Open 864 Thread 3

[Not_Mafia]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

Look at this grovelling

[furtiveglance]

furitiveglance hurry up

The mod hasn't even set a deadline for this round

Okay but I got prodded

I think I'll take my time rather than cater to your desire to end the game.

[furtiveglance]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

Look at this grovelling

I did look at it. I actually like the grovelling, you should do some.

[ProfessorDrapion]

Mod, how long do I have to decide?

Sunday.

[furtiveglance]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

From your perspective, is Not_Mafia more obvious mafia than hutmeil?

[furtiveglance]

Mod, how long do I have to decide?

Sunday.

Got it.

[Not_Mafia]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

Look at this grovelling

I did look at it. I actually like the grovelling, you should do some.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89ZfbX4Rdzw&t=53s

[Nona1510]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

From your perspective, is Not_Mafia more obvious mafia than hutmeil?

Do you mean am I more surprised by hutmeil being scum? Both are equally obvious scum to me right now. If you’re asking about before the IC picks, then my best guesses at the other two vts were obscure and YoirHighness. If your asking which pick I was the most shocked at? Then yes, I would agree on NM.

[furtiveglance]

Prodding myself

[furtiveglance]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and

it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

Nona, what you're saying here is that it's obvious at least one IC chose wrong because N_M is here. But from your POV both hutmeil and N_M are mafia. Besides the very fact that we have a second round shows that at least one IC chose wrong. So the way you used N_M implies that you think N_M is more obvious mafia than hutmeil, that's why I asked the question.

[furtiveglance]

Well I know for a fact that NM and Nona are scum. So that GE gamble on NM was a bad decision. I don't know why she had to roll the dice there. As for Nona, I don't blame you for that since Nona was very townie. If I were IC I might have chosen her as well.

You might have chosen Nona? Would you or not? I'd expect you to have been thinking about this, were you?

Hutmeil?

[Nona1510]

Feeling a bit stuck at the moment.

Do you guys have any arguments that you think will help me?

I wish I could think of something that could help you.

I will try to think of something, hopefully.

All I can come up with right now is possible theories why scum chose me specifically. I think Bella trying to make you doubt you choosing me, was an obvious ploy to make you question your decision, just in case the other two ICs chose incorrectly and it’s obvious that at least one did, since Not Mafia is here.

From your perspective, is Not_Mafia more obvious mafia than hutmeil?

Do you mean am I more surprised by hutmeil being scum? Both are equally obvious scum to me right now. If you’re asking about before the IC picks, then my best guesses at the other two vts were obscure and YoirHighness. If your asking which pick I was the most shocked at? Then yes, I would agree on NM.

furtive, I know Gamma chose wrong because Not Mafia is here. No IC chose hutmeil. I don’t think Yume was vt in Auro’s thread, so that’s what I’m saying. I know both hutmeil and Not Mafia are scum, I’m obviously not certain that obscure is vt but that seems the most likely. Does that make what I’m saying cleaer to you or not?

[Nona1510]

What I’m saying is that I know for certain that both hutmeil and Not Mafia are scum, the same way I also know that Bella and Mala are also scum. All are equally obvious scum because I’m vt.

As for obscure, Yume, YourHighness, Galron, the best I can do is try to the best of my ability to guess their alignments and my best guesses are that the vts are most likely obscure and YourHighness, which if I’m right would obviously mean that Auro chose correctly but I don’t know that for certain. That’s why I said at least one IC chose incorrectly, because I actually know that Gamma did but I don’t know for sure if Auro did but I really don’t think so.

[hutmeil]

Hutmeil

Sorry got busy irl. I'll respond a bit later.

[ProfessorDrapion]

@furtive please make your final choice

[ProfessorDrapion]

If you wish for more time I can extend it for another while until this upcoming Saturday.

[furtiveglance]

VOTE: Nona

[furtiveglance]

Wp to hutmeil, sorry if wrong etc

[ProfessorDrapion]

Game Over

[ProfessorDrapion]

With the IC being the only IC to have chosen wrong not once but twice

Mafia has emerged Victorious!

Congrats to the team of:
YourHighness/Enchant
Galron
Hutmeil
Yume
Nona
Malakittens

[furtiveglance]

My bad guys

[ProfessorDrapion]

Also fun fact Klick pointed out in a DM.
Klick was right, Hutmeil was mechanically confirmed wolf.

[ProfessorDrapion]

This is what Klick sent me:
1. There is guaranteed 2 scum in {Nona, NM, hutmeil}
2. There is guaranteed 1-2 town in {Nona, NM, obscure}
3. There is guaranteed 1-2 scum in {hutmeil, obscure}


IF hutmeil is town, THEN Nona and NM are scum
IF hutmeil is town, THEN obscure is scum

That would mean Nona, NM and obscure are all scum.
But that can't be true, because there's guaranteed 1-2 town in {Nona, NM, obscure}
Therefore, hutmeil must be scum.

[furtiveglance]

Wow, didn't think of that

[ProfessorDrapion]

If you did, would you have just voted for Nona immediately or tried talking with Not_Mafia?