NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[Aegor]

VOTE: Kab

I know he voted on both scum wagons and neither town wagon D1, but he should die.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 6.1

Rainbowdash (3) - emeraldemon, Thesp, kabooooom
Sotty7 (1) - HighShroomish
Thesp (1) - Rainbowdash
kabooooom (1) - Aegor

Not voting (2) - Sotty7, Thor665

With eight players alive, it takes five votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Six is Wednesday, 30th April 23.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-30 22:00:00)).

[kabooooom]

VOTE: Kab

I know he voted on both scum wagons and neither town wagon D1, but he should die.

no comments. i would want the same if i were in your place.

[HighShroomish]

Oh, thanks.
Gosh it's hard to keep track of replacements.

[HighShroomish]

Damnit kab bad response

VOTE: Kab

[kabooooom]

Well but its the truth! :/

[emeraldemon]

ABP don't leave me hangin' I was looking forward to playing with you

Aegor, what is your read on Rainbowdash?

[emeraldemon]

Oops that quote is unrelated, forgot I hit the multiquote button while reading.

[inHimshallibe]

[deadpost]Thanks for the game, Huntress![/deadpost]

[Thesp]

Thesp, why Rainbow and not Kab?

I think he's likelier scum and I'm still not thrilled with his fight against ABR's lynch, nor his entirely ignoring ignoring the Bulbazak wagon. (There may be a hint of dislike for his vote on me, though I try to ignore that in my approach.) I also figure a RainbowDash wagon is slightly more likely to get off the ground. That said, I'd be quite happy with a kabooooom lynch as well.

---

Sotty,

Rainbowdash, I can find plenty of instances of you defending ABR or directing away from his wagon (1788, 1803, 1808, 1843). And yet as I read your case against Thor (2114,2151) it seems largely about Thor not pushing ABR or directing away from his wagon. What's up?

This is all I've written so far. Honestly a lot of it is about PoE, I have townreads on you and Thesp, and I'm leaning town on HighShroomish, Thor, and Aegor. That leaves RBD and Kaboom.

I am still semi-paranoid about Thor (inHim did say "It's down to PJ and Thor for me" late yesterday -- 2585) and Aegor, so my main goals for today are to sort them, Kaboom and RBD as best I can. I'm happy to start with RBD.

This sums me up pretty well also.

[Thesp]

Thesp, why Rainbow and not Kab?

I think he's likelier scum and I'm still not thrilled with his fight against ABR's lynch, nor his entirely ignoring ignoring the Bulbazak wagon. (There may be a hint of dislike for his vote on me, though I try to ignore that in my approach.) I also figure a RainbowDash wagon is slightly more likely to get off the ground. That said, I'd be quite happy with a kabooooom lynch as well.

My apologies, the pronouns within should be "she/her". I'm happy to move to kabooooom if that's the way the wind blows - feel free to consider my vote as being on either one.

[Aegor]

ABP don't leave me hangin' I was looking forward to playing with you

Aegor, what is your read on Rainbowdash?

I would be willing to lynch RBD. But kab has done nothing to suggest he is town, and I would much rather he die now.

[Aegor]

Thesp, why the flip-flop on kab v. RBD?

[Thesp]

Thesp, why the flip-flop on kab v. RBD?

I had RainbowDash ranked slightly higher yesterday after the read-through - are you asking why I changed at that time?

If I was Condorcet ranking Rainbowdash and kabooooom, though, I'm not sure I wouldn't put them on the same line. (Like I said, I'm still quite happy to lynch either.)

[Aegor]

Yes

[Thesp]

Yes

Much of my answer can be found here:

Thesp, why Rainbow and not Kab?

I think he's likelier scum and I'm still not thrilled with his fight against ABR's lynch, nor his entirely ignoring ignoring the Bulbazak wagon. (There may be a hint of dislike for his vote on me, though I try to ignore that in my approach.) I also figure a RainbowDash wagon is slightly more likely to get off the ground. That said, I'd be quite happy with a kabooooom lynch as well.

Also looking back in my notes, I see an exchange between you and Bulbazak starting on Post #1951 and running through #1958 (really through 1971 or so) where you talk about why you want Rainbowdash dead, and Bulbazak defends him through attacking you. That likely played a part as well.

[Aegor]

VOTE: RBD

If he flips town, please, can kab die tomorrow?

[Rainbowdash]

VOTE: RBD

If he flips town, please, can kab die tomorrow?

Absolutely not.

You lynch Thesp tomorrow.

Kab is town. Look at how Bulb treated the Kab vs ABR wagons. There is no way scum just ducks both wagons. He at least picks one and runs with it for the town credit and to try to preach the wagons haven been town vs scum in an attempt to clear his partner.

Defeat that logic. Explain why Bulb decides to avoid what was very clearly going to be the two rival wagons if they were on his partners. Its a win-win. If he voted scum that got lynched, it means that he has town credit. If he voted scum who didn't get lynched, in a situation he got lynched it basically clears his partner. I would almost say SH is more likely scum than kab.

Its Thesp.

If not Thesp its probably 70% Thor 30% sotty. Look at the Inhim kill. His suspects: Thesp and Thor. Did ED die? No... he was calling those two town. HS? Same thing. One of these things is not like the other. Thesp and Thor. Kab is the mislynch that scum is probably hoping for in lylo if they get there.

Not a singly player has countered my logic on kab. Im getting mislynched I am going to shut down what im very sure is another mislynch.

Thesp comes in an quickly just lays a lazy vote on Bulb for what he seems to be thinking deadline reasons. When a chance to move off Bulb onto town comes up, he suddenly does. Very early with Bulb you can see Thesp think "Bulb is going to be lynched". If scum has that read, why are you not going to try to bus? If you thought your partner was doomed, if not today then immediately after the next mislynch, why do you not try to bus?

[HighShroomish]

Okay RBD, you've gone a little to far into NK WIFOM.

VOTE: RBD

And I just face the fuck up on that analisis. I can't type all that on my phone.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 6.2

Rainbowdash (5) - emeraldemon, Thesp, kabooooom, Aegor, HighShroomish

Thesp (1) - Rainbowdash

Not voting (2) - Sotty7, Thor665

With eight players alive, it takes five votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Six is Wednesday, 30th April 23.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-30 22:00:00)).

[Huntress]

Over the past few weeks the citizens numbers had reduced as they attempted to root out the evil among them. Their first two attempts had failed and retribution followed fast as members of their group mysteriously disappeared in the night.

The faces changed over time as some made excuses amd left their deputies to take their places. Others just failed to turn up to meetings and newcomers had to be drafted in.

But then their luck changed and despair turned to hope as one, and then another, of the mafia were tracked down through the painstaking work of the citizens.

Knowing they weren't finished yet their attention turned to two more of their number, eventually taking out the one who seemed just a bit too anxious to prove he was one of them. Unfortunately he was. Could the other one of the pair be the last of the mafia? This time they didn't delay. But were they right?

Rainbowdash (

Mafia goon

) has been lynched.

Game over - Town wins!

Thank you all for playing.

[emogirl123]

hm that's cool.

[Zdenek]

I'll have renewed faith in the world if it's RBD.

Thanks Huntress.

[emogirl123]

thank you thesp.

[Huntress]

Dead thread