Mafiascum.net

This game is like..... Super slow......

Okay, since this game isn't going anywhere....

In post 26, Ircher wrote:Okay, since this game isn't going anywhere....

Out of {Not_Mafia, Hiraki, RadiantCowbells}, who do you want gone the most at the moment?

RC's discard is pretty unlikely to be coming from scum. It's a strong card for any anti-Town role, especially for a player who has a reputation for being dangerous as scum and is likely to be policy checked. Why do you think this is a good place to vote?

I want to hear Hiraki's response to my question in 16 before I comment on him.

I'm already voting for NM.

@Ircher I'm curious. Why bodyguard for discard?

Excluding when I was in a Hydra with someone who wanted scum I've never picked scum in greater idea or greatest idea.

Actually I think I chose scum once because my cards made all my town options shit but I had really good scum options. Sole time it happened.

@CeeJay, why did you discard Supersaint?

Brassherald's discard feels like it has a town motivation on the surface as with Not_Mafia's considering the Reflexive aspect but that could also mean that there were better roles out there aka doesn't really tell us much. LaserGuy's discard doesn't say much either, simply because the role is problematic for the user.

I also want to hear the why Hiraki discarded Mason because It can be useful potentially having someone else you can trust and to discuss with. Guacamole's discard feels like it has town motivation. And RC's discard places them as being most likely town. (At this moment, I'd put RC & Guacamole as being most likely town)

In post 32, GeminiTwin12 wrote:@CeeJay, why did you discard Supersaint?

Supersaint ability is that it kills the player that places the hammer vote on you. Not very good imo.

I doubt you can pull town motivations out of discards. Anyone who chooses their cards would select the one that they feel is most useful. I'm only going to call it towny if the discard is a particularly strong card for a non-town alignment, like Mafia Godfather.

In post 26, Ircher wrote: Out of {Not_Mafia, Hiraki, RadiantCowbells}, who do you want gone the most at the moment?

Curious why you chose these 3 to focus on for your question.

In post 29, ceejayvinoya wrote:@Ircher I'm curious. Why bodyguard for discard?

I drew three town cards. Bodyguard isn't that great tbqh.

In post 36, guacamole wrote:

In post 26, Ircher wrote: Out of {Not_Mafia, Hiraki, RadiantCowbells}, who do you want gone the most at the moment?

Curious why you chose these 3 to focus on for your question.

Not_Mafia because they can be annoying to read at times. But I find the discard townie, so......
Hiraki because their discard doesn't really feel that town-motivated.
RadiantCowbells because they can occasionally be very annoying person to work with.

The next person to post (other than the mod) scum-claims.

I declare myself the mod

In post 39, Ircher wrote:The next person to post (other than the mod or Not_Mafia) scum-claims.

EBWOP.
(An exclusion is made for Not_Mafia because they would post just to foil this.)

In post 39, Ircher wrote:The next person to post (other than the mod) scum-claims.

In post 41, Ircher wrote:

In post 39, Ircher wrote:The next person to post (other than the mod or Not_Mafia) scum-claims.

EBWOP.
(An exclusion is made for Not_Mafia because they would post just to foil this.)

So, this is you claiming scum?

In post 33, GeminiTwin12 wrote:Brassherald's discard feels like it has a town motivation on the surface as with Not_Mafia's considering the Reflexive aspect but that could also mean that there were better roles out there aka doesn't really tell us much. LaserGuy's discard doesn't say much either, simply because the role is problematic for the user.

There were better roles and I also never want to be mafia.

So, mafia goon was a good discard so that I could be town and get a PR.

In post 42, LaserGuy wrote:

In post 39, Ircher wrote:The next person to post (other than the mod) scum-claims.

In post 41, Ircher wrote:

In post 39, Ircher wrote:The next person to post (other than the mod or Not_Mafia) scum-claims.

EBWOP.
(An exclusion is made for Not_Mafia because they would post just to foil this.)

So, this is you claiming scum?

Bye bye scum; you knew what I meant.

In post 35, ceejayvinoya wrote:I doubt you can pull town motivations out of discards. Anyone who chooses their cards would select the one that they feel is most useful. I'm only going to call it towny if the discard is a particularly strong card for a non-town alignment, like Mafia Godfather.

I see what you're saying, though it helps give you somewhere to start (inferences, feelings, reactions). and it also depends on the card (sometimes not just Mafia Godfather)

In post 43, brassherald wrote:

In post 33, GeminiTwin12 wrote:Brassherald's discard feels like it has a town motivation on the surface as with Not_Mafia's considering the Reflexive aspect but that could also mean that there were better roles out there aka doesn't really tell us much. LaserGuy's discard doesn't say much either, simply because the role is problematic for the user.

There were better roles and I also never want to be mafia.
So, mafia goon was a good discard so that I could be town and get a PR.

Now, still nothing extremely AI but still worth noting going forward. (consistency)

In post 35, ceejayvinoya wrote:I doubt you can pull town motivations out of discards. Anyone who chooses their cards would select the one that they feel is most useful. I'm only going to call it towny if the discard is a particularly strong card for a non-town alignment, like Mafia Godfather.

VOTE: cj

Think this is scum discrediting perfectly good reasoning to keep the Lynch pool open.

In post 44, Ircher wrote:

Kill: LaserGuy

In post 47, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 35, ceejayvinoya wrote:I doubt you can pull town motivations out of discards. Anyone who chooses their cards would select the one that they feel is most useful. I'm only going to call it towny if the discard is a particularly strong card for a non-town alignment, like Mafia Godfather.

VOTE: cj

Think this is scum discrediting perfectly good reasoning to keep the Lynch pool open.

I agree with this.

VOTE: cj

.