NY175: Sycamore Scuffle

[notscience]

do I get a shout out

[Juls]

mirhawks*. Stupid ipad autocorrects that for some reason

[Mirhawk]

WHOOOO YAY.

Thanks!

[TheAdrienC]

TheAdrienC - I struggle with what to say to you. Your fakeness can be forgiven because you were, well, fake, cause you had to be. Hopefully you can improve on that.

I've actually been lynched as town for sounding fake so if you have any advice on how to work on that, it would be a tremendous help.

PEdit, Happy birthday, Mirhawk.

[notscience]

Oh happy birthday!

[notscience]

Oh happy birthday!

[Juls]

do I get a shout out

Go back and read my posts, I know...you couldn't be bothered to in game but I literally pointed out about 30+ things that came across as fake. Then read Salamences posts to get even more. The rage posts were super obviously not real.

[TheAdrienC]

I think that was directed at me? Haha. I will, thank you.

[TheAdrienC]

I didn't do it in game because I felt like I was digging a deeper hole, haha.

[Juls]

Oops, the quote should not be with that response...
Notscience - I went with the final mod list. You weren't around much and I think you hit the game at a particularly busy time for me so I don't have a lot of comments. Be more science, less notscience!

[Alina]

Thanks boon, I'll do my best, haha.

Adrien, I'm not sure how to help you with the fake sounding thing. A lot of the time it just sounded like you were being overdramatic; but you had some really good posts that muddled my scumread on you here and there.

And happy birthday Mirhawk!

[Juls]

I didn't do it in game because I felt like I was digging a deeper hole, haha.

You dug a deeper hole with me for NOT responding and I am irritated no one else held your feet to the fire about it.

[notscience]

I'll eat a bullet for thinking along the same lines as you any day, Juls

[Juls]

VOTE: notscience

[Boonskiies]

@Reinoe - I totally knew I was cop confirmed along with Brood when Aegor mentioned it in his post. I was going to do something like, "why do you guys just auto assume I'm town because he gave an innocent on me?" to try and act like I also was a godfather of some sort, so I could get through another night without being killed. Also another reason I hammered Juls. I need to seem semi stupid so I can stay alive. I don't lose very often. Usually when I'm more serious are the games I lose...

[Burning_Earth]

welp gg

[BP]

So close....

[Wake1]

Wow, so I got a successful wagon going and helped take out Scum.

Thank God I kept questioning myself. Thought Juls was on to something, too.

[Not_Mafia]

So, those kills, why?

[Wake1]

@Wake:

Nice job at the end. I strongly disagree with your early kills, and the fact that you and scum shot the same people is...not awesome, but nice job with setup spec at the end. As a note, Commuters should never, under any circumstances, be considered cleared.

@Toomai:

Thank you for modding this game. It had a great setup, my role was awesome, and this was the smoothest and most aesthetically beautiful modding I have seen in some time.

@All:

If you want more Large Normals, Wake's is now in signups, and you should definitely pre-in for mine.

I got the feelings they were Scum. Those scum-vibe feelings. Chances are I'll make mistakes early on in the game, and that goes for mislynching folks on accident, too. Hindsight is 20/20, and I try not to get mad with people after the fact for being wrong.

Thought I was on to something late in the game, and it looks like it helped in getting us to not die.

Toomai, you had a great game, most fun I've had in a mafia game.

Wake, you got me! I panicked a little when I realized you were shifting to distrusting me.

I tend to distrust players more than others, which is why I don't like making reads lists. Everyone's suspicious to some degree, and in this case the paranoia was a good thing.

And damn, N1

and

N3 had someone double-targeted. That definitely threw me for a loop. Was convinced for a while Wake was putting on the hugest gambit ever.

Haven't done a gambit in over 7 months.

No wonder I was confused over Nights 1 and 3. Ha!

Wake was instatown the second he posted that he was responsible for those kills. Double so seeing as how Aero flipped SK immediately afterward.

True. I figured my goose was cooked that Night.

Adrien, did you leave me alive? If I'm in a good Town-Light, don't ever leave me alive, especially in late-game. I suck in early game, but play much better late game.

Juls

, my life is health care. I know how to talk to people. Mafia's different, because want to manipulate, kill, and drive you crazy via paranoia. Easy to talk smack after the game is over, and I could also discuss your own flaws in this game, but that'd be doing the same thing you're doing.

Toomai

, thanks for running a good game. I can be abrasive and forceful at times, but that's a small part of my personality. Don't think I noticed any hiccups in snags in your game, either.

[Wake1]

To the Scum and Dead QTs!

*Dons helmet and armor.

[Wake1]

Reading over the funny comments about me saying there's a Vig here: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=58281

Like this: "Lol at Wake pushing this "odd night vig" nonsense. Any vig claim at this point is a serial killer claim."

Ha!

[Aeronaut]

Wooo! I lose regardless!

But actually, I had an awesome time playing with everyone here, and I'd be happy to play with most of you again. I'm pretty pumped that I got so far as SK in my second game ever. Really my favorite role and I hope I get it again some day.

Most of my kills were aimed at scum purposely. I realized halfway through that the town wasn't going to get it done, and I didn't want to be stuck in Lylo with four scum. Reinoe, I'm mad sorry that's how your game ended. That sucks.

I'll have everyone know that I was always legitimately scum hunting, I just apparently was scummy about it. I thought BP was town for sure, and I defended him like an idiot. Dumb, dumb Aeronaut

N_M was also killed because I thought he was scum. Farside was killed because he was onto me.

Good on Mirhawk and Juls for calling me on my shit.


As a whole, I really liked this game and Toomai ran it like a pro. Will definitely play in whatever game he mods next

Will stick around for post game a little

[Aeronaut]

Wake, the dead QT might be a rough read. I know as for myself, I think you played dreadfully, but you pulled it through at the end and that's what matters. As far as I'm concerned, I'd be fine to play with you again, but please just don't be the vig

[Wake1]

I did notice Cabd's nasty comments.

Perhaps if Cabd didn't come off as an incredibly foul, mean person towards towards players, those players wouldn't react in kind in a different way.

When Town plays as a team, Town also doesn't vomit their nastiness on other players. I've done that in the past, and I don't pretend I haven't.