NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[DeathNote]

Idk. GC.

Meaning GC is scum?

[Green Crayons]

Are you being purposefully obtuse because you don't want to seem like overeager scum?

Ythan thinks I'm scum. I think Ythan is scum. This is not new news. This is old news.

[Green Crayons]

I just read my post and realized that it could be read as a bit harsh.

But instead of rewording what I said, I'm going to stick by it. You're not thick, so I don't see how you could be confused about Ythan's post. So your apprehension about where Ythan stands looks feigned.

[Green Crayons]

I would love for every player to post before we start voting from sheer boredom.

I think DN and Anti should go ahead and set out their order of who to vote and why.

Elyse can then state her peace, since everyone agrees that she's the most town.


That makes the most sense to me as the order of things.

[DeathNote]

GC, shut up.

I don't play the game the same way you do. Just because it is "common knowledge" doesn't mean I don't have a reasoning for asking my question.

When Ythan just pops in, says he is doesn't care about the game, then says "Idk. GC." without adding anything else... that kind of isn't good enough for me.

So I ask him a blatant question that should be leading to a response about Why you are scum. I don't want Ythan to just set himself with a fuck it vote on you. That is stupid and anti-town.

Now if he is scum, then fine... I'll just lynch him. But that comment comes across as uninterested town to me and not lurking scum.

[DeathNote]

I already said what my target lynch for the day was.

Ythan>Anti>GC

However, that could easily be changed if Ythan participated. I really want to think he is town but with only 5 people left, it is becoming increasingly obvious to me that he is likely scum.

[Antihero]

another large game i replace into late, another lylo that i'm not prepared for...

in the last page alone, green crayons looks p town and the "apathy" from ythan looks artificial (is GC the only scum or is he just saying that because of the PoE game we're in right now?).

[Green Crayons]

@DeathNote:

This isn't a matter of play style, and I don't see how my criticism about your post makes it a matter of play style, so that's a strange direction to want take this.

When Ythan just pops in, says he is doesn't care about the game, then says "Idk. GC." without adding anything else... that kind of isn't good enough for me.

So I ask him a blatant question that should be leading to a response about Why you are scum.

The above explanation of motives and play makes sense.

However, it does not jive with what you actually asked:

Idk. GC.

Meaning GC is scum?

Your question begs a yes/no response. That's not "leading to a response about why <I> am scum." That's leading to a response we all know before it's stated: "Yes." Or, maybe even, "Yes, GC is scum." Like, even ignoring the GC/Ythan history of this game, Ythan's meaning is self evident. And so I don't see how that's getting beyond his minimal input for the day.


BUT WHATEVER. It looks like I jumped the gun in reacting to this because now we can't see how your uninfluenced interaction with Ythan would have played out. I blame it on the fact that you're all bored with the game and so the not-GC-posting rate has gone way down.


-----

@Anti:

Do you agree with your predecessor's assessment that there is only 1 scum left? Why or why not.

[Antihero]

@Anti:

Do you agree with your predecessor's assessment that there is only 1 scum left? Why or why not.

at first blush, i thought it might be possible, but i've thought about it and i'm pretty sure it's 2. the scum PRs flips are pretty nerfed (limited shot, as opposed to full). extrapolating out from 10:3, 13:4 ratio, i think it's probable this game has 5 scum total.

[DeathNote]

Responses lead to other responses. I didn't ask the question the way you would have and so you get upset about it.

[Green Crayons]

Me vocalizing a reaction (of "hey this play is suspicious to me") is not getting upset. It's saying "hey this play is suspicious to me." Which is what I usually do in mafia games, and what I presume most other folks do as well.


If you want upset, see today's first posts in re: the lack of a productive result from the No Lynch fiasco.


But, at any rate:

BUT WHATEVER. It looks like I jumped the gun in reacting to this because now we can't see how your uninfluenced interaction with Ythan would have played out. I blame it on the fact that you're all bored with the game and so the not-GC-posting rate has gone way down.

[DeathNote]

If we lose because of this then whatever. I just want this game to be over with because I don't see anyone really trying anymore.

Vote: Ythan

Good Game guys, my vote stays here.

[DeathNote]

Also, Ythan's buddy, please kill me tonight. -_-

[Green Crayons]

I did a skim of Yates's and DN's posts and, looking at how they interacted with each other, I don't think that they are scum partners. Therefore, assuming 2 scum left, it's either Ythan & DN, or Ythan & Yates/Anti (obviously from my perspective, which slots Elyse and myself as town). If only 1 scum left, and it isn't Ythan, then this won't be the end of things.

VOTE: Ythan

[Elyse]

Here goes nothing.

VOTE: Ythan

[Desperado]

ythan has been lynched. He was a

Vanilla townie!

Elyse, Town Mason, and Green Crayons, Vanilla Toe n ie, have been endgamed.

DeathNote, Mafia Goon, and Antihero, Mafia Goon, victorious!

Full mod reveal later tonight.

[Cabd]

Oh look, you all lynched bulba when he told you that nurse that way was not normal (it's not) and then you proceeded to ignore him anyways!

[Cabd]

Oh well, I'm content that I got 2 of you for my own death; and then I had the game solved in the dead QT.

[Marquis]

I probably should have explained that my townread on DeathNote only happened because I thought he was a Mason at first

[DeathNote]

Yeah... I think we won based off apathy.

[DeathNote]

I probably should have explained that my townread on DeathNote only happened because I thought he was a Mason at first

I tried really hard to set myself up for a mason cc too. But after the nurse thing, I decided against it.

[Green Crayons]

I did a skim of Yates's and DN's posts and, looking at how they interacted with each other, I don't think that they are scum partners.

Beep boop this was wrong.

[Marquis]

Scum QT would be fun while you're all here

[Marquis]

Oh hey I guess the VT - Nurse - Doctor claim mishap was a slip too

[DeathNote]

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/SFjU3uUkEJNk4