Mafiascum.net

UNVOTE: Broken Aquarium
VOTE: PeaceBringer

I get the feeling your going to do that -I won't do any reads thing on day 1 thing again-. You could of just said "it's a rvs because I don't feel like I can make a read or something any explanation is better than none." I don't mean to sound mean but can I ask what do you get out of mafia.

well garmr, you can take it and stick it up your backside
it is not schtick it is what I do and how I play... feel free to do what you are doing...
you cannot help it...

oh and garmr- I don't get anything out of the way the game is played here and when my commitments to current games are done, I am moving on...

Ok I wish you luck then.

Totally unhelpful.

Hello, everyone! I am Skelda, or when you suspect me, that damn scummy goat. I take moral highground and tend to avoid the RVS, but at this point I do see someone who deserves my vote.

VOTE: PeaceBringer for the OMGUS vote and the utter gibberish he is spouting. "Just how I am" is an argument I've seen scum use, in fact I've used it as scum, and I really hate that logic. Scum should be acting like their townie selves if they are doing their job properly, and tend to reinforce it.

And hey, Hermy! Fancy seeing you here!

I don't know the statistics on flips on people who choose to play like dicks like Peace here but regardless I'd like to go for the slightly more subtler scummy players and mozamis is currently leading in that category IMO.
Still if peace is the consensus lynch of the day I have no problem hammering him/voting him if other wagons clearly won't work and if he continues to play like posts 51 and 52.
Skelda out of interest, did that argument work when you were scum i.e. was it effective? Also what breed of goat is that?

Rofl how do you find these gifs? I would have never thought they existed.

Oh shit I actually haven't voted for moz

UNVOTE: MnemonicDevice

VOTE: Mozamis

Nice. So 3 votes on me for no reason. and 4 votes on peacebringer. Also because of his playstyle.

I also like how Skelda just randomly jumps on the peacebringer wagon. RVS much?

what you on about?
There's only 1 vote on you.
Skelda gave reasons as to why he jumped on the peace wagon but even if he hadn't, can you really blame him considering how peace is playing right now?

Yes. Peace is playing like peace normally plays.

Godwin's Law.

Honig, is it possible to sit any more firmly on that fence re Peacebringer? We're on page 3 of day 1 - there is no way we have a consensus lynch at this point, and now who's looking to end the day? And however we get out of RVS, we're out of it now. How is that a bad thing?

Peacebringer isn't striking me as scummy so much as uncommitted, that he's showing up but not really making even the barest of efforts. Anti town != scummy.

Broken Aquarium is fluffposting (see posts 42 and 43). And yeah, I meant explain the logic behind your votes. Actually, this applies to many people at this point, which does not make me happy.

@Honig: you're right I got some personal bias going on there, I tend to think of scum being smart and calculating. I am not liking the way moz is jumping his vote around for aggressively not very good reasons.

On peacebringer, I didn't read it as scummy. Although I have to wonder if he hates the site so much why did he sign up for a new game and why doesn't he replace out. I think the wagon is bad though and I'm looking at skelda for jumping on it. I also have no idea what his explanation is trying to say. Scum should act townie but peace isn't acting townie and he hates this??

Well then Shane, you probably won't like this either:



His post was way too "blendy", friendly and cheerful. Certainly, when you compare him and Peacebringer, its much more likely that he is scum than Peace. Peace annoyed me by being unhelpful, but it takes gutsy scum to play like that. Scum far more likely to play "nicey nice" like Skelda.

Yes, I have moved my vote around a bit, but I dont see that as a bad thing. It gets reactions going, conversations, and its better thn sitting on the fence.
But out of all my votes, most confident about Skelda being scum.

UNVOTE: Peacebringer
VOTE: mozamis

In post 65, mozamis wrote:Well then Shane, you probably won't like this either:

VOTE SKELDA.

His post was way too "blendy", friendly and cheerful. Certainly, when you compare him and Peacebringer, its much more likely that he is scum than Peace. Peace annoyed me by being unhelpful, but it takes gutsy scum to play like that. Scum far more likely to play "nicey nice" like Skelda.

Yes, I have moved my vote around a bit, but I dont see that as a bad thing. It gets reactions going, conversations, and its better thn sitting on the fence.
But out of all my votes, most confident about Skelda being scum.

I don't think a blendy a cheerful posting style is a valid scum sign. Skelda at least provided a reason to his vote and this makes me more inclined to think his town. You also jumped on the peacebringer wagon with out giving any reason what so ever then vote someone because of it.

The rvs was slightly confusing but i can't really give scum points for that. His reason for voting JKLM was because he joked about himself being scum and looked like a tryhard scum. I don't see try hard scum in JkLM's posting, I see someone mucking around trying to get reactions out of players with that, but that's just me.

Mozamis is my top scum read at the moment While I don't have have a top town read since no one has reached that point yet. Skelda,Honig and JKLM are starting to lean town.

we obviously disagree, but for the record I did give a reason for voting peace "totally uhelpful" was my reason at the time.
Look at Skelda's post again -it couldn't be anymore "Hey, love you guys, and I'm gonna vote for the bad unhelpful Peacebringer too, me too!" if it tried.

@Mozamis He still provided a better reason than you through. But I will acknowledge that you gave a reason. Still your plays so far have been a bit iffy.

@Project Matt I'm going to call you out through and ask why did you Vote Mozamis with out listing any reasons. I would actually like to hear some insight on how the game is going.

In post 65, mozamis wrote:Well then Shane, you probably won't like this either:

VOTE SKELDA.

His post was way too "blendy", friendly and cheerful. Certainly, when you compare him and Peacebringer, its much more likely that he is scum than Peace. Peace annoyed me by being unhelpful, but it takes gutsy scum to play like that. Scum far more likely to play "nicey nice" like Skelda.

Yes, I have moved my vote around a bit, but I dont see that as a bad thing. It gets reactions going, conversations, and its better thn sitting on the fence.
But out of all my votes, most confident about Skelda being scum.

It was my first post, I like to make good first impressions. And you are voting for me on the grounds that I was too friendly? I find that kind of pathetic, honestly.

VOTE: Skelda

For reasons I'm not allowed to say ATM, this is his scummyness.

There isn't a lot of stuff going on here that I have to say, I'll give this thread another read.

In post 61, mnemonicdevice wrote:Yes. Peace is playing like peace normally plays.

I checked, it is.

UNVOTE: , VOTE: mozamis

Responding to prod. Sorry.
Um... woo! It's the weekend! And hi Skelda

Somehow I don't think I ought to put Mozamis at L-1 yet, though... I don't know...

VOTE: projectmatt for voting without a reason. Bit bandwagon-y.