A notable error I made was giving Golden_Robster a vanilla town pm, an error I only realized after they had replaced out (though I'm confident I would have caught onto it at night when thinking about receiving night actions). I notified their predecessor. Ultimately, I don't think this had a big impact on the game.
Thanks Not_Mafia for replacing in, you replaced into a really rough position
I ran this as a pre-designed game, meaning I was given the setup, daytalk was my decision however (though it was either everyone had daytalk or nobody did)
In post 796, Garmr wrote:My gut says gamma is town from earliest interactions. But being on every leading wagon it wouldn't surprise me if flipped scum.
Why do people I want to be town flip scum.
GG all
Game really picked up for me when gustavo left.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:35 pm
by popopopopopopo
jesus i forgot about gustavo
what a tool
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:39 pm
by Krazy
Do you guys think my fakeclaim (Town-informed Hider) was implausible from an objective pov? I feel like I still have a hard time understanding what does or does not make for a plausible fakeclaim in this site meta. Like what am I supposed to do when roles sound like "loyal neighborizor"... I kinda went out of my way to make my fakeclaim sound more convoluted just because it seemed like every claim was weird and limited but that really backfired.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:44 pm
by Garmr
In post 2162, Krazy wrote:Do you guys think my fakeclaim (Town-informed Hider) was implausible from an objective pov? I feel like I still have a hard time understanding what does or does not make for a plausible fakeclaim in this site meta. Like what am I supposed to do when roles sound like "loyal neighborizor"... I kinda went out of my way to make my fakeclaim sound more convoluted just because it seemed like every claim was weird and limited but that really backfired.
When you said informed I pretty wanted you gone, if you are town I would confirm a slot, if you were scum it's another win. Also it's very uncommon and with Gustavo which is also a weird role it was less believable. I wanted to do all my cases through before you were lynched I only got to do bujab.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:45 pm
by Garmr
In post 1566, UnrealSeal wrote:goddammit the instant I go on V/LA to recover is the instant I get put to L-1
Well claim time, so buckle down gents.
I am a
Mason Even-Night Rolecop
. My Mason partner is
Krazy, who is a Mason 3-Shot Bulletproof
which is why I'm not exactly hung up about revealing him. Still kind of stings but eh.
I was planning on investigating Garmr tonight in order to confirm his alignment but that plan's probably shot to hell now since I've probably got a target on my back now.
So this is probably my last post of the game or at least till I'm off V/LA.
I leave everything to Krazy and his capable hands, I'm sure he'll steer this town to victory. Please listen to him.
And finally,
Lynch Akarin.
So glad we went through with this lynch.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:47 pm
by Krazy
I wish he hadn't said 3-shot bulletproof, I would have claimed mason if he hadn't made it totally unbelievable
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:50 pm
by Krazy
I guess optimal day 1 would have been to try to lynch Gustavo through his claim, but I kinda feel like there's no way I anticipated town having this much power. I saw three goons and thought this game was going to be based on playing around Gustavo, I don't see any way I anticipate three other fairly strong TPRs with what we had.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:57 pm
by Garmr
Yeah I felt even through limited town had a lot of power.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 9:05 pm
by Music
Wooooo GG guys! This was supposed to be me trying to play outside my usual meta, only to get called out on being me lol. But with this game gone, I'm done to only two active games left before I take a break
This was fun to play in, even if I barely knew what was happening most of the time lol. Glad I could help lynch all of the mafia lol.
Nah you helped town out a lot you stopped a potential mislynch, got yourself lynched and got krazy on the chopping block eventually.
Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 10:16 pm
by Garmr
Also while scum lost this game I feel like gamma's slots and krazy did well. If not for day 1 Krazy and his interaction with james and him pushing for akarin while trying to keep unreal seal alive. He may of been in my town list. It's just those two slip ups.
Gamma was chill he just needed to avoid jumping on every major lynch.
Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:46 am
by BuJaber
And not flake out.
Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:54 am
by BuJaber
People who said it's townsided are probably right.
We weren't a bad town per se, but we had way too many personality clashes. Like I've never seen a game where the outcome was decided in no small part by the fairly quiet people voting for the right person at the right time.
Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:43 am
by Garmr
can we have the mafia thread I want to know what the mafia must of thought through the early messy phase of the game.
