Favorite Open Setups RESULTS

[Somnus]

Without further ado, here's the results for the Favorite Open Setups Poll. Thank-you to the 18 people who took the time to fill it out.

Spoiler:

The Coalition - 9
White Flag - 7
09:12 - 6
Fire and Ice - 5
Friends and Enemies - 5
Greater Idea - 5
Nightless Exploder Pandemonium - 5
PYP X/Y HoS_S - 5
Trust Fall - 5
Assassin in the Palace - 4
C9++ - 4
Diffusion of Power - 4
Guardians of the Fortress - 4
Jungle Republic - 4
Purgatory - 4
Twin Trap - 4
Chromavalon - 3
Forest Fire - 3
Lovers Mafia - 3
Nomination Mafia - 3
Pollock's Flag - 3
Would You Like To Be My Neighbor - 3
Carbon-14 - 2
Chosen Mafia - 2
Donner Party - 2
Hanahaki Disease - 2
Kill All Townies - 2
Masons and Mafia - 2
Near Vanilla - 2
Pick Your Poison - 2
Pick Your Power X/Y - 2
Popcorn Mafia - 2
Stack the Deck - 2
Two-Fold 2d3 - 2
Watchmen Wanted - 2
8-Ball - 1
Charge Me Up! - 1
CK9++ - 1
CultD3 - 1
Dayvig Deactivators - 1
Dead Silence - 1
Desperation Day - 1
Duck Duck Goose - 1
Hard Boiled - 1
Haunted Village - 1
Hope Plus One - 1
House Party - 1
Jungle Oligarchy - 1
Load the Deck - 1
Making Friends and Enemies - 1
Noir - 1
Noughts and Crosses - 1
Panic Room - 1
Polygamist - 1
Secrets of the Anuket Topaz - 1
Sharing is Caring - 1
The Council - 1
Tit For Tat - 1
Vanilla Nightless - 1
Vengecop - 1
We Need a Fifth - 1

[Irrelephant11]

Proposal: anything with 2 or more votes should be on the list of approved setups for first time mods, and most should be in the new "fast" queue in the Open Queue

[Irrelephant11]

thanks for doing this! fun results even if everyone is wrong

[Irrelephant11]

well, coalition is awesome. It's the rest of the list that's in a weird order, but

[Somnus]

It was my pleasure! If nothing else, I mostly just wanted to give current and future mods of open setups an idea of what tends to fill easily. It’s not a huge sample size that can be viewed as concrete evidence of anything, but it’s nice to have a little bit of data to work with.

[Something_Smart]

Proposal: anything with 2 or more votes should be on the list of approved setups for first time mods, and most should be in the new "fast" queue in the Open Queue

I think pretty much all of these setups are already eligible for the Rapid slot-- the only requirement is that the setup not be brand-new.

As for approval, a few votes of popularity isn't enough for that, but I'm sure the results here will inform what setups people choose to run. (Plus, some of these setups, such as Greater Idea and Assassin in the Palace, are clearly not fit to be approved.) We'll have to see how well they do in the queue, but I could easily see approving the likes of Friends & Enemies, Trust Fall, Diffusion of Power, etc. I considered NEP because of its recent popularity, but I'm not sure it's the kind of setup I really want new mods to be running.

And yeah, echoing the thanks to Somnus. I didn't want to do something like this because I didn't expect much turnout, but 18 responses isn't that bad, and I'm always happy to have more data to work with.

[Gamma Emerald]

Anyone who voted Jungle Republic has shit taste /hj

[DkKoba]

whoever voted white flag i wish you a very mountainous experience.

[DkKoba]

i see tbone and I were the only 2 people to vote Chosen mafia

[T-Bone]

I was the only one to vote Noughts and Crosses so everyone is getting banned now

[Alianna]

Farewell, Mafiascum!

[DkKoba]

I was the only one to vote Noughts and Crosses so everyone is getting banned now

wth i JUST finished the logo for the MS anniversary game ...

[T-Bone]

You were warned!