In post 22, Harambey180 wrote:I think they'd spread it out a bit as in one does the talking and the other stays quiet.
Ah, you explained a bit more. Why do you think they'd spread it out?
Because in my eyes, the scum team wants to have influence on the way the game goes. They won't if they stay quiet, so at least one of them is likely to have a big role in the game.
Don't think that both of them would be active from the start, unless they're putting up a show so big that we're gonna think both are Town.
Although now that I'm on that part...
Why would they not both start the game's first interaction?
Well as you could tell from my response it's made at least one of them suspicious.
That's why I think only one of them is scum. Then it's 1v1 and if it swings in favor of scum then they're havin a good start.
Bambi and sheep are NOT both scum, because their 1v1 interaction in the game is very likely to make one of them suspicious.
Bambi and sheep are also NOT both Town, because assumably scum wants some sort of influence in the game. Having one person in that 1v1 is good for influence. Also if scum are lucky then the other one of the two (the Townie) is going to be suspected while the actual scum isn't.
@Mumble
Does this make sense to you or do you think it's differing from this?
harambey, dont you see the possibility that bambietta and i both randed town, and we were the only ones online when the game started so we just had a conversation
I do usually banter with friends when I come into games. Friends or... Well known individuals. I don't know if that's AI, but it's just something you should know.
In post 30, sheepsaysmeep wrote:harambey, what do you find risky about thinking we could be t/t
i find it very likely
Well grab your calculator. The chances of you two both being town is just 1/6, and if you'd leave me out that's still just 3/10. Purely statistically it's very unlikely actually.
Also I explained that scum is expected to want to have input. There is a possibility that both of you are Town but it's unlikely. Given the reasoning I already gave you, it's almost a certainty that you and Bambi are SvT.
If you have a different look at the situation, please tell us yours. You only said you found t/t likely but you stopped there. Also you had a reason to question me (you had differing opinions), if you are going to question another player's thought process you oughta explain your own too.
Why is it necessarily overaggressive.
Also why is it PoE here. Especially so early on in the game, and with UCV not having made a single post, I'm really wondering why you think it's PoE.
Why is it necessarily overaggressive.
Also why is it PoE here. Especially so early on in the game, and with UCV not having made a single post, I'm really wondering why you think it's PoE.
the confidence is just bad
then "probably the partner" is forced
you are either obvtown or almost as good at scum as i am. bambietta is likely town so it's sort of poe
In post 28, Harambey180 wrote:@Mumble Does this make sense to you or do you think it's differing from this?
It makes sense, but I disagree. While their 1v1 ended up making one of them suspicious, I don't think that it necessarily had to have. Nor, do I think that it's a good reason to eliminate the possibility that both are scum (or town).
In post 24, Mumble wrote:Do you think activity is alignment indicative? I'll give you active lurking can be, but do you think that overall activity is?
Could you point out what you found overly aggressive, and hash out your POE for me.
In post 33, sheepsaysmeep wrote:harambey, dont you see the possibility that bambietta and i both randed town, and we were the only ones online when the game started so we just had a conversation
I see the possibility that you both randed scum as well.
In post 24, Mumble wrote:Do you think activity is alignment indicative? I'll give you active lurking can be, but do you think that overall activity is?
Did you miss this?
Well I'm kind of in a struggle with that. I've had two mafia games previously (won't go too much into detail). One of them taught me that activity is good for catching scum and the other game said that's invalid here.
So I can't really give a good answer to that.
But then again I was just talking about lurking. Lurking usually is either scum or a PR but as there are no 'Power Roles' here I assumed that lurking is more likely to be scummy. Correct me if I'm wrong on this.
