely strong town

right now i feel other scum may be zmuffinman or matias, i'll look over the play of who them so far and who've they subbed in to later

I disagree. Mafia can always bus for some type of cred. Dopoq is barely posting and he's posting to what seems to prod dodge. He's coasting.

[zMuffinMan]

dopog had two options: hammer or not hammer. not hammer = someone else might have, making him look worse. hammer = possibility for milking town cred. i think the complete lack of interactions between dopog and flipped scum prior to his votes on them is telling.

[Metal Sonic]

these replacements are the strongest in the game

could you guys imagine that at the start of the game, with the exception of HD and KX, nobody started before 2013? yeah suck

[zMuffinMan]

i don't think join date has anything to do with the strength of a player.

@matias,

do you actually plan on reading the game? or isos, or anything?

[Matias]

i don't think join date has anything to do with the strength of a player.

@matias,

do you actually plan on reading the game? or isos, or anything?

I have been. I just needed updated reads to support what I'm reading. 50 pages isn't too much but it's nice to have a now and a then to compare.

[Matias]

I'm also taking my time a bit since KX is a sure lynch for today, I hope you guys are okay with that

[zMuffinMan]

where are you at now?

[zMuffinMan]

also, do you plan to give intermediate updates on your thoughts as you read? coz that would be cool, to have a now and a then to compare.

[Matias]

Yeah you have a good point. I've been lightly skimming everything, and only today have been specifically going through ISOs. Here's what I have so far, just on an extremely basic note:

SV and MS are obvious town to us at this point (SV confirmed, I should say).

I do find EddieFenix to give me weird vibes, but CTD to make me feel better. Your predecessor made me feel the same way as well. I feel like both of you guys redeemed your slots.

meeps hasn't really used his vote to pressure but he looks genuine in his hunting. He goes on the town pile.

Evil Regals seems alright to me right now.

Evil Regals said that dopog was coasting. I agree with that. I also don't feel very good about marquis...what's the general consensus of him?

My money's on notscience for last scum over dopog and marquis though. Did a lot of tunneling to no avail. Hasn't been pushing people past general taunts.

I need to review everything again later but that's my intermediate update.

[zMuffinMan]

i had bad feelings about marquis when i read through d1 (mostly due to the way he was consistently calling beastcharizard scum but it never felt like he wanted a lynch on beastcharizard to go through). but if you read the d2 posts and how he interacts with flipped scum (posts between #896 and #1249) i have trouble seeing him making sense as scum with hd and beastcharizard.

notscience has even more interactions with flipped scum that make even less sense, plus i'm reading most of his posts as town. annoyingly anti-town at times, but still town.

[meeps]

@ 1460

he hammered with like 2-3 mins before deadline iirc. beast attempted to hammer twice i believe. speaking about beast he was scum so yeah, im not saying dopog is town, but it was just something to keep in mind

[zMuffinMan]

no i mean like half an hour earlier he committed to hammering. but yeah sure, i suppose you could make a case that he could have just pretended to have no been around at the deadline. i'd still consider it null at best.

[notscience]

KX is scum

I am town

Tahdah

[Matias]

KX is scum

I am town

Tahdah

Welp, I can't argue with this logic. Confirmed town it is.

[Marquis]

fine ns can have the hammer.

VOTE: kx

[Matias]

Wait a little longer, please. CTD wanted to catch up, I still need some reads from some players.