HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Eiralox]

Eira unvote is yucky

Screw you I'm voting Elements

[Eiralox]

Well. I'm voting Elements. Toffee and Elements wanting this hammer so bad and early?



..................................


..........................


Goooodbyyyeeeee.

[Eiralox]

Teams like Killing Joke/Elements/Toffee/Whatever very feasible here if Erynis is town.

Starting to think they are, as I did Day One.

Erynis, get in here if you can. There's sharks.

[Flea The Magician]

Right, I'm on the laptop, lets play catchup.

I have 22 pages to skim... I got some nyoom juice, and a full art Gengar and Dusknoir, Lets fire up Spotify and do this.

Todays song - Sonata Artica: The Vice

[Gimli]

UNVOTE:

[Eiralox]

Hey Flea!

Please tell me how fae feels about Elements putting Erynis at -1 whenever fae can.

[Elements]

I don't like Gimli or Eira

[Eiralox]

Me neither(Gimli is maybe okay). But we're crew.

[Eiralox]

I have like twenty chances at talking left.

So.


Anyone not thinking Elements is scum really need to be convincing about it at this point(Rat).

Erynis, if you're loyal, I really need to feel that.

-FIN-

[Gimli]

I don't like Gimli or Eira

Liar of course you like me

We're just different alignments this game

[Titus]

Eira should claim. Please don't hammer until I do a reads list tonight.

[Eiralox]

?

I'm not claiming.

We're not hammering Erynis.

You mean Erynis should claim?

No. They most definitely don't.

I wont ask Erynis too claim, at all.

Let Elements share their damned result before we force someone to claim on a flash wagon.

[Elements]

I don't like Gimli or Eira

Liar of course you like me

this is true

[HighPrincessErinys]

Huh, this one ISN'T dead yet.
This one is... interested, in how erratic Eiralox's play has been wrt this one and its wagon, and it can concur with the point of this being an absolute flashwagon too, and it can't help but feel town is going to regret ending the day

this

soon regardless of how it flips. Overall Eira is feeling rather towny because this one imagines scum would absolutely leap onto a E-2 easy mislim this early, and its certain there's scum even outside of its two prime suspects on the wagon.

[Elements]

VOTE: Eira

[Flea The Magician]

Spoiler: Number 9 of 11 little littermates

The self hammer was crap, understandable but still crap. That wagon has information, and lots of it. Flip doesn't surprise me. The counter wagon is always a good shot. Kinda surprised that went green ngl.

I received Black Spot.

I fucking won.

If this is serious, conftown for the day. Also potentially a scum favourable gamestate. I wonder if D1 was doomed for town, should probably look at the low posters of the day.

I think scum have at least one role blocker as well, FWIW.

Curious.

Eh, more interested in action Dan/flea rn? Eira seemed more buddy as scum but this is only on one games meta.

Interested in me why?

Flea defended passenger to me a lot without engaging in the meat of why I was worried? Like maybe a tmI?

Cool, noting this one. I feel this can lead to sorting you.

Why are you asking me questions?

Why are you town, Eiralox?

I'm a pirate. Why the asking?

your posting looks less meaty than a man that's been devoured by piranhas

Oof burn. Heya Gamma, nice entry sequence.

Spoiler: Rotten apples all the way!

[

Eira, I've liked Elements posting.

Fair they just haven't felt right to me at any point so that's where my mind's at.

As I was so cosmically wrong on Fenrir I'm willing to be open though, at least on most of ya'll.

You are striking me a someone who should be a consistently strong player, you have a lot of confidence in what you're posting - I am liking this post, but I do find myself wondering if you're as strong a poster as scum, and I get the feeling you should be in an overall better position when it comes to talking to others and directing town. Like I don't feel you're in the position you should be and while this is probably NAI overall I am really curious about it.

[snip]I very much know that there has to be at least one mutineer in Flea/Joke/Elements. I'm just not sure who or how to approach that yet, but here I am saying it anyway.

Curious again on whom you're thinking is the most likely.

I also missed this post.

Sorry, as well as Kj. They sifted weird role related reasons std was scum and walked them back and like, no one challenged. So it's even weirder that action Dan's top scum reads are in people who didn't make an impact day one, and let's the people who should've made an impact a town pass?!?

P-edit I'm not sure about eira. I feel both flea and kj were narrative forming yesterday

What sort of narrative? Working with or against each other? To what goal?

Theatre is a thing, yeah? I think I'd flip kj first but like....is that what scum wa r us to do?? *Tinhat*

While yes, theatre is a thing - do you think Nancy is the sort of person to emotionally invest so hard against me as theatre? Even when tinfoiling? I ask Nancy because I'm a known Role Player and acting is something I do in my games so I absolutely can, and given you don't actually know me asking if you believe I'd do that to someone is irrelevant.

I'm interested to see KJ's reaction to these flips when they return, I think that will be quite telling

Joker and I had allof therse (or mostly Joker) expectations and none of themcame to pass.

I didn’t expect either to flip town.

~Harley (last one was as well.)

Speaking of, Harley this is one hell of a limp in. I'm hoping there's more to come after this.

The cards for Day and Night 2 are as follows:

D2-1:

Eight of Swords

- Negative thoughts, self-imposed restriction, imprisonment, victim mentality.

D2-2:

The Devil

- Shadow self, attachment, addiction, restriction, sexuality.

D2-3:

Three of Wands

- Progress, expansion, foresight, overseas opportunities.

N2:

Two of Pentacles

- Multiple priorities, time management, prioritisation, adaptability.

The Ace of Pentacles from yesterday seems to have revealed it's play: The opportunity was the passing of a passenger, Passenger. More on that later, as for today... No doubt the crew is feeling a bit ashamed and guilty about the deaths of two loyal crewmembers, so the Eight of Swords certainly fits. The Devil and His negativity too will hinder us it seems, and the dark sides of the crew coming to light. Finally, the Three of Wands and Two of Pentacles feel somewhat linked. At the end of the day, perhaps some progress in the crew's favor will be made, or a prescient play will be made, and then when night falls it'll be up to the town to follow up on what is revealed by it. Hard to say exactly.

...As for Fenrir and Passenger. This one is starting to heavily question KJ, and Joker

in particular, and how much of a help they really are to the crew

when both of their suspects turned out to be good and true crewmen...

Are you suggesting to policy us?

*sigh*
By your own admission, two of us who "should" know your meta are independently thinking you're not town.

Spoiler: Littermates, all with different fates...

Above was at Eira.

Nancy, can you respond to Gamma's post? If they're scum, why do they come into the game and scum read you knowing it will earn them a scum read back?

I like you, you can be town.

Basically, it probably really doesn’t matter what I say here. It doesn’t even matter hox ridiculously I am out of my scumrange and how bleeding obvtown I am. People are wrongly scumreading Joker’s playstyle, so yeah he was wrong, we both were but being wrong doesn’t make us scum. If I had either played the game solo/Joker been proven right, I’d be a consensus tr right now.

OK my issue is Joker has taken you fully outside of your scum range, you just need to do what you do which is exactly what you're doing. But what you're doing is meta attacks and meta defences and I don't think you're bleeding obvtown here Nancy, Joker has tainted the slot, and yes if StD did flip red you would be a consensus TR - thats how it works. Being wrong isn't whats making you scummy, its everything around the approach, the wagon, and how you have both handled it and your defenses.

Nancy how is Jokers mechanical play usually?

I am poisoned. I will die.

Spicy, well I don't have to worry about sorting you but now I'm lacking people I know I can trust. eugh.
Please have something good for me later x.x;

I am concerned because Elements expressed he was poisoned. I know we both visited KJ.

KJ visited no one.

I visit someone and determine who they visited and who visited them.

Elements should claim what he did.

Elements hasn't claimed poisoned?

I lied

damn it enchant -.-; I can't even be mad because this is the level of BS you'd pull. I don't like how quiet you are though, any thoughts on whats happened?

Spoiler: Taught them almost all I knew.

I’m not opposed because that vote wasn’t good but I think it’s really weird Elements claimed to visit us and how did both of get poisoned?

Unless Elements claims to be visted by someone other than us, they’re confirmed lying scum here.

[snip]
~H

Euuuugh damnit nancy... I want to be able to ignore your slot.
I can't. When I skimmed I saw the second line, thought "ok maybe the dyslexia has kicked in there, check context."
Are you now claiming to be poisoned?
Are you claiming to have visited Elements?

Eugh this is messy as all hell...

That’s specifically because I’m not gonna put much effort into this game rn and that surpasses my current effort allotment by a long shot
You may get it eventually, but I’m not gonna try to accelerate it at all.

Okay, why not? How do I know you aren't just scum copping out by saying "I don't want to put a lot of effort into this game"? How am I supposed to tell the difference between your play right now and scum?

Not happening anytime soon, pal.

Why not?

Because I don’t want to.

Okay, aren't you a player who presumably takes pride in their Town game and had the better part of a night phase to read the game?

Why am I getting Deja Vu?

Damn.

KJ look real bad and Eira still won't vote them.

Elements, talk about that visit.

My read is that BBT is still town and will have a hard time leaving the KJ tunnel

I hope I'm right on KJ. It felt like town the entire D1, and I swear I'm strong townreading everything Nancy posts in D2 even if it's a little unfair to gamma who just replaced in

Also: hi gamma! Good to see you here

With as much respect as is possible please remove your head from which hole it currently resides and play as something other than a lost lamb.
Genuinely worried you're going to get separation anxiety if one of you or KJ gets keelhauled at this point.

No answer?

VOTE: Killing Joke

???

Why are you voting us when Titus soft inno’d us?

There's a keyword there, SOFT. You can be non-killing mutineer. I hate you've run with this so long after being told...

Absolutely one in you/Gimli at this point. Two if you flip red.

Without quoting you again, you are not cleared by any means other than no action N1 which means nothing.

Gamma seems good. Gimli seems good. Killing Joke seems good even though they defragged as fuck.

Toffee might seem good but I'm not yet the trusting type.

Dan?

Elements. you're scum.

Erynis, you might be, Convince me you're not?

Flea, talk. I want to hear from fae.

Enchant? Crew. Yes? I think.

Hi, AMA.

Vote progression

The posts linked are not the sole reason for votes in most cases, but the point I am deciding to vote.

1179 - VOTE: Killing Joke
1229 - UNVOTE: Killing Joke
1261 - VOTE: Killing Joke
1281 - VOTE: Gimli

@55
Bellaphant, Eiralox, Killing Joke, Enchant

[Enchant]

Called me?

[Aisa]

Reminder there's a site update, during which the site will be down, in like three hours: viewtopic.php?f=4&t=90330

[Gamma Emerald]

Teams like Killing Joke/Elements/Toffee/Whatever very feasible here if Erynis is town.

Starting to think they are, as I did Day One.

Erynis, get in here if you can. There's sharks.

This is not town.
Down to vote out either of Eira or HPE.

Also I have a readlist written out technically but I’d like to nail down my less confident reads before posting it.

[Eiralox]

Teams like Killing Joke/Elements/Toffee/Whatever very feasible here if Erynis is town.

Starting to think they are, as I did Day One.

Erynis, get in here if you can. There's sharks.

This is not town.
Down to vote out either of Eira or HPE.
it.

It is though. Try harder.



UNVOTE:


I like what Flea is saying.

[Flea The Magician]

Then respond to it and interact with me. I am TLing your slot but can't progress either way and its frustrating me.

Back at the catchup.

[Flea The Magician]

Like there is a lot in that post, I'm commenting on at least 20 posts. You will need to be specific at this point.
There's a reason there's 5/6 posts per spoiler. To allow interaction.

[Flea The Magician]

And my brain apparently crashed I thought you said don't like, honestly my points still stand, I am wanting to be able to move you to a solid read.

[Eiralox]

I'm off to dreamland, and having like.................................. more than fifteen? posts left for five days, I think I'll talk in one big post when I'm back here again, so I can at least defend myself once scum decides to go full force.


Feel free to throw questions my way, I did ask fae about what Elements recently did.

But before your posts I've been having some doubts about Killing Joke and Gimli, fearing for my neutrality, so sorta........ we'll see.

Understanding me right now: I have two concrete reads, one being someone I trust. Other than that I'm a bit lost and basically used today to try and not be..... I'm not sure on that yet.

But regarding the rest, I can be frustrating.

Won't be hearing a lot more from me going on.

I think I'll talk if I have something solid enough for my tastes.


*P-edit to 1:20 1:21. I don't think I'm going to say exactly what I liked. Above can give some idea regarding one specific aspect of it at least. I'm not sure what to think about KJ in particular, my vote is nowhere and my mind is open until like..... whenever.

[Killing Joke]

I’m seriously starting to wonder between some people either possibly being scum or taken leave of their senses. Not interested in getting into a fight or anything and also not trying to offend but we have a confitown with a soft inno on us like we did in the game where I was in the hydra Arkham Asylum in Vengeful Ghosts where flipped consensus tr Dannflor protected us and there was no kill but the majority of the people (in the dead thread) making that decision didn’t think so and literally the only reason town didn’t lose was literally one of the townies who wrongly scumread us despite all evidence to the contrary, just happened to be asleep at the time and the cw was the last scum.

Wrt to Eira, their constant jumpiness reminds me of their play in Nobility where they seemed to be changing their mind like pretty much every 15 seconds.

I’m still suspicious of Elements but that post by HPE saying one scum between us and Enchant makes no freaking sense to me whatsoever.

Why make an absolute pairing like that between two players with no connection that I can see? The complete arbitrariness of that pairing just looks really bad to me.

@Flea - 3 words: *egg on face*. <3