Open 796: Haunted Village Game Over

[MURDERCAT]

Well we have a counter claim between Isis and Dunn and one has an independent guilty on them and the other has an independent inno on them.

[Gamma Emerald]

I feel you on that. Sometimes I just need things explained to me like I'm five, I'm sorry. Also, what benefit is there even in having a fast day? Can we like... slow our roll a little here?

Yeah, it seemed like everyone was okay with D2 ending when it did but I don’t want two quick days in a row

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah I agree

[Gamma Emerald]

Well we have a counter claim between Isis and Dunn and one has an independent guilty on them and the other has an independent inno on them.

Both of which are assumed. And Dunn

also

has a point in it not making sense that scum would pick banshee with just one protective in the game (a healer or some amount of commuters) . Like, my entire body is wanting me to go in so many directions rn.

[Infinity 324]

UNVOTE: Ok we can talk about stuff. I am actually more suspicious of gamma than xof, mainly cause of his play today. Though maybe it's just cause I expect townies to all be confident when it's likely town wins and gamma doesn't seem to be. I would like to hear his reads, because he seems to be throwing shade at a lot of people.

[MURDERCAT]

Well we have a counter claim between Isis and Dunn and one has an independent guilty on them and the other has an independent inno on them.

Both of which are assumed. And Dunn

also

has a point in it not making sense that scum would pick banshee with just one protective in the game (a healer or some amount of commuters) . Like, my entire body is wanting me to go in so many directions rn.

Dunn's claim implies there is another commuter who didn't claim though because trickster is 1 point

[Gamma Emerald]

Well the thing is I’m doubtful this is going to be a town win. Especially with you trusting MCat for ??? reasons, when I find MCat rather suspect

[MURDERCAT]

Do you not think Isis is scum?

[Infinity 324]

Well the thing is I’m doubtful this is going to be a town win. Especially with you trusting MCat for ??? reasons, when I find MCat rather suspect

Gamma if I'm town murder is town. Promise.

[xofelf]

Isis's claim fits the math, right? And Dunn's makes things extra weird. And I'm curious what he means about the team being one he wouldn't pick. Like to me that doesn't clear him of shit really. It *is* weird, but with all the Witchhunter's we've had revealed wouldn't their choices be to try to counter those? I'll admit trying to figure out how roles fit together is not something I'm good at, but something here feels super fucking weird, and I'm not sure what that is.

[Infinity 324]

Why does scum!dunn cc isis here when we were basically gonna clear him?

[Gamma Emerald]

@MOD can scum pick roles freely within their power limit or do they have to pick their limit’s worth?

I did mix up the setup but maybe I mixed it up in a way that was accidentally correct?

[Gamma Emerald]

Well the thing is I’m doubtful this is going to be a town win. Especially with you trusting MCat for ??? reasons, when I find MCat rather suspect

Gamma if I'm town murder is town. Promise.

I don’t trust this AT ALL.

[MURDERCAT]

Isis's claim fits the math, right? And Dunn's makes things extra weird. And I'm curious what he means about the team being one he wouldn't pick. Like to me that doesn't clear him of shit really. It *is* weird, but with all the Witchhunter's we've had revealed wouldn't their choices be to try to counter those? I'll admit trying to figure out how roles fit together is not something I'm good at, but something here feels super fucking weird, and I'm not sure what that is.

Roleblocker and role cop counters the WH's no? The only thing that I think is off is strongman instead of godfather, but maybe 2 commuters is enough of a reason? I mean I probably would have gone godfather, but I see why they would go strongman. I think 3 JOATs is just kinda a trash setup because it's basically impossible for scum to play around. :/

[Infinity 324]

Well the thing is I’m doubtful this is going to be a town win. Especially with you trusting MCat for ??? reasons, when I find MCat rather suspect

Gamma if I'm town murder is town. Promise.

I don’t trust this AT ALL.

You think I'm wrong or scum?

[xofelf]

No, you're not wrong on that Infinity, that would be a very ridiculous play from scum, and I don't think Dunn is that kind of weird as a player. What I mean is more, okay if that is what's up, then what does that mean exactly?

And Cat, I'm asking because even though I've read the wikipage like 5 times, I keep having to reread it because I keep not parsing why things work how they do. Not that I think it's impossible or anything like that, more hi, I'm dumb.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think you’re scum versus wrong, because if it’s a scenario where your wrong I don’t understand why MCat is the person you’re being wrong about. You behaved in a very specific way to me early that you don’t seem to have followed through on.

[Gamma Emerald]

I probably would have gone with avenger instead of strongman and tried to blast some WHs

[Infinity 324]

No, you're not wrong on that Infinity, that would be a very ridiculous play from scum, and I don't think Dunn is that kind of weird as a player. What I mean is more, okay if that is what's up, then what does that mean exactly?

We probably have 1 other commuter in the setup (or maybe another 1-point PR). Scum probably took strongman to have healer as a safeclaim.

I think you’re scum versus wrong, because if it’s a scenario where your wrong I don’t understand why MCat is the person you’re being wrong about. You behaved in a very specific way to me early that you don’t seem to have followed through on.

Do you want to elaborate on this?

[MURDERCAT]

Isis come back

[Gamma Emerald]

Hi everyone! I've been following this game and all I know is that murdercat is town.

Going to reread a bit and give my reads soon, since I might have a lot of null reads I'll give possible town and scum narratives for those players so people can tell where my head is at, at least.

How confident was this at the time? What were you seeing from MCat?

[Isis]

I'm running errands and still skimming.

If the numbers say a PR is fake that would mean PlusJOYED fake guiltied a partner, which is a thing that happens in games. I would be a little disappointed in my townread so I hope someone miscounted.

I don't have my macro when I'm phoneposting in parking lots MURDERCAT

[MURDERCAT]

Ok come back soon <3

I think plus scum fake guilty is unlikely to say the least.

[Gamma Emerald]

The problem I see with Plus!scum is the fact he has a a clear train of thought and hasn’t been CCed for the Taylor vig I think. Only reason I can see for making that move would be if scum had Rolecopped Exorcists N1 and killed them and got lucky.

[MURDERCAT]

I'm also not sure if that is technically possible given that Taylor died, anyone want to think through that for me?