Mafiascum.net

In post 5971, Creature wrote:

In post 5951, DrewVa wrote:

In post 5948, DrewVa wrote:There simply are certain slots that I excel at reading, Nero, Creature are amongst them and people would be wise to listen to me on that.

In. b4 Creature disputes this with YGM. It took me awhile to discern all of the obvious towntells but I did get there eventually.

Who is YGM?

In post 1172, Something_Smart wrote:I couldn't point to specific posts (other than you complaining about long quotes for short responses which I know is NAI but I still appreciate), but in my catchups your posts have felt pretty genuine.

In post 5968, Creature wrote:

In post 5936, Cheeky Dancer wrote:

In post 5774, RCEnigma wrote:Cool, can we chop creature in half now?

Agreed.

If that would mean Elsa not getting lynched, sure.

In post 5917, UnaBombaH wrote:

In post 5781, The Last Knight wrote:Or we could wait a day so that I can give Profii his fruit back. In that case, we could lynch Elsa or BEF today.

I might just be too out of the loop to understand this, but how does it conf.town you, if you "give profii his fruit back"?
I fail to see how scum!TLK couldn't give a fruit to town!profii.
Or Scum!TLK to scum!profii.
Hell, I don't even think profii is scummy, but it could even be town!TLK giving it to scum!profii.
What do we confirm/decide with you giving a fruit to profii tonight?

In post 5975, DrewVa wrote:

In post 5971, Creature wrote:

In post 5951, DrewVa wrote:

In post 5948, DrewVa wrote:There simply are certain slots that I excel at reading, Nero, Creature are amongst them and people would be wise to listen to me on that.

In. b4 Creature disputes this with YGM. It took me awhile to discern all of the obvious towntells but I did get there eventually.

Who is YGM?

You’ve Got Mail

In post 5929, profii wrote:

In post 5917, UnaBombaH wrote:

In post 5781, The Last Knight wrote:Or we could wait a day so that I can give Profii his fruit back. In that case, we could lynch Elsa or BEF today.

I might just be too out of the loop to understand this, but how does it conf.town you, if you "give profii his fruit back"?
I fail to see how scum!TLK couldn't give a fruit to town!profii.
Or Scum!TLK to scum!profii.
Hell, I don't even think profii is scummy, but it could even be town!TLK giving it to scum!profii.
What do we confirm/decide with you giving a fruit to profii tonight?

The fruit return is one element of the situation that bugs me -

we know scum can interfere with the fruit so it has essentially lost its value - why offer to give it to me, even if I try to give it to secret loyal dude, scum can stop us - so it's pretty much always going to be a fruitless endeavour from now on ha ha

In post 5964, Cheeky Dancer wrote:If you guys are seeing a town creature then you must be considering a scum Unah? I could even see that as SvS tbh.

~ C

In post 5974, Xtoxm wrote:yeah S_S is scum
this is one of the most egregious cases of lack of read evolution ive ever seen
and hes seen my scumgame in worst idea, he really has no right calling me scum here
if we're lynching outside of TLK i can purge this

In post 5984, RCEnigma wrote:

In post 5974, Xtoxm wrote:yeah S_S is scum
this is one of the most egregious cases of lack of read evolution ive ever seen
and hes seen my scumgame in worst idea, he really has no right calling me scum here
if we're lynching outside of TLK i can purge this

On top of that he comes off with the typical unengaged scumread list with multiple lynchable slots whom have already been pushed and then the one townread slot that they know won't gain traction but might get them towncred for pursuing.

I kind of want to give Creature a townread if S_S flips scum. I think it was Nancy said Creature never buses but NK's normal saw a fair bit of Day 1 scum theater and I wouldn't totally clear him off of it. It would look better though.

In post 5985, The Last Knight wrote:Thanos is absent right now but I did read the Thanos and DrewVa interaction late D1 to be SvT, in no particular order. DrewVa is more of a town read for me now, especially with Thanos lurking today. I'd love to get their input on this but it isn't the worst counterwagon I've heard today.

In post 5987, The Last Knight wrote:And SS is scum until they prove otherwise at this point for me. They're coasting too comfortably for me to be okay with it. I do appreciate the dedication to the game when it comes to replacing out, but that just makes me feel like they want to skate by without having to contribute.

I'm mainly just asking for more from them. Then I'll reaS_Sess (reassess).

In post 5990, RCEnigma wrote:I mean it should be on TLK but I digress.

In post 5883, DrewVa wrote:Null side

Davesaz
The Last Knight
RCEnigma
BrightEyedFish
Thanos
UnaBombah
Kokichi Oma
Something_Smart

Scum side

who should be moved up or down?

-d

In post 5992, Something_Smart wrote:If TLK is going to be the lynch I'm fine with hammering him if that's what people want.

In post 5988, DrewVa wrote:

In post 5985, The Last Knight wrote:Thanos is absent right now but I did read the Thanos and DrewVa interaction late D1 to be SvT, in no particular order. DrewVa is more of a town read for me now, especially with Thanos lurking today. I'd love to get their input on this but it isn't the worst counterwagon I've heard today.

Whose? Us or Thanos? Our vote is currently on Elsa but DVa has given me permission to switch to SS. I prefer either Elsa or SS but I want to trust Creature on Elsa, so I guess I’ll switch to SS.