I think you're being too lenient. Cmitc1 is new to this site, BUT he does have off site experience. So he knows how the game works.In post 918, Hoopla wrote:Since D1, my solid town read on cmitc1 has evaporated somewhat. After seeing more of his play he really just seems like a placid, uninterested newbie, and I don't think you can deduce his alignment from classical tells you'd use on most other players. There is just no purpose and motivation in his play and I think it's just the way he is.
He should only be lynched if there are no other attractive options. Hopefully we can PoE the game around him, so his alignment becomes obvious that way.
Exactly. You were blindly cashing in on popular opinion. That's scummy.cmitc1 wrote:I did not find anyIn post 917, Grendel wrote: He has yet to give me any examples that show me why my set created bad discussion, or even why its scummy. Yeah, he never answered why he thought it was scummy he just said it made bad discussion. So unless he is asserting that scum are the only ones who are crap posting then he only half answered my question. If he can even explain how peoples Reponses to the set were crap post-y.
It's not out of the question that Blank could be scum, but it seems like it'd be harder to establish a wagon duel D1 with scum in it so easily, particularly if Masq is town. I imagine scum would be throwing Masq's hat into the ring too or at least stalling the Blank push/not allowing a Vedith vs. Blank duel to occur in the first place.In post 932, Seraphim wrote:Hoopla, you are one of the few things keeping this game together. Can you explain a little more why you think D1 gives us Blanktown and Masqscum rather than vice versa?
When I was reading and didn't know who was getting lynched, Vedith looked pretty much like a sure thing. Blankface never got any traction. I feel like there was never any serious competition to that wagon. And now folks have moved right onto Masq without any sort of countervailing sentiment. That feels like bussing/railroading to me. Maybe concerning is the wrong word, I just think it feels too easy especially after yesterday. Masq might just be bad town, Blank looks like classic scum coasting. I recognize it because when I used to play it was how my scum game would typically look.In post 934, Hoopla wrote:It's not out of the question that Blank could be scum, but it seems like it'd be harder to establish a wagon duel D1 with scum in it so easily, particularly if Masq is town. I imagine scum would be throwing Masq's hat into the ring too or at least stalling the Blank push/not allowing a Vedith vs. Blank duel to occur in the first place.In post 932, Seraphim wrote:Hoopla, you are one of the few things keeping this game together. Can you explain a little more why you think D1 gives us Blanktown and Masqscum rather than vice versa?
Why is the fact the Masq wagon happening today as opposed to yesterday concerning to you? It seems like the tide is turning in a pretty natural way post-D1 flips. The composition of this wagon looks town fueled, with perhaps one person suspecting Masq is in trouble and bussing early -- Egg most likely, as I'm reading Elyse as townish and BBmolla too. Although, I'd really like molla to do more this game, rather than coast on the defense I've given him so far.
is this legit?In post 937, Killthestory wrote:I'm the people's champion, and I investigated Elyse. They're scum.
of course he isn't. he's just bored and doesn't want to read the game.In post 943, BBmolla wrote:KtS confirm you're claiming a guilty or I'm ignoring it
I'd like to know why he gets a free pass for it.In post 944, Hoopla wrote:of course he isn't. he's just bored and doesn't want to read the game.In post 943, BBmolla wrote:KtS confirm you're claiming a guilty or I'm ignoring it
does this even need to be said?
Better safe tHan sorry.In post 931, Grendel wrote:Why is that?
I didn't say it was bad to put somebody at L-1, I just pointed out it had been done so there wouldn't be an accidental hammer.
I will get to that question tomorrow, it has been a long day.Seraphim wrote:So shit is solidly fucked this game, given that most of the posting yesterday was focused around players who aren't even the game anymore.
Vote: BlankFace
BlankFace is conspicuously non-confrontational given his confrontational posting style. I don't remember who posted this but BF spends a lot of time and emotional energy trying to defuse the Robb bullshit. A typically worthy endeavor, but there's no other pushes, especially when despite all the shit that went down there is a lot of other content, a lot of other players to look into and push. I think Grendel is misguided town, but BlankFace is trying to cash in on a player who will be an easy lynch regardless of alignment.
I am totally shocked that a Masq wagon didn't materialize yesterday and the fact that it's happening today makes me uneasy.
Hoopla, you are one of the few things keeping this game together. Can you explain a little more why you think D1 gives us Blanktown and Masqscum rather than vice versa?
cmitc1, if you could vig shot one player in the game without a claim, who would it be and why?
Grendel, identify for me one thing or post in particular that you don't think town would do that cmitc1 has done or posted.
