I see a perfect reason for scum to kill someone that wasn't making much of a difference in the game
Can you explain this? Why would scum kill someone who hasn't made mych impact?
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 11:31 am
by Flavor Leaf
Gonna be inactive for the giving days. Be back soon.
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 1:30 pm
by Flubbernugget
I wasn't hard sold on lalendra being scum (I listed my scum team later that day too) and compromise lynches are for the sake of flips, making them likely to land on town
This town is very uncooperative with each other. Scum doesn't want that to change, so it's in their interest to kill someone who wasn't changing the state of the game much.
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 1:40 pm
by lucca261
I'm back. Let's finish my D2 re-read and I'll talk.
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 4:10 pm
by lucca261
hey, comm didn't you have a big case to do on those three pairs of associative tells? I kinda wanna see your theory.
aubrey page 48 feels manufactured. how quickly he misdirected to Chisa her own suspicion. makes me paranoid.
in fact, I'm fucking paranoid all over. I have this gut feeling that I know exactly the scumteam and I'm not going to focus on them.
this is my vote count checker that I made for D1 and D2. I'm putting the D2 one because reveals shit and I was kinda tired of thinking about it. the one interesting movimentation can be seen in the VII spot. before that, D2 was a crapshoot with several small wagons and no real focus. three new players voted Lalendra from VI from VII. knowing it was a mislynch, there's definitely scum there. the only movement other than quick/chisa/fial jumping on Lalendra is Maki starting a wagon on Flub and Comm voting Chisa.
the point being: scum wasn't being threatened. there was no clear reason for the pile up on Lalendra. what I think about it is that there's definitely 1 scum off the wagon, maybe even 2. but the D1 chart is much more interesting. tomorrow I'll put it.
so this post is kinda shit, but kinda not.
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 4:47 pm
by Chisa Yukizome
lucca ftr mine (and iirc everything after) was 100% "regardless of alignment here I don't want a fucking no lynch" so I don't think that's a reasonable read
I wanna think / wait for a certain person to post before I post more thoughts
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 5:21 pm
by Aubrey
In post 1206, lucca261 wrote:how quickly he misdirected to Chisa her own suspicion.
By defending myself, and stating that scum could be killing a direct threat, OR potentially setting up a frame kill?
--
Awoo did a poor job in hiding whether or not she was a mason. Unless scum are dense, that was not a power-role check, but rather an intentional kill with the hope of an after-effect. NK15 only talked about three people (
start of day I forgot he went after Chisa
). That is not a lot of people, and a relative small pool of info for people to look into.
So
.... few suspects, short and easy ISO, it isn't shocking why people would quickly assume he was onto something after an early death. Now look at the slots in question, Me, Chisa, and Epic. You have 2 slots who have had a healthy dose of suspicion, and were easy lynch targets going into today, and myself who was highly against the Lalendra slot who has now flipped town.
Pre-night 2: Epic and Chisa are slots who were likely going to face scrutiny going into tomorrow due to poor performance. It doesn't make sense from a scum point of view for them to really kill off someone like NK15 who has only gone after 3 people in order to relieve pressure form their slots. Then you have me and everything I said in Post 1186 who has sat damn pretty this whole game. What's one person (
who can't even fight back when questioned
) really going to do to me, especially when I'm not even his main target? The night kill just doesn't make a lot of sense for any of us to make to me.
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 5:22 pm
by Aubrey
In post 1207, Chisa Yukizome wrote:I wanna think / wait for a certain person to post before I post more thoughts
hi?
Posted: Thu Nov 23, 2017 6:25 pm
by Flubbernugget
You're over analyzing the fuck out of this dude
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2017 6:35 am
by CommKnight
Prodge for today.
Gotta get some time tonight hopefully before bed. My laptop screen is cracked so I gotta use the TV hookup to even play. Got a laptop on order to arrive Monday though so will be good by next week.
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2017 7:30 am
by Chisa Yukizome
I meant comm but I'm not waiting for him to finish prodging so
