The Mystery at King's Landing - DEAD PT

[House Dayne]

Hello, this is a thread for the dead and spectators to hang out in!

(Reminder to those

dead

- if you want to ego the thread with 1

content-less

"bah" post after you're dead you're free to)

Current people with access to this thread:

Spoiler:

Me and my main
Mykonian (Backup mod)
Andrius (Reviewer)
Mhsmith0 (Reviewer)
Wraith (Spectator)
Regfan (Spectator)
Giovanni il Pellegrino (Previous player/Spectator)
Tammy (Previous player/Spectator)
KuroiXHF
mastina
Firebringer (Previous player/Spectator)
TellTaleHeart (Previous player/Spectator)
randomidget
Gorkington
Cheetory6
Mathblade
MaxwellPuckett
Vaxkiller
Nachomamma8
Untrod Tripod
Everyone! It's now public.

[House Dayne]

Some initial thoughts:

The game is going a good pace imo. Ik alted/anonymafia games usually move at a slower pace. (And Mormont and Tyrell should be here soon after their V/LA so we'll have almost everyone - not sure where Dondarrion is. I think it's his brutal working schedule )

For Tully, not sure exactly what kind of gambit he's trying to pull! (I kinda have an idea). His "claim" is p interesting though!

[House Dayne]

I'll post some alt guesses I get via PM here as well:

Connington = Creature so far from what I can tell.

Huh. So Titus is Gray
*redacted rest of stuff b/c spoilers!*

Regfan (spectating on own/on replacement list):

Early alt guesses, Clegane is Nacho and Connington is Tammy. (Only read ~20 posts total).

Oh and very high chance Reed is petapan/crypto or whatever account he's using at the moment. He probably joined expecting me in the game.

[Wraith]

So considering your comments I'm going to guess that Tully is a Cop with a N0 result

[Wraith]

Martell with an anti-Clegane post restriction would make a lot of sense.

[Wraith]

House Reed knowing nothing about ASOIAF is hilariously ironic

[Wraith]

So Alisae is Arryn?

[Wraith]

So considering your comments I'm going to guess that Tully is a Cop with a N0 result

Should have realized from your wording that it's also possible he's scum.

[House Dayne]

Martell with an anti-Clegane post restriction would make a lot of sense.

That would have been fun to do.

But for this game I don't think I would've been able to put house interactions based on lore. Basically everything was randomized on each other:

Alts are randomized on roles/alignments, which will be randomized onto the playerlist.

It might be fun in the future to run a game with house interactions (or alt-stealing roles like some in the thread are suggesting!) but those (and most definitely the latter) would be advertised as such.

[House Dayne]

Oh I should amend my statement a bit:

I have a

very

rough guess as to what Tully might be trying to attempt, but the plan might backfire* hard.

*Or Blackfyre

[Andrius]

I love Frey's roleplaying, even if they're scum.
No guesses as to who they are, however.

[House Dayne]

That ABR alt slip though lol.

[House Dayne]

Regfan last thoughts before coming here:

Greyjoy/Tully/Clegane for town, Conningham for scum; that's about the only reads I'd confident put forward. Everything else feels...very weak.

[House Dayne]

Now that you're here I can answer your question. The game is singleball

There are 3 scum and 1 unrecruitable/kill-able traitor.

[Regfan]

Hello! Well SAD posted most of my reads so you guys know where my heads at with most things.

I'm not really a fan of traitor as a role but respect that its' a nod to how Westeroes games were run.

Pretty displeased with Tullys claim if it's not actually real and he's town; if he's scum props to him for taking the brazen approach but if he's town fake claiming there is just horrific since he's left most people (Including myself) clearing Greyjoy giving him a very easy way through the day (and possibly game) if he's mafia. There's a special place in hell for fake claimers.

I can confidently tell you that Frey is Tammy, I thought Clegane was Nacho but based on spoilers in here Dondarrion may be Nacho instead. I'm also fairly sure Reed is an EMForumer.

[Regfan]

I mean it's not impossible that Tully is just the traitor signalling to Greyjoy as a partner, that'd make sense logically I suppose, and there's also the world where as traitor he's trying to make a townie look bad by linking himself to them early on so they get lynched after his flip. Plenty of reasons to consider lynching him

[House Dayne]

Oh I forgot Frey alts guess:

90% that dondarrion is nacho *redacted rest because spoilers*

[Regfan]

That kind of confirms Frey-Tammy and Dondarrion-Nacho then.

[Regfan]

You should post the playerlist, but not who's who and see if we can piece it all together!

[House Dayne]

Hmm, that's sounds like an interesting idea!

Nahdia
Tammy
MaxwellPuckett
TellTaleHeart
Hiraki
Albert B. Rampage
Untrod Tripod
Nachomamma8
KuroiXHF
Firebringer
Gorkington
mastina
Nexus/ChannelDelibird
Giovanni il Pellegrino
beeboy

[House Dayne]

Oh well the hydra is p obvious

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

I think titus might be reed.

Nice!

[House Dayne]

House Bolton alt guesses!

House Arryn 2.0
House Baratheon
House Clegane
House Connington (Creature or LUV?)
House Dondarrion (Nacho?)
House Frey
House Greyjoy (Mathblade?)
House Martell
House Mormont
House Reed 2.0 (Pretty sure this is Titus?)
House Seaworth (Slipped as ABR)
House Stark 2.0 (Chance of being Gin?)
House Tully (Pretty transparently Firebringer)
House Tyrell

This isn't easy.
I mean, there's some people I would think would be in the game if not for siteflakes/promises not to play/me not having an ability to identify who they'd be: JaeReed, nancy, MoI, and Pine all come to mind. The former two as two who don't seem like they'd have the motivation to play; the latter two have vanished.

Also, someone in this game is probably RadiantCowbells, but I'm not sure which of them it'd be. Pretty much the only house who has the necessary post count and drive would be Clegane.

And House Martell is a head of Reasonably Rational.
I believe it's Drixx, but there's the outside chance it's Cerb. It's definitely one of the two, though. I very, very, very strongly recognized their style of wording when doing an iso of them.

[Giovanni il Pellegrino]

Hmm...

I caught a glimpse of the Baratheon slip and I know they are Untrod Tripod.

As I thought, I hadn't played with anybody else before, save for Nahdia. I also think Nahdia is Reed 2.0. The "Sergeant Does Not Care" response they gave to me before I replaced out seems like something Nahdia would say if annoyed.

[Giovanni il Pellegrino]

Dang, I am dense. Hadn't realized that the player list you gave us above was the initial one before the replacements.