Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Morning Tweet]

[Seriously impressive modding job by Temporal, i'm looking thru the mod PT rn. So many moving parts]

[chkflip]

Let Lich know what you thought about the flavor.

gg TL. That'll do, Lich. That'll do.

[Chateau Lobby]

@Bingle & Titus

I didn't expect to lose you both so suddenly. But it was a pleasure aliening around with you two!

[TemporalLich]

The Grand Idea thread is here: Grand Idea Mafia

Feel free to add insane, crazy, or ridiculous roles there to make the next game of Grand Idea even more fun to play.

Grand Idea roles could be something simple like a Town Seer Doctor, something strange like a Town RC Hobbyist, something weird like a Mafia Delayed Vanillaizer, something crazy like an Electrified Werewolf Festival Starter, or even something insane like a Chaos Rerolljester.

[Chateau Lobby]

i was getting more paranoid of my MT townread by the day

My plan was hoping for this and somehow getting to a 3p lylo with you and MT. Then hoping you would get paranoid or question your MT read.

I was not too far away from that so that makes me feel a little better.

[Chemist1422]

[MT!!!!!!]

[Starbuck]

So all of those nights where there was a no kill, Porkens and I assume that we got effed by Yellow Cards.

[Hayasaka]

I like to imagine I helped, good job town!!

[Ircher]

Thanks for modding TemporalLich.

[TemporalLich]

Let me know if you'd be interested in any other Grand Idea mutations.

Of course, anyone can run Grand Idea GPick if they want to, it's open enough for anyone to run it.

[Starbuck]

I really wish I had started this game from the beginning.

TemporalLich, please consider me a /pre-in moving forward or even a co-mod.

[Bingle]

Thanks for the game, TL.

I think the only real thing I disagreed on was your parsing of the Effort saver. I would definitely have interpreted that role as being roles that specifically end the game when they win, like showstopper lyncher or bomber.

Otherwise it's just a bad role, which, tbf, is a thing that happens in GIDEA all the time. Also, I probably would have let the infinite dayvig through since it being gamebreaking is dependent on it also gamethrowing.

[Bingle]

Also, my scumteam was great and I enjoyed the uphill battle with you guys.

[Morning Tweet]

[MT!!!!!!]

[Chem!!!!!!!! Great choice of crumb!]

[callforjudgement]

The Jester Infinite Dayvig is gamebreaking because they can ally with a groupscum team in order to cause both teams to win. It isn't like it's a hard role to confirm, either.

[TemporalLich]

Effort Saver was one of the roles that were ambiguously worded, the narrow scope interpretation would have been close to a Vanilla in power.

And yeah a Jester Infinite Dayvig is basically a Kingmaker scenario in a role.

[Bingle]

Effort Saver was one of the roles that were ambiguously worded, the narrow scope interpretation would have been close to a Vanilla in power.

And yeah a Jester Infinite Dayvig is basically a Kingmaker scenario in a role.

Infinite dayvig jester can't autowin that way, though, because they can't trust a scumteam claim post them having confirmed themselves to actually be telling the truth (What if it's masons or just town yolo-ing to try and win?) and no scumteam is going to out prior to them fully confirming themselves. It drastically changes the game in what is potentially an unfun way, but isn't gamebreaking necessarily. It does probably autowin by holding the town hostage to lynch it on D1, but as it isn't showstopping that's just super meme-y. Hence the gamebreak strategy being gamethrowing. Also I think your interpretation for effort saver was probably the most technically correct one, although I think it's neither the intent of the role or a fun role to include.

Your choices were completely fine, though, I was just sharing my thoughts on what I would have done differently. I think you did a great job modding what is a naturally chaotic game type.

[farside22]

Glad to see town win. The lack of info amd deaths really made me start hating this game.

[Titus]

I want to give an honorable mention to CL. Fighting on in those circumstances was rough.

I think in general the aliens got boned by the lack of nightkills by mafia and the wolves. Then they both ganged up on the aliens. I suspected my death was coming, so we used my loverize to take out two targets. Also, that loverize role PM needs to be a lot clearer. I almost got misexecuted for that and it wasn't my fault in the slightest.

[Starbuck]

Please remember that the lack of nightkills was probably due to Yellow Cards. It wasn't like we weren't trying.

[Porkens]

My shame at my twilight confession is s only matches by my pride in Town Green Glass Door Alien Reroll Sympathyzer Werewolf JoaT.

[Chemist1422]

[MT!!!!!!]

[Chem!!!!!!!! Great choice of crumb!]

[beautifully done follow-through]

[TemporalLich]

A PT has been released!

Porkens x Looker PT - Pink Sun Lounge

[Porkens]

I wish I had had the guts to just ask for coordination in that PT. Looker would you have gone for that if I had confessed and asked to coordinate?

[TemporalLich]

All PTs have been released!

Mafia PT - Dark Hideout
Werewolf PT - Sacred Link
Alien PT - Celestial Starship
Neighbourhood PT - Friendly Neighbourhood
farside22 x Ircher PT - Blue Sun Suite
Starbuck x Iconeum PT - Orange Sun Condo