TM 2023 | Masterchef MafiaScum (Game over)

[Aureal]

I'm glad my role actually came in useful! I read it and was like "but what does it DO?? Can I catch scum with it? How the heck does this work???" It worked better than I expected. >.>

[Alisae]

I'm glad my role actually came in useful! I read it and was like "but what does it DO?? Can I catch scum with it? How the heck does this work???" It worked better than I expected. >.>

you are fun to have in games btw

[NorwegianboyEE]

I came into TM expecting to be my teams biggest embarassment so at least that didn’t happen.

[Alisae]

I came into TM expecting to be my teams biggest embarassment so at least that didn’t happen.

nah bro you had me and shirou backing u up ur fine

[Alisae]

you are a representative of 4 brains

[DkKoba]

i specced this game and i think i made a meme, let me check discord

[DkKoba]

also i caught a scum on d1 b4 they died, i am pro

[Korina]

I just strongly dislike this game, and I think anything like this should be openly stated before the event starts, because I would've put this as my most undesirable game if I was informed there was significant mechanics impacting the mafia NK, or any mechanics that change the NK from "X targets a player, assuming no interference that players dies tonight." The roles in this game made it so my kill is effectively luck based, which is awful, and I would've greatly appreciated being told that was the case before playing in this game.

That's all I have to say really about this game.

[Korina]

Norwee only died by sheer luck. That's it. Based off what I was told about Norwee's role, I could've been 1 ingredient off of killing, and that would've been even worse to know post-game. I just. Once again, I wish it was openly stated there are significant mechanics impacting the NK before playing the game.

[DkKoba]

I just strongly dislike this game, and I think anything like this should be openly stated before the event starts, because I would've put this as my most undesirable game if I was informed there was significant mechanics impacting the mafia NK, or any mechanics that change the NK from "X targets a player, assuming no interference that players dies tonight." The roles in this game made it so my kill is effectively luck based, which is awful, and I would've greatly appreciated being told that was the case before playing in this game.

That's all I have to say really about this game.

it was essentialy an arso game where you can inspire paranoia early on, losing a scummate d1 was probably the least optimal thing and weakened your team significantly, but being able to turn a 7p into surprise limlo is the benefit

[DkKoba]

nightless is actually incredibly hard for town if they dont have polarized players

[Korina]

Yeah but like, there's no guarantee of any kills, especially with two roles that can just outright stop me from making a kill if I get unlucky in the roll of what to take. That's the problem. The fact that there is any degree of chance in any of my kills outside of an actual doctor is bad and I would've liked to be told that. A doctor is reasonably anticipatable, and I can expect to play around a doctor, but being told your NK is not guaranteed due to mechanics, and is dependent on knowing who has what ingredients.

At least with arso, if there's a firefighter, I can reasonably anticipate them stopping my kill. I can't anticipate random chance.

[Korina]

It's just like, the fact that any degree of random chance was added into the game and wasn't announced prior to the game is my issue with it. That's it.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I was also planning to hardpush Korina if i was alive at daystart.
But it didn’t matter in the end and town caught them anyways.

[McMenno]

it had approximately 0 impact on the game result

[Thestatusquo]

I disagree.

[Thestatusquo]

Wait I thought you said I and I was like wut no menno you were fine this game.

[Doctor Drew]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

[Thestatusquo]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

The feeling was somewhat mutual on our end, though not MTs.

[Doctor Drew]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

The feeling was somewhat mutual on our end, though not MTs.

The apologies or that I should know better lol?

[Korina]

it had approximately 0 impact on the game result

It’s almost like my partner died d1 for not doing anything and rng ended up playing into my favor and let me kill norwee anyways. Wild how rng works.

[Thestatusquo]

it had approximately 0 impact on the game result

It’s almost like my partner died d1 for not doing anything and rng ended up playing into my favor and let me kill norwee anyways. Wild how rng works.

Just curious why you claimed to not have lost the flour. That was the main thing we couldn't figure out.

[Thestatusquo]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

The feeling was somewhat mutual on our end, though not MTs.

The apologies or that I should know better lol?

We were still kind of non plussed by how we felt you had treated Ari and couldn't shake a slight scum read on you. MT didn't really scum read you that much.

[Doctor Drew]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

The feeling was somewhat mutual on our end, though not MTs.

The apologies or that I should know better lol?

We were still kind of non plussed by how we felt you had treated Ari and couldn't shake a slight scum read on you. MT didn't really scum read you that much.

I might have been tunnely on Ari, but was all in the spirit of the game and me thinking she was scum, how did I treat her bad enough for her to call me a bad person??

That is what tilted me.

[Doctor Drew]

Besides yelling at me from the second I subbed in lol, I thought McMenno was great.

And apologies to Morning, I had a bit of PTSD from your predecessor and couldn't shake a scum read, I should know better.

The feeling was somewhat mutual on our end, though not MTs.

The apologies or that I should know better lol?

We were still kind of non plussed by how we felt you had treated Ari and couldn't shake a slight scum read on you. MT didn't really scum read you that much.

I might have been tunnely on Ari, but was all in the spirit of the game and me thinking she was scum, how did I treat her bad enough for her to call me a bad person??

That is what tilted me.

*for her to say she hates me as a person, forgot exactly what she said. How would you feel if someone says that about you?