Micro 830: DoY II: Plato's Symposium! Lyncher/Inquisitor Win

[InfernoBrafin]

Inferno says:
Going to go out on a limb here and say the scumteam is Carmen/Carcalilly.

Will explain more when I have time.

[Carcalilly]

mass claim mass claim

[Aristophanes]

VC 1.1

Krazy

(2): BrightEyedFish 13, Carmen 15

Carmen

(2): Krazy 5, MariaR 68

BrightEyedFish

(1): InfernoBrafin 7

Not Voting

(2): Carcalilly, FA_Q2 23

Day 1 will last until a hammer is dropped or Tuesday, November 8/18 at 6pm.
Whichever comes first.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Mod Notes:

Nada

[Carmen]

James:
Yep, Fa_Q2 is townlocked for me.
Krazy, would you tell me some about your meta? How do you play as town? Scum? PR?

You're locktowning him... after four posts?

[Carmen]

wtf are you sure it's a 3 scumteam

I only vaguely know fa_ scum and they haven't posted enough for me to tell

Also Carmen wagon is so random

And yeah there's no way it's a 3 scum scumteam

OK the more I read it over the more it seems like Carmen was using a hyperbole and not actually serious or thinking about that number

VOTE: Carcalilly

[Carmen]

Mini, don't want to see a hammer happen suddenly. Did not realize 4 ends in a hammer aright away. Still want to see a response here.

Yeah, the three person scumteam is going to quickhammer me on page two.

Why mention a number in the scum team here? I have heard that statement a thousand times in various forms here but I don't think that anyone has ever said something so awkward as 'the three person scum team' like this. It just does not fit.

I thought yours was the only vote on me. Concern over a quickhammer seemed ridiculous.

[Carmen]

If you aren't seeing Carcalilly scum here, you aren't looking hard enough.

[Carmen]

Because there's no guarantee Maria is the only one with flavor-name related mechanics. If Maria says she already has the real name, then there is no reason to tell a potential third party or scum the real flavor name.

Krazy is probably town for his concern over revealing flavor info. Scum have more info about the setup and what roles there are, and in the first place are probably less concerned about potential malicious actions against them unless it's some kind of investigation.

[Carmen]

Also townleaning Inferno.

[Carmen]

I can claim if you want given my action has to happen n1.
I know someone is (put flavor here) as I'm not saying what flavor that is but I need to decide if I want to kill that player night 1 or give them x bps

The fact that there's apparently a role that can kill someone night one is reason for pause. Can this setup really end night one if you misvig someone?

[Carmen]

BEF is a gut scumlean but I have no doubts I can clarify that better given time.

[Krazy]

It's a bastard, this game could have ended in pre-game LOL

Carmen what do you think of FA_Q? tbh his unvote post bothered me. But I also don't have a great track record in reading him. Usually I incorrectly scumread him because he's too aggressive. Now I'm scumreading him because he's too passive. But maybe he's just always scummy? idk

[Carmen]

I think everything he's said about me has been terrible, but in more of a personal sense than in a scum-indicative sense. He's null for me so far otherwise.

[Carmen]

It's a bastard, this game could have ended in pre-game LOL

Is it? Hadn't realized. I remember that this is apparently the second in some series but I can't find the first game to see what that setup was like.

[Carmen]

What do you think of Carcalilly and why isn't it a scumread?

[Krazy]

Krazy and FA looks very town to me from recent scum meta

And yeah I don't mind massclaiming flavor

I guess the thing that most puzzles me here is by what metric FA is town here

I don't know that FA is lockscum for me but I don't understand how Carca reaches this conclusion based on meta

Carca are you making up meta or is there actually something you're thinking of here?

[Krazy]

I'm thinking about Carca.

[Krazy]

I'm a little worried she's too scummy to be scum here, but don't hold me to that.

[Carmen]

I'm a little worried she's too scummy to be scum here, but don't hold me to that.

Thinking like that will lead you straight away from the correct solution nine times out of ten.

[Krazy]

Is it possible your game has any of the following bastard roles or mechanics? Indeed, this will be bastard.

[Carmen]

Oh, wonderful, even more nonsense to deal with.

No offense to the mod.

[Krazy]

BEF is a gut scumlean but I have no doubts I can clarify that better given time.

I don't think BEF votes me in RVS as scum tbh

it's possible he wants to come at me more aggressively this time, but I wouldn't count on it

[Carmen]

I don't understand the connection.

[Krazy]

I lynched him fairly recently in a recently completed game and I think the manner in which I did so left an impression.

I keep wanting to do this and now I think I'm going to do it

Vote FA_Q

Hope he's not like Profii and is just someone I'm always thinking is scum but never is

[Carmen]

What's your read on me?