In post 392, Persivul wrote:Personally I think the answer is that you need to lay more groundwork to avoid appearing scummy. You town read me at one point. You began the shift in 317 and have been escalating it.
Escalating how, exactly?
I was originally townreading you for an assumption that was later nullified. Doesn't mean i think you're defscum.
This is the post that made me townread House. I assumed that he thought that Persivul was the mason and that was the assumption i.e. Claiming VT. Obviously not.
In post 267, PantherPunt wrote:
guess it isn't that hard to fake, but I'm a sucker for posts like this (the "I'm the soldier" bit)
No clue what you're saying.
Persivul - r u scum br0
No. That's you, and lately I'm thinking lizard.
the consideration in the perspective:
"why is he pushing me rather than SS?...potentially because I'm the soldier"
I'm a sucker for the perspecive, but it is easy to fake.
despite the derp you made if you are in fact town..though unlikely.
the "are you scum" question- it's a feeler thing that sometimes elicits a good response. yours doesn't give much of any weight to my opinion on you, but I lean toward it being bad tone-wise.
I'd like the perspective of Persivul thinking he's the soldier, and calling people out on that, a lot more if his original Panther scum read wasn't based on Creature being the soldier... Both things can't be true
I don't like this post.
soldier spec this early is in general really bad. scum have many different reasons to push somebody and I doubt they'd gun obviously for the soldier early on day 1.
"You are the Joker of mafia players" - Oversoul
"last time I was scum with Firebringer
his first post in the scum PT was "yes I rolled scum!"
I decided to post "haha just don't post that in the main thread", but to get up to date on the main thread first.
His first post in the main thread was "yes I rolled scum!" -popsofctown
This is more a case of trusting my ability to find town over scum.
House, when did you think Persivul was town and I pushed him through? This is your post from late day one, you wanted Persivul lynch, I wanted Expedience. Day two you thought Persivul was the one Expedience claimed masons with, I pointed out that was Creature, then you voted Persivul without a wird about a townread.
In post 199, lizardqueen wrote:Re-read House's ISO, got some nice town vibes there. I'd like to see your thoughts on Persivul House if you get the chance.
I'm townreading Persivul. He doesn't seem to be overly active, but when he's here, he does present some good points.
He's a little misguided on me, obviously, but he's not coming across as having an agenda behind his push.
Not interested in voting you or him today. Creature is a possibility, but if he's town I might wrong about Panther?
He was a townread off mine d1, but not rock solid because of his limited activity.
In post 199, lizardqueen wrote:Re-read House's ISO, got some nice town vibes there. I'd like to see your thoughts on Persivul House if you get the chance.
I'm townreading Persivul. He doesn't seem to be overly active, but when he's here, he does present some good points.
He's a little misguided on me, obviously, but he's not coming across as having an agenda behind his push.
Not interested in voting you or him today. Creature is a possibility, but if he's town I might wrong about Panther?
He was a townread off mine d1, but not rock solid because of his limited activity.
Yeah, and then you wanted him lynched over Expedience, who I was voting.
Creature wrote:Nah, I don't think "I voted scum rather than town" is a valid argument in a short game.
I'm not using that as an argument I'm town, I'm using that to show that House is lying when he says he thought Persivul was town and I pushed him through.
Not sure he mentioned your usual playstyle, he though you might be scum with Expedience. I'll paraphrase the mason chat after I find that set of posts from before.