Large Normal 223 | New Beginnings | GAME OVER

[texcat]

Well played scum! Can't wait to see the scum thread; why did y'all kill the traitor?

[AaronFrost]

I do like the idea of scum having visitors to mess with watcher/tracker results but something to counter all the town power would've been nice (preferably not on our traitor either). I'm not a setup designer though

I think we thought he was some kind of PR in disguise? I honestly don't remember. Somehow none of us picked up on the 'Benedict Arnold' thing.

[Titus]

We were utterly convinced that Garmr was the traitor. I even told Garmr Rick was on our side when he made that push.

I figured Benedict Arnold was a trap. No traitor would be that obvious.

[Garmr]

So I was basica traitor traitor.

[Garmr]

basically a traitor traitor.*

[Flavor Leaf]

You freakin’ confirmed my fake doctor shot on Carcalilly then backtracked after the ascetic.

Like, for some reason I had my doubts that you were the traitor after that, but yeah, hindsight Gobbledygook was obv traitor. Sheeping me on Eevee.

That was a fun game. Yeah, back up mod would have fixed everything in regards.

I was fine with the setup. I don’t necessarily care if I play in a setup that leans one way or another, just don’t have a broken setup, and I don’t believe this was broken by any means.

I’m very much about scum making bold plays, though.

[Flavor Leaf]

Release the PT’s!!!

[Flavor Leaf]

You will see

“i think I’m fruit fucked”

In the mafia thread. Spoiler.

[Flavor Leaf]

I swear Garmr was gonna catch me, though

[Flavor Leaf]

In my nightmares I see myself and the rest of town too stubborn to lynch scum!Dalton because even though he's scummily glazing by, it's not "scum indicative for him" or some shit.

To be fair, Rick’s actions thus far are par for the course. If we have a vig he or she should just kill Rick.

Youknow I’ve only been vigged once when I was town? Wait, no, twice.

In my near 6 years on site.

Also, this is scummy of Gobbledygook, because he acts like I’m Vig worthy when just about every “par for the course” game I’ve had with him, i’ve Been town with a correct solve. This might only be a sample size of one, but I hard pushed him when he was a SK, Something I have a lot of accuracy and result doing. Check Tttt in Pokemon Upick.

Also, he states par for the course like I’ve played more than one game with him.

hard FOS: Gobbledy

For that blatant chop at me

In my nightmares I see myself and the rest of town too stubborn to lynch scum!Dalton because even though he's scummily glazing by, it's not "scum indicative for him" or some shit.

To be fair, Rick’s actions thus far are par for the course. If we have a vig he or she should just kill Rick.

Exactly why I am having anxieties right now

I think there’s a high likelihood for a vig or an SK given the size of this game. Our prayers may be answered yet.

Hilarious how this gets brought up after I claim doctor.

This and in case I needed to backtrack my claims is why i killed Gob

[Flavor Leaf]

This would have been a good booneytoonz game

[Gamma Emerald]

Another fucky scum numbers game and I end up on the losing side AGAIN
And like I might have avoided claiming if 1) it wasn’t JJD who freaking called me out and 2) if Carca didn’t ham it up way too hard early

[davesaz]

So much facepalm play by town pr.

LUV I was hard on you but you showed class in owning up to the issues. Just stick to the promise to mod only when you do have the time.

I should push hunches more. Ricks play was correct for scum, which is what I meant by that one comment. But I have a hard time attacking a soft claimed doc. Titus totally fit my scumtells for her but I let it slide because of honoring RL. In both cases the gut reaction should have overridden the canonical play.

[Garmr]

I swear Garmr was gonna catch me, though

was thinking it I was like scum aren't touching him for a reason.

[profii]

What a mess ha ha well done scum

[profii]

Hehe I expected 4 scum, I had Aaron and Rick at the point I died, didn't really get Titus but everyone in the dead thread was on it and we didn't have spoilers so not sure how it all went so wrong. Meh

[bob3141]

I think the biggest reason town lost is that we simply couldnt come togather on one lynch. How many times were players scum reading titus but couldnt come together on his lynch at the same time. Think it would have been a different story if had managed to get titus lynched day 6. We had the votes but not at the same time

[bob3141]

I picked titus satrt of day but when hi wagon wasnt moving. I did flip between aaron and eve and got the wrong one first

[bob3141]

I picked titus start of day but when his wagon wasnt moving i got very impatient. So then I did a flip between aaron and eve and got the wrong one first.

[Garmr]

I think the biggest reason town lost is that we simply couldnt come togather on one lynch. How many times were players scum reading titus but couldnt come together on his lynch at the same time. Think it would have been a different story if had managed to get titus lynched day 6. We had the votes but not at the same time

Yeah I don't understand why town didn't lynch titus she was obvious scum and I don't think any town was stupid enough to town read her. I sensed something was off when titus town read me then did a 180 after the traitor flip.

[Titus]

I sensed something was off when titus town read me then did a 180 after the traitor flip.

Truth, it did flip because you were not the traitor but being your usual town self. Instead of using this though, you picked a fight with me, failed to submit an action that gave me cover, and refused to reset your reads.

If scum mistake you for the traitor, what does that mean about your reads as a whole?

[bob3141]

Thats actualy why i town read garmr at the start. Though start of today i did get bit paranoid about garmr but knew for sure titus and garmr were in 1v1

Although i found it confusing when scum killed billy then carc. I was thinking unless scum have roleblocker then why woudl they risk rick blocking the kill going after billy. Then if they have a roleblocker why not get rid of me before carc. As they can kill him when ever they want. Those macho made ricks claim everso believable as I thought they wouldnt put something in game without a reason. But alas rick was scum.

[Garmr]

I sensed something was off when titus town read me then did a 180 after the traitor flip.

Truth, it did flip because you were not the traitor but being your usual town self. Instead of using this though, you picked a fight with me, failed to submit an action that gave me cover, and refused to reset your reads.

If scum mistake you for the traitor, what does that mean about your reads as a whole?

I don't know depends on what they are mistaken me for. End game I had the scum bar rick early game was a mess.

I did pick up on gamma and a few other townies as town through. So if I were to say anything about my reads I'd say averagish, If I were going to talk about my play this game meh at best because I stopped caring.

[Garmr]

Long twilight,lack of vca,terrible set up,lots of replacements I just didn't want to play which is why I wanted lynched. Replacing out would be a burden on who ever took my slot.

[gobbledygook]

We were utterly convinced that Garmr was the traitor. I even told Garmr Rick was on our side when he made that push.

I figured Benedict Arnold was a trap. No traitor would be that obvious.