Scummies 2015 - Nomination Thread!

[Nexus]

nominate Davsto for Kodak Moment for this post

2nd

[Cheetory6]

Holy shit that's fucking hilarious.
Davsto you're a gem dude.
3rd.

[pirate mollie]

4th

[Titus]

5th

Also, I would like to create a category for Scotmany for his performance as the SK. I don't feel like it fits most cunning manipulator but at the same time I feel like the play deserved some sort of scummy none the less. There are many games each year that a player has great play but is a victim of circumstance. I feel this was it. If there can't be a category for great play in a loss, so be it. I feel at least he should be nommed though.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=63662

[Titus]

Nth third party

Scot many, same game

[Flameaxe]

nominate Davsto for Kodak Moment for this post

2nd

Nth

And nth whatever it ends up being for scot. He had the whole game fooled every point of the game, myself included.

[Aneninen]

Also, I would like to create a category for Scotmany for his performance as the SK. I don't feel like it fits most cunning manipulator but at the same time I feel like the play deserved some sort of scummy none the less. There are many games each year that a player has great play but is a victim of circumstance. I feel this was it. If there can't be a category for great play in a loss, so be it. I feel at least he should be nommed though.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=63662

I second the category itself. Sometimes certain players are doing it exceptionally but they fail in the end because of something silly. (Another example for this is Egg in NewYork #181, he was the SK, Nightkilled two Mafiosos, got to LyLo (the Mafia was out of the game after Day4) and somehow he got lynched.) <-- Although this category shouldn't be only for SKs.

[Flameaxe]

The Horseshoes and Hand Grenades award

[Faraday]

Also, I would like to create a category for Scotmany for his performance as the SK. I don't feel like it fits most cunning manipulator but at the same time I feel like the play deserved some sort of scummy none the less. There are many games each year that a player has great play but is a victim of circumstance. I feel this was it. If there can't be a category for great play in a loss, so be it. I feel at least he should be nommed though.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=63662

I second the category itself. Sometimes certain players are doing it exceptionally but they fail in the end because of something silly. (Another example for this is Egg in NewYork #181, he was the SK, Nightkilled two Mafiosos, got to LyLo (the Mafia was out of the game after Day4) and somehow he got lynched.) <-- Although this category shouldn't be only for SKs.

Best performance third party exists.

[hiplop]

Best performance third party indicates a win though I think is what she's saying

Also known as the “Hannibal Lecter” Award. Awarded to the player or players that performed the most impressively in winning their game as a third party.

Not sure how I feel about it because I think this game is so crazy and based on so many subjective things that not winning is a pretty big blunder, I think? I mean like an SK is already inherently hard to find because they are also hunting scum and SHOULD look town, which helps them win more often

and I feel like basically every loss can be pinned on one moment/mistake, so there would be like 728399 games nom'd. I do think there are some people who get screwed (replacements? Modkills? Someone breaking a huge rule, axxidently linking to scum PT) but those seem few and far between and likely would be overcrowded by "if mastin wasn't in this game I could have won!"

[xRECKONERx]

it's not based on winning, that description is stupid. winning is a prerequisite for any awards

[Psyche]

victory is the only valid vindication

[shos]

lol so fuck this
I wanna nom myself for winning twice in the same game as two third parties

[Jake from State Farm]

lol so fuck this
I wanna nom myself for winning twice in the same game as two third parties

Link? I'll nom you if true

[shos]

lol so fuck this
I wanna nom myself for winning twice in the same game as two third parties

Link? I'll nom you if true

I shit you not

[Jake from State Farm]

nom shos for best 3rd party for micro 530 - http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=63431

[VysePresident]

I think Kodak moment might be more appropriate?

I haven't had time to check the thread, so it could be really genius play on his part that deserves 3rd party nom, but I'm just asking?

[wgeurts]

He went about his role pretty well but as the mod I wouldn't mind

2nding

Shos.
That whole game makes for a good laugh if you read it.

What makes me laugh even more though is that he then proceeds to be the only survivor as town in the sequel due to the final scum hammering a supersaint in lylo.

[Drixx]

3rd Shos. That was brilliant.

[Not_Mafia]

Nominate Mini:1688 Bees for best setup

[Fro99er]

Nominate Mini:1688 Bees for best setup

2nd!

[RadiantCowbells]

Front page update when?

[Untrod Tripod]

Maybe tonight~

[Glork]

Nominating the town of MAFIACEPTION for Best Performance - Pro-Town Team.

They lynched all 5 scum in 5 days, blocked a nightkill, successfully used a unique mechanic-related ability to weaken the scumteam, and just played overall fantastic. They ended the game with more dead scum than dead town, and that says a lot.

[Plotinus]

2nd mafiaception

I was following this game and town did really impressively well.