TM 2023 | Masterchef MafiaScum (Game over)

[Morning Tweet]

Dessew you're taking what you think lilith might have meant

then going like ??????????????????????

adding in a little !

and then going boom the numbers mason look at hte role names WHAT DO THEY MEEEAANNNNNN

WHat i'm saying is, you're being a tad, speculative here

[Dessew]

Do you concede that a contestant can be a thief or an eavesdropper? Do you concede, that the same for stagehands would only be incidental at best, and it wouldn't even be mentioned in the show? Do you concede, that an inspector or a redistrubtor couldn't be a contestant? Do you concede that stagehands could be inspectors and redistributors to monitor and steer the show?

Redistrubtor isn't a town role.

[Morning Tweet]

Korina went from "Sooner Aureal dies game ends" to "Drew is conf scum for claiming mafia NK" how did you come to a mechanical certainty of a guilty twice and what happened to the thing that happened with Aureal

Dessew I guess there isnt much to say about the Flour. Scum probably did it. Although if thats true, why. I dunno

[Morning Tweet]

Do you concede that a contestant can be a thief or an eavesdropper? Do you concede, that the same for stagehands would only be incidental at best, and it wouldn't even be mentioned in the show? Do you concede, that an inspector or a redistrubtor couldn't be a contestant? Do you concede that stagehands could be inspectors and redistributors to monitor and steer the show?

Redistrubtor isn't a town role.

YOU SOUND LIKE YOU"VE GONE MAD DESSEW

[Dessew]

Finally managed to sort my sig out

[Morning Tweet]

Why the fuck is thieving or eavesdropping in masterchief as a contestant but inspecting and FUCKING REDISTRIBUTING is stagehand and stagehand (As we all know) IS SCUM so by that reasoning the only logicaal conclusuion we can come to is that, yes, Drew must be scum.

[McMenno]

Setup

Nightkills are replaced by

"redistribution,"

which moves around ingredients to/from players.

Also since we are all claiming.

I am a

redistributor.

I can take ingredients from two people(or the shelf) and give them to two other people.

This is why I don't believe Dessew.

Like is this not the funniest shit in the world if Drew is scum

this is more convincing than any argument dessew has made

[Dessew]

DO YOU CONCEDE? BY THE HOLY SPIRIT, DO YOU CONCEDE?

[Morning Tweet]

Between you and Dreew I CANot tell which of you has the more batshit, conspiracy theoryesque reasoning igve quite possibly EVER heard in my LIFE but you're saying it COMPLETELY STRAIGHT like it's basic atrithmetic

[Dessew]

I HAVE LOOKED INTO THE ABYSS, AND WHAT I SAW THE TRUTH! REDISTRUBTOR IS NOT A TOWN ROLE! DREW IS CLAIMING GOON! REPENT! REPENT! DREW IS CLAIMING GOON!

[Morning Tweet]

this is more convincing than any argument dessew has made

Whaty argument is Dessew making??? I challenge anyone in this game to recap what Dessew just said with different words same meaning

But yes, the possibility that Drew somehow makes thje oversight of claiming what scum is publicly said to do as his exact role name then plays it off like that'd be the most ridiculous play ever is so unbelievably funny I can't take it seriously

[Dessew]

why did I mistype -_- there was meant to be no "what"

[Morning Tweet]

Thank you Dessew this has been a great session this game is getting goooooodddd

I'll try re-opening my third eye again later

[Dessew]

You've already repeated my argument. Drew claims to do the thing mafia does. But then you go, no, no, Drew would never play so poorly. But he would! He is!

[Dessew]

Why the fuck is thieving or eavesdropping in masterchief as a contestant but inspecting and FUCKING REDISTRIBUTING is stagehand and stagehand (As we all know) IS SCUM so by that reasoning the only logicaal conclusuion we can come to is that, yes, Drew must be scum.

Here you also repeated my points. We already know that inspecting is scum.

[lilith2013]

V OTECOUNT 2.003
S HELF: Beef, Egg, Flour, Milk, Stock, Water, Wine
E LIMINATION V OTES
P LAYER N AME	C URRENT V OTES
Aureal (0)	None
Dessew (1)	Doctor Drew
Doctor Drew (2)	Korina, Dessew
furtiveglance (0)	None
Korina (3)	Aureal, Morning Tweet, McMenno
McMenno (0)	None
Morning Tweet (0)	None
NOT VOTING: furtiveglance
Notes: pagetops: Lilith 9 | Aristeia 6 | Norwegianboy 6 | Dr Drew 3 | MT 3 | Korina 2 | furtive 2 | McMenno 1 | Aureal 1 | Dessew 1

[Morning Tweet]

Are you still claiming that the stagehands have something to do with this?

[Morning Tweet]

The idea that a town role could move ingredients is not really that ludicrous.

A town role having the same name as scum's nightkill mechanic, that's a bit odd. But it is a vigilante I guess. I'm not really into scrutinzing the name so much as what it does and what it does is kind of kill. Meh. It's suspicious but I'd still be very surprised

The component of your argument devoted to drew having scum's mechanic is perfectly fine. Everything else is completely off of the walls

[Morning Tweet]

TSQ kind of thinks that Drews role CCs Dessew which is why Dessew would have been forced to attack Drew regardless of alignment

I didnt really consider it from that perspective. I think town's power probably sucks (seeing as it's random, see: drew's n1). So I dont think the roles contradict. But I guess I can see where Drew is coming from more. I also kind of get why Drew thought Dessew was scum the other day

So drew's been claiming redistributor ever since Dessew claimed. No accident, no hesitation. Remember he was certain Dessew was mafia the other day, so he was planning on saying that his role felt like it didn't exist in the setup with town!Dessew's. For multiple game days, that's been the plan

Maybe to save bianco........... that doesnt really seem all that convincing to me though does it. CC a real town power role as yourself (the nonsuspected scum) rather than bianco. no, I don't think that makes sense. Just outright counter claim Dessew rather than hinting at it. There's no point in doing this

No, ultimately i dont think Drew claims to redistribute ingredients (His scum NK) in order to CC a real ingredient redistributor just to bus bianco anyway but then still fully believe this Dessew logic the next day (Which he fully knows is wrong). It makes a lot more sense that Drew's town. There's too many things that make no sense about that

[Dessew]

Redistributor would be Doctor and Vig at the same time. In fact, Drew claims to be double Doctor and double Vig.

[Dessew]

Of course, it's about the stagehands, no argument has been presented against this idea. Redistrubtor isn't a town role.

[Dessew]

What doesn't make sense to you about it? Is there any more meat to your arguments than "Drew just can't be such a moron to outright claim mafia"?

[Dessew]

Guys, new meta just dropped: when mafia, claim goon. Tweet will defend, no matter how many loops she has to jump through.

[furtiveglance]

Dessew, why is it not possible for there to be a town pseudo-vig in this game?

[Dessew]

He's a double vig and a double doctor! If there's only one mafia in the game left, then we've got a minimum of 4 town PRs (you, me, Aureal and Menno). And he's a redistributor, he does what mafia does, and his role thematically is not a contestant, just like bianco's wasn't. Nothing fits for the town!Drew narrative.

Ceterum censeo, Redistrubtor isn't a town role.