Situation Room [Game Over!]

[northsidegal]

oh, yeah. to be clear, ultimately i do think the setup is probably on the scumsided side, just that depending on play it can skew really hard in one direction or the other.

[OkaPoka]

plus dann was in one hood, bell was in hood, i was in one hood. hard to get a parity break if you are killing one hooders and that was forced because of early bussing basically

[northsidegal]

anyways here's my excuse to use this image again

[Dusa]

Woooooooo

[Dusa]

Why did the dead PT scumread me (

[Dusa]

Dannflor whyyy

[Dannflor]

Cupcake! Northsidegal tasked 13 of us the chore of damaging mafia! She gave 4 of us the task of damaging town! Gamma Emerald is very clearly mafia! That makes most of 13 people want to hurt him and all of four people not want to hurt him!

I hope that helps you understand why so many people are voting him!

It's less clear what you are!

this one post sent me on a spiral of paranoia

[Dannflor]

I thought you knew some tricks

[OkaPoka]

Isnt being scumread as town the best compliment one can give

[GuiltyLion]

I'm so happy Dusa wasn't scum lol, I kept thinking about all the times I felt certain we were on the same wavelength, it would have been top 10 anime betrayals for me if she were

[Dusa]

Being nightkilled is a compliment!!

[Dusa]

GuiltyLion probably posted 37 town indicative observations about me an 17 scum indicative observations about me!
So much stuff!!
I have no idea how he will replicate his town meta if he rolls evil in the future!

[Dusa]

Hades is not an anime!

[Dannflor]

Isnt being scumread as town the best compliment one can give

I do think we should be promoting less polarized play in general

although sometimes I feel like I'm playing trash as town and deserve the scum reads

[Bell]

I thought Dusa might've been scum because they didn't die. Uh, other than that I didn't have much to complain about with their play. Probably the most pleasant gimmick I've ever played with. Not just flavor, not just hunting a nice mix that could be genuinely amusing. Thanks for playing Dusa, you made me smile more than once this game.

[FakeGod]

I'm sorry guys

I played like garbage

[Dannflor]

you were pretty obv town! I think you were good

[Bell]

I'm sorry guys

I played like garbage

As an aside, related to reading the mod PT. I'm not sure where the tell originated, but I have a general feeling that scum don't like to appear incompetent. (I certainly don't) which results in them bussing and making more insightful commentary than they really should. You can sort of reverse this into a town read. For example, The more FG was wrong the more confident I was that he was town.

[Dusa]

Yuri! I enjoyed playing with you! I think I know your identity! But I will be polite!

[Bingle]

As an aside, related to reading the mod PT. I'm not sure where the tell originated, but I have a general feeling that scum don't like to appear incompetent. (I certainly don't) which results in them bussing and making more insightful commentary than they really should. You can sort of reverse this into a town read. For example, The more FG was wrong the more confident I was that he was town.

This is accurate in a lot of cases even for people who don't feel the need to be right. For example, I'm more than happy to be loudly wrong. But if I'm loudly right as scum and then flip, people are more likely to dismiss what I was saying.

It's my approach to mechplay as scum. Loudly argue what I think is the best town mechplay and then let town ignore it when/if I flip scum.

[T3]

I react really badly to pressure.

[Bingle]

Why did the dead PT scumread me (

I thought most of the tells people were using on you were personality instead of alignment and as such weren't a great reason to townread you. I had pretty solid reasons to townread basically everyone (I was locktowning FG/A50/GL at the end there and wouldn't have considered flipping any of the three). I was also pretty sold on Titus town based on the Yuri bus, although I like to think I would have reconsidered before endgame.

Basically, I was assuming you were playing a pretty solid scumgame, because that made the most sense to me.

OTOH, the comments from Yuri and GE in the deadthread did kind of make me think I was wrong on you, because they both heavily implied that there wasn't a well positioned deepwolf from the early game.

[Bingle]

GuiltyLion probably posted 37 town indicative observations about me an 17 scum indicative observations about me!
So much stuff!!
I have no idea how he will replicate his town meta if he rolls evil in the future!

GL's XLO wim is the stuff of legend.

I'm glad to have seen it twice and come out on top both times recently.

[Bingle]

anyways here's my excuse to use this image again

I think my only real complaint is the term distinction between the two phases (elim and kill).

I'd be interested in seeing it run the other way, as that turns what is a never bus setup into a setup where there is a clear upside and downside to bussing.

[Dusa]

Next time I will play on my main account! That way! Everyone will say, "she must be good, she is not good enough at mafia to be evil!"