Quacks of Quedlinburg | Game over

[Felissan]

It's beautiful.

Original Roll String: 1d20

1 20-Sided Dice: (11) = 11

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Black 1
10	Green 1
11	Red 1
12	Blue 1
13	Red 2
14	Blue 1
15	Blue 2
16	Red 1
17	Green 1
18	Black 1
19	Green 2
20	Blue 2

[Felissan]

See? I told you! The streak of Bomb 1's was a way to bring in a single good roll. Yeah.
Rolling for the Blue 1...

Original Roll String: 1d19

1 19-Sided Dice: (8) = 8

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Black 1
10	Green 1
11	Red 1
12	Red 2
13	Blue 1
14	Blue 2
15	Red 1
16	Green 1
17	Black 1
18	Green 2
19	Blue 2

[Felissan]

It's a Green 1, that I'm definitely keeping.

Original Roll String: 1d18

1 18-Sided Dice: (16) = 16

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Black 1
10	Red 1
11	Red 2
12	Blue 1
13	Blue 2
14	Red 1
15	Green 1
16	Black 1
17	Green 2
18	Blue 2

[Felissan]

Whoa, did a Black 1 just come out of my bag? I didn't know this was even possible!

Original Roll String: 1d17

1 17-Sided Dice: (6) = 6

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Red 1
10	Red 2
11	Blue 1
12	Blue 2
13	Red 1
14	Green 1
15	Black 1
16	Green 2
17	Blue 2

[Felissan]

A premature red, oh well.

Original Roll String: 1d16

1 16-Sided Dice: (11) = 11

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Red 1
10	Red 2
11	Blue 1
12	Blue 2
13	Green 1
14	Black 1
15	Green 2
16	Blue 2

[Felissan]

The first Orange 1, coming in just slightly too late.

Original Roll String: 1d15

1 15-Sided Dice: (6) = 6

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Red 1
9	Red 2
10	Blue 1
11	Blue 2
12	Green 1
13	Black 1
14	Green 2
15	Blue 2

[Felissan]

A better-timed Red 1.

Original Roll String: 1d14

1 14-Sided Dice: (6) = 6

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 2
4	Bomb 3
5	Orange 1
6	Green 1
7	Red 1
8	Red 2
9	Blue 1
10	Blue 2
11	Green 1
12	Black 1
13	Green 2
14	Blue 2

[Felissan]

That puts me at 5 bombs, and at risk of exploding. Gonna wait a bit here.

[vincentw]

Rerolling!

Bombs: 3

Original Roll String: 1d8

1 8-Sided Dice: (5) = 5

Spoiler: Bag

1. Bomb 2
   
   
2. Bomb 3
   
   
3. Orange 1
   
   
4. Black 1
   
   
5. Black 1
   
   
6. Blue 1
   
   
7. Bomb 2
   
   
8. Bomb 1

[vincentw]

And I'll wait.

[Snakes]

Inspiratieloos draws a

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

and a

Bomb 2

and moves 4 spaces in his cauldron. Felissan draws a

Blue 1

,

Green 1

,

Yellow 4

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Green 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Black 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Black 1

,

Red 2

,

Blue 1

,

Blue 2

,

Orange 1

and

Bomb 2

and moves 12 spaces in her cauldron. Vincentw draws a

Bomb 2

and moves 2 spaces in his cauldron.

Cauldron

Spoiler:

Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players	Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players
0	0	No		21	6	No
1	0	No		21	6	Yes
2	0	No	Felissan Start	22	7	No
3	0	No	Felissan rat	22	7	Yes	Vincentw (13.5)
4	0	No		23	7	No
5	0	Yes	Vincentw Start	23	8	No
6	1	No	Inspiratieloos Start	24	8	No
7	1	No	Farren Start	24	8	Yes
8	1	No	Farren rat, Vincentw rat	25	9	No
9	1	Yes		25	9	Yes
10	2	No		26	9	No
11	2	No		26	10	No
12	2	No	Inspiratieloos (4.5)	27	10	No
13	2	Yes		27	10	Yes
14	3	No		28	11	No
15	3	No	Felissan (9.5)	28	11	Yes
15	3	Yes		29	11	No
16	3	No		29	12	No
16	4	No		30	12	No
17	4	No		30	12	Yes
17	4	Yes		31	12	No
18	4	No		31	13	No
18	5	No		32	13	No
19	5	No		32	13	Yes
19	5	Yes	Farren (9.5)	33	14	No
20	5	No		33	14	Yes
20	6	No		35	15	No

Farren

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Yellow 1
8	Black 1
9	Blue 1
10	Yellow 2
11	Red 4

Spoiler: Chips Played

Green 1

,

Orange 1

,

Green 4

,

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 2

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Red 2

,

Orange 1

,

Bomb 1

Victory Points:

15

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

0

Vincentw

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 3
2	Orange 1
3	Black 1
4	Black 1
5	Blue 1
6	Bomb 2
7	Bomb 1

Spoiler: Chips Played

Blue 1

,

Green 1

,

Yellow 4

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Green 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Black 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Black 1

,

Red 2

,

Blue 1

,

Blue 2

,

Orange 1

,

Bomb 2

Victory Points:

11

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

1

Felissan

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Red 1
7	Red 2
8	Blue 1
9	Blue 2
10	Green 1
11	Black 1
12	Green 2
13	Blue 2

Spoiler: Chips Played

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Blue 1

,

Green 1

,

Black 1

,

Red 1

,

Orange 1

,

Red 1

,

Bomb 2

Victory Points:

15

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Empty

Rubies:

0

Inspiratieloos

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Orange 1
10	Black 1
11	Blue 2
12	Red 1
13	Red 4
14	Orange 1
15	Blue 2
16	Purple 1
17	Red 2
18	Bomb 1

Spoiler: Chips Played

Bomb 1

,

Blue 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Bomb 2

Victory Points:

18

Bombs:

4

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

1

[Farren]

Okay, I just want to wait for Farren since he's the other one who posts the bag. And yes, you should reroll.

Hm. I'd be okay with players being allowed to choose their method as long as:
1) The player posts their bag consistently with every roll;
2) The method they use to update their bag is consistent; the player should not switch between methods. (Example: always use the "removed/returned chips go to the end" method; always use the "removed/returned chips go back to the slot they were in" method. Pick one, stick with it, and be clear from the start which method you're using.)
3) Moderator-posted bags override player-posted bags, regardless of which method is used;

I think that makes it a bit easier to stick with the 'once you draw it, it's yours' principle without violating the 'players should have accurate information to base their decisions off of' principle.

If a player doesn't post their bag, then the default method (Snakes's method) should apply as usual.

[Farren]

Hard to judge based on making life easier here, though - with Blue chips, it's easier to leave it in place. With Yellow chips, it's easier to put it back at the end. With the Potion, it depends on if the bag is updated in between drawing the chip and using the potion or not.

[Snakes]

I would be fine with letting players post their bag. It doesn't really matter what method is used as long as it's clear what the dice roll means.

[inspiratieloos]

Original Roll String: 1d18

1 18-Sided Dice: (15) = 15

[inspiratieloos]

Original Roll String: 1d17

1 17-Sided Dice: (14) = 14

[inspiratieloos]

Original Roll String: 1d16

1 16-Sided Dice: (13) = 13

[inspiratieloos]

Original Roll String: 1d15

1 15-Sided Dice: (2) = 2

[Snakes]

Inspiratieloos draws a

Black 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Purple 1

and a

Orange 1

and moves 4 spaces in his cauldron.

It is now turn 9. Inspiratieloos has drawn a chip and must now decide if he wants to stop or continue.

Cauldron

Spoiler:

Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players	Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players
0	0	No		21	6	No
1	0	No		21	6	Yes
2	0	No	Felissan Start	22	7	No
3	0	No	Felissan rat	22	7	Yes	Vincentw (13.5)
4	0	No		23	7	No
5	0	Yes	Vincentw Start	23	8	No
6	1	No	Inspiratieloos Start	24	8	No
7	1	No	Farren Start	24	8	Yes
8	1	No	Farren rat, Vincentw rat	25	9	No
9	1	Yes		25	9	Yes
10	2	No		26	9	No
11	2	No		26	10	No
12	2	No		27	10	No
13	2	Yes		27	10	Yes
14	3	No		28	11	No
15	3	No	Felissan (9.5)	28	11	Yes
15	3	Yes	Inspiratieloos (8.5)	29	11	No
16	3	No		29	12	No
16	4	No		30	12	No
17	4	No		30	12	Yes
17	4	Yes		31	12	No
18	4	No		31	13	No
18	5	No		32	13	No
19	5	No		32	13	Yes
19	5	Yes	Farren (9.5)	33	14	No
20	5	No		33	14	Yes
20	6	No		35	15	No

Inspiratieloos

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Orange 1
10	Blue 2
11	Red 1
12	Red 4
13	Blue 2
14	Red 2

Spoiler: Chips Played

Bomb 1

,

Blue 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Bomb 2

,

Black 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Purple 1

,

Orange 1

Victory Points:

18

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

1

[inspiratieloos]

Original Roll String: 1d14

1 14-Sided Dice: (4) = 4

[inspiratieloos]

Blue 2

Original Roll String: 1d13

1 13-Sided Dice: (7) = 7

Original Roll String: 1d12

1 12-Sided Dice: (9) = 9

[inspiratieloos]

I'll take the Red 4

[Snakes]

I'll take the Red 4

You actually drew a

Blue 2

and a

Bomb 3

. Which one do you want to add to your cauldron, if any?

It is now turn 10. Farren and Felissan have already drawn chips and must now decide if they want to stop or keep going. Inspiratieloos must decide what to do with his blue chip and then decide if he wants to stop or keep going.

Cauldron

Spoiler:

Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players	Buys	Victory Points	Ruby?	Players
0	0	No		21	6	No
1	0	No		21	6	Yes
2	0	No	Felissan Start	22	7	No
3	0	No	Felissan rat	22	7	Yes	Vincentw (13.5)
4	0	No		23	7	No
5	0	Yes	Vincentw Start	23	8	No
6	1	No	Inspiratieloos Start	24	8	No
7	1	No	Farren Start	24	8	Yes
8	1	No	Farren rat, Vincentw rat	25	9	No
9	1	Yes		25	9	Yes
10	2	No		26	9	No
11	2	No		26	10	No
12	2	No		27	10	No
13	2	Yes		27	10	Yes
14	3	No		28	11	No
15	3	No	Felissan (9.5)	28	11	Yes
15	3	Yes		29	11	No
16	3	No		29	12	No
16	4	No	Inspiratieloos (9.5)	30	12	No
17	4	No		30	12	Yes
17	4	Yes		31	12	No
18	4	No		31	13	No
18	5	No		32	13	No
19	5	No		32	13	Yes
19	5	Yes	Farren (9.5)	33	14	No
20	5	No		33	14	Yes
20	6	No		35	15	No

Farren

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Yellow 1
8	Black 1
9	Blue 1
10	Yellow 2
11	Red 4

Spoiler: Chips Played

Green 1

,

Orange 1

,

Green 4

,

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 2

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Red 2

,

Orange 1

,

Bomb 1

Victory Points:

15

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

0

Felissan

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Red 1
7	Red 2
8	Blue 1
9	Blue 2
10	Green 1
11	Black 1
12	Green 2
13	Blue 2

Spoiler: Chips Played

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Blue 1

,

Green 1

,

Black 1

,

Red 1

,

Orange 1

,

Red 1

,

Bomb 2

Victory Points:

15

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Empty

Rubies:

0

Inspiratieloos

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Red 1
8	Orange 1
9	Orange 1
10	Red 1
11	Red 4
12	Blue 2
13	Red 2

Spoiler: Chips Played

Bomb 1

,

Blue 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Green 1

,

Bomb 2

,

Black 1

,

Bomb 1

,

Purple 1

,

Orange 1

,

Blue 2

Victory Points:

18

Bombs:

5

Potion:

Full

Rubies:

1

[Farren]

Okay, this is where we left off. Bag's been updated using Snakes's last update; chip tracker looks like it's still good. Just had the wrong stopping point. 1/11 chance of exploding, which is very much ungood. I can still Potion, but I still have two Yellow chips as well that could theoretically remove that Bomb.

I think we risk it.

Farren

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Black 1
7	Yellow 1
8	Black 1
9	Blue 1
10	Yellow 2
11	Red 4

Chips Played: Start 7, Rat 1, Green 1, Orange 1, Green 4, Bomb 1, Bomb 2, Bomb 1, Green 1, Red 2, Boost 1, Orange 1, Bomb 1 <--- 20 Buys, 5 VPs

Bombs:

5

Original Roll String: 1d11

1 11-Sided Dice: (5) = 5

[Farren]

First black chip, which may at least mildly inconvenience someone even if it doesn't help me much. 1/10 chance of exploding; potion is no longer helpful.

Farren

Spoiler: Bag

Dice number	Chip
1	Bomb 1
2	Bomb 2
3	Bomb 3
4	Orange 1
5	Green 1
6	Yellow 1
7	Black 1
8	Blue 1
9	Yellow 2
10	Red 4

Chips Played: Start 7, Rat 1, Green 1, Orange 1, Green 4, Bomb 1, Bomb 2, Bomb 1, Green 1, Red 2, Boost 1, Orange 1, Bomb 1, Black 1 <--- 20 Buys, 6 VPs

Bombs:

5

Original Roll String: 1d10

1 10-Sided Dice: (10) = 10