Posted: Thu Aug 08, 2019 7:47 am
by Gamma Emerald
Spoiler: thoughts on every title
Krazy - Kat
No, there's definitely better.
Zaphkael - Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Maybe? Need to look at this one again.
Gamma Emerald - Undiscovered
I don't know if this one fits me, and even if it does I think it can be worded better because imo there's a username pun that can represent this.
Firebringer - Roar (From "Trail Blazer")
Idk thinking about the Pokémon move itself
RedFlavor - You Better Know
What?
SleepyKrew - Did His Job (From "Snark Attack")
I'm fine with the new or old one rn.
Creature - Of Habit (From "Transparent")
Worth considering.
singletonking - Plays Mafia
No, too generic.
Ankamius - Taking Back the Town
Ankamius - Stop Killing Yourself
Out of these two I prefer "Stop Killing Yourself".
Cheetory6 - Colorful
I think it fits.
McMenno - Aren't we all
Idk the real merit of this one.
Pine - Chopped Down (From "In Your Head")
Nah, I like "In Your Head". Reminds me of the concept presented by Russell Hantz from his Survivor performances of the "Russell seed".
Skygazer - Let's Get To Know...
This is going to become outdated if SkyG doesn't have the position anymore, so no.
Maruchan - passportent
I think this one had a reason to it, but idk what it was.
TheWayItEnds - Someone Dies
Good idea, but does it fit?
Irrelephant11 - In the room (From "COTM 2018 Winner")
Why not? I like it.
Ircher - What A Grand Idea
Maybe? Aside from cfj he's the most frequent poster in the Grand Idea thread and I recall Ircher modding a game with this title.
Inferno390 - Host of Hosts
Why does this fit Inferno?
Chemist1422 - Stable Reaction
If if's more than a username pun sure.
PenguinPower - Pongwin
No. Dude doesn't even have the avatar it is based on.
xzzzy - xwvut (From "comical third option")
I feel "comical third option" fits his personality better.
RadiantCowbells - Beat It (From "Smooth Criminal")
RadiantCowbells - People tried (From "Smooth Criminal")
Either kinda fits but I'm actually leaning towards "people tried"
Raskolnikov - Thanks
Bleh, feels generic.
BulletNLynchproof - Mods/Reviews Games (From "Micro Madness")
Same as singletonking's title.
animorpherv1 - No longer mostly noise (From "Honey Trap")
No, Honey Trap is still good.
Elbirn - Content Aficionado
Didn't Elbirn say he liked it? Also in the "warring nations of mafiascum" thread Elbirnsort of accepted his position as the meme police so I think this is good.
BuJaber - Not Even My Final Form
What?
Nancy Drew 39 - Passionate
Maybe? Could fit others too.
Gorkington - Better than Cheetory6
Probably not.
Pink Ball - Better than pinturicchio
Pink Ball - pint-sized powerhouse
I like pint-sized powerhouse. It references his main and also could describe the initial character he was representing (he initially had a Knife Kirb avatar)
Niko - Still Discovering Myself
Idk
Severa - Better than RadiantCowbells
Pass, same reasons as Gorkington. Plus something I'll get to later.
Bitmap - Old, not Outdated
I guess? Could fit others too.
TemporalLich - Lavos
I mean it works but there might be better. In this case it seems right to let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
Vengaboys - Up And Down
Maybe?
Katyusha - Red Death
I like this. Fits their economic philosophy and imo they are pretty good at scumhunting, this being death for red Role PMs.
Tsuchinoko - Venomous and Dangerous
What?
Jingle - Ring a Bell?
Maybe? Was there a non username based reason for this?
xofelf - Generally an Angel (From "Miss Mash")
I forget the reason for this one.
Bins - Not Trash
I like this one a bit.
RCEnigma - Not the Cowbell
I think this could be fleshed out better.
Blake Belladona - Taking Back the Town
Don't know if it works.
Mumble - Hardly Heard
I think this fits, but I think it breaks the "rewarding bad actions" rule for the main title fairy thread (in reference to lurking)
MaryJoLisa - That's Not My Name
I recall seeing it said that MJL actually has to say this so sure.
momo - Most Mislynchable
I think it kinda works for their play, plus it works off the username (
INAUFTA - INATFTA
Okay? I'll get to this later.
Keychain - Creates Words
What?
Vijarada - Grumpy
I mean Vijarada said it fits?
Something_Smart - Somewhat_Balanced
Uhhh maybe not. Could fit others.
Plotinus - Wise Words
How does this fit?
Bambi Jay - Confusion and Chaos
I think better exists.
Yume - Can I Be Here?
I feel the same for this as I do for Mumble.
Nimueh - Siren Song
What?
Fire Assassin - Lava Plume
Reasoning?
MewThree - Better than Mewtwo
Meh. Will get to this later.
itlepip - It'll click
Don't think the reasoning works?
123456789 - Numbers
I mean he frequently gets called that but is it a good title?
T-Bone - Spites the haters
T-Bone - disappointed
T-Bone - Has a steak in the site
T-Bone - A Cut Above
Obviously in favor of the one I suggested.
Iconeum - Spy
Maybe.
Jesus Louisus - Soulreader
I think it actually fits because of the "Jesus" part.
chennisden - not to be taken seriously
What's the reasoning?
Fluminator - Peace-loving Police Officer (From "Best LSG/MishMash Player (Mashtermind)")
What?
CheekyTeeky - Sneeky
Maybe?
Korina - Recruiter
Totally support this.
Aronis - Just here fore the Pagetop!
This works. But why does it say "fore"?
mastina - Mason
This is under deliberation in the title fairy thread so no vote for it here.
Alisea - Is A Username Pun
Uhhh this isn't even right.
Prince of Renais - Restoration King
This is where all the "I'll talk about it later"s are pointing to. If we want to pass this one I think all memey roleplay "alts" should get a title. I put alts in quotes because imo Kokichi Oma also fits that type of account but idk I'd it's an alt.
mallowgeno - Not late to the party
Fits with their Mish Mash presence imo. I'm for it.
No, there's definitely better.
Zaphkael - Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Maybe? Need to look at this one again.
Gamma Emerald - Undiscovered
I don't know if this one fits me, and even if it does I think it can be worded better because imo there's a username pun that can represent this.
Firebringer - Roar (From "Trail Blazer")
Idk thinking about the Pokémon move itself
RedFlavor - You Better Know
What?
SleepyKrew - Did His Job (From "Snark Attack")
I'm fine with the new or old one rn.
Creature - Of Habit (From "Transparent")
Worth considering.
singletonking - Plays Mafia
No, too generic.
Ankamius - Taking Back the Town
Ankamius - Stop Killing Yourself
Out of these two I prefer "Stop Killing Yourself".
Cheetory6 - Colorful
I think it fits.
McMenno - Aren't we all
Idk the real merit of this one.
Pine - Chopped Down (From "In Your Head")
Nah, I like "In Your Head". Reminds me of the concept presented by Russell Hantz from his Survivor performances of the "Russell seed".
Skygazer - Let's Get To Know...
This is going to become outdated if SkyG doesn't have the position anymore, so no.
Maruchan - passportent
I think this one had a reason to it, but idk what it was.
TheWayItEnds - Someone Dies
Good idea, but does it fit?
Irrelephant11 - In the room (From "COTM 2018 Winner")
Why not? I like it.
Ircher - What A Grand Idea
Maybe? Aside from cfj he's the most frequent poster in the Grand Idea thread and I recall Ircher modding a game with this title.
Inferno390 - Host of Hosts
Why does this fit Inferno?
Chemist1422 - Stable Reaction
If if's more than a username pun sure.
PenguinPower - Pongwin
No. Dude doesn't even have the avatar it is based on.
xzzzy - xwvut (From "comical third option")
I feel "comical third option" fits his personality better.
RadiantCowbells - Beat It (From "Smooth Criminal")
RadiantCowbells - People tried (From "Smooth Criminal")
Either kinda fits but I'm actually leaning towards "people tried"
Raskolnikov - Thanks
Bleh, feels generic.
BulletNLynchproof - Mods/Reviews Games (From "Micro Madness")
Same as singletonking's title.
animorpherv1 - No longer mostly noise (From "Honey Trap")
No, Honey Trap is still good.
Elbirn - Content Aficionado
Didn't Elbirn say he liked it? Also in the "warring nations of mafiascum" thread Elbirnsort of accepted his position as the meme police so I think this is good.
BuJaber - Not Even My Final Form
What?
Nancy Drew 39 - Passionate
Maybe? Could fit others too.
Gorkington - Better than Cheetory6
Probably not.
Pink Ball - Better than pinturicchio
Pink Ball - pint-sized powerhouse
I like pint-sized powerhouse. It references his main and also could describe the initial character he was representing (he initially had a Knife Kirb avatar)
Niko - Still Discovering Myself
Idk
Severa - Better than RadiantCowbells
Pass, same reasons as Gorkington. Plus something I'll get to later.
Bitmap - Old, not Outdated
I guess? Could fit others too.
TemporalLich - Lavos
I mean it works but there might be better. In this case it seems right to let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
Vengaboys - Up And Down
Maybe?
Katyusha - Red Death
I like this. Fits their economic philosophy and imo they are pretty good at scumhunting, this being death for red Role PMs.
Tsuchinoko - Venomous and Dangerous
What?
Jingle - Ring a Bell?
Maybe? Was there a non username based reason for this?
xofelf - Generally an Angel (From "Miss Mash")
I forget the reason for this one.
Bins - Not Trash
I like this one a bit.
RCEnigma - Not the Cowbell
I think this could be fleshed out better.
Blake Belladona - Taking Back the Town
Don't know if it works.
Mumble - Hardly Heard
I think this fits, but I think it breaks the "rewarding bad actions" rule for the main title fairy thread (in reference to lurking)
MaryJoLisa - That's Not My Name
I recall seeing it said that MJL actually has to say this so sure.
momo - Most Mislynchable
I think it kinda works for their play, plus it works off the username (
Momo, Mo
st Mislynchable)INAUFTA - INATFTA
Okay? I'll get to this later.
Keychain - Creates Words
What?
Vijarada - Grumpy
I mean Vijarada said it fits?
Something_Smart - Somewhat_Balanced
Uhhh maybe not. Could fit others.
Plotinus - Wise Words
How does this fit?
Bambi Jay - Confusion and Chaos
I think better exists.
Yume - Can I Be Here?
I feel the same for this as I do for Mumble.
Nimueh - Siren Song
What?
Fire Assassin - Lava Plume
Reasoning?
MewThree - Better than Mewtwo
Meh. Will get to this later.
itlepip - It'll click
Don't think the reasoning works?
123456789 - Numbers
I mean he frequently gets called that but is it a good title?
T-Bone - Spites the haters
T-Bone - disappointed
T-Bone - Has a steak in the site
T-Bone - A Cut Above
Obviously in favor of the one I suggested.
Iconeum - Spy
Maybe.
Jesus Louisus - Soulreader
I think it actually fits because of the "Jesus" part.
chennisden - not to be taken seriously
What's the reasoning?
Fluminator - Peace-loving Police Officer (From "Best LSG/MishMash Player (Mashtermind)")
What?
CheekyTeeky - Sneeky
Maybe?
Korina - Recruiter
Totally support this.
Aronis - Just here fore the Pagetop!
This works. But why does it say "fore"?
mastina - Mason
This is under deliberation in the title fairy thread so no vote for it here.
Alisea - Is A Username Pun
Uhhh this isn't even right.
Prince of Renais - Restoration King
This is where all the "I'll talk about it later"s are pointing to. If we want to pass this one I think all memey roleplay "alts" should get a title. I put alts in quotes because imo Kokichi Oma also fits that type of account but idk I'd it's an alt.
mallowgeno - Not late to the party
Fits with their Mish Mash presence imo. I'm for it.
VOTE: T-Bone - A Cut Above
VOTE: RadiantCowbells - people tried
VOTE: Ankamius - "Stop Killing Yourself"
VOTE: Cheetory6
VOTE: Korina
VOTE: mallowgeno
VOTE: Aronis
VOTE: Jesus Louisus
VOTE: Vijarada
VOTE: Momo
VOTE: Katyusha
VOTE: Pink Ball
VOTE: Elbirn
