Normal 2302: Magical Girls | GAME OVER

[Emperor flippyNips]

I’m alive

[Emperor flippyNips]

A lot to read tho soooooooooooooooo

[Emperor flippyNips]

I’ll be a min

[HighPrincessErinys]

Really funny how this one is kinda just vibing and is on track to get mislimmed.

Big fan of 294, and kinda feeling a gera vote after reading their ISO in-depth.

I want @HPE to explain being a "big fan" of this post lol

the only reason I dont dislike those posts is because I know ckd does it as town from that large normal we keep talking about

Cause it's a good post? It points out several reasonable points and has ckd's thoughts on various slots throughout.

[Emperor flippyNips]

Kill me if like, do no good u. Good u I live

[HighPrincessErinys]

My big gripe right now is that people seem to be allergic to elaborating on their reads/making cases in any way because this one is apparently the uberscum but no one will really fucking tell me or anyone else

why

.

[Thestatusquo]

VoteCount 1.6

Hu Tao [ 4 ]

Morning Tweet, DrippingGoofball, Elements, Save the Dragons

HighPrincessErinys [ 4 ]

sheepsaysmeep, geraintm, towwl, OopsieDaisy

curiouskarmadog [ 1 ]

Firebringer

Morning Tweet [ 1 ]

hu tao

Elements [ 1 ]

Curiouskarmadog

Not Voting [ 2 ]

HighPrincessErinys, Emporer flippynips,

With 13 alive it takes 7 votes to be executed.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2023-06-09 17:15:31)

[towwl]

My big gripe right now is that people seem to be allergic to elaborating on their reads/making cases in any way because this one is apparently the uberscum but no one will really fucking tell me or anyone else

why

.

Phoneposting in the office rn. I’ll write up a case once I’m home

[Elements]

VOTE: HPE

[geraintm]

VOTE: HPE

if it wasnt for this vote i would have switched wagons

[geraintm]

Also since we're gonna be getting near the point soon, could we announce intents to hammer before we do so the players have a chance to claim? Or is that not something people are a fan of?

That’s standard procedure

what, a claim or intent to hammer?

[geraintm]

So why does that stink to you?

Because from what I know about large normal 243, Hu Tao was wrongly voted out when they were town and so when I see them similarly getting pushed here I'm worried about another misvote on the slot based on what is just them making reads that don't make much sense to us.

Alongside this I scumread you and STD has strong associations with you through voting. Seeing you both on the wagon worries me too.

most people get voted off wrongly. scum arent dumb.
this post screams "i know they are going to flip green and wantt o get that in now"

naughty point for you

[geraintm]

but if someone doesnt ask someone else's stance...How does ANYONE know? this reasoning is just really bad.

could wlel be bad, i am never claiming to be a good player.

[geraintm]

Hey Gera, who is scum and why? Ill go ahead and take that "naughty point" because I asked.

<checks role message>
<wasn't told who were my scum partners>

yeah, it is day 1 i have no idea who is scum.

no one does

[geraintm]

I could vote Erinys as well.

man, ive just gone back through your posts and they suck

this post saying you could vote erinys
a random vote for Hu Toa because you are "ready to slay"
a town read you faked dissapating
another town read gone because ??
firebringer is always town?

2 more "these people are town slots"

VOTE: drippinggoofball

[OopsieDaisy]

So why does that stink to you?

Because from what I know about large normal 243, Hu Tao was wrongly voted out when they were town and so when I see them similarly getting pushed here I'm worried about another misvote on the slot based on what is just them making reads that don't make much sense to us.

Alongside this I scumread you and STD has strong associations with you through voting. Seeing you both on the wagon worries me too.

most people get voted off wrongly. scum arent dumb.
this post screams "i know they are going to flip green and wantt o get that in now"

naughty point for you

Yea I do think they're gonna flip green, that's why I made the post lol. Most people do get voted off wrongly but it's important to try and prevent that right? That's like the whole point of the game

[geraintm]

@oopsiedaisy

you can do it in different ways, and this felt like you were performing the whole slot is going to get voted off and woe is town

[Elements]

VOTE: HPE

if it wasnt for this vote i would have switched wagons

VOTE: DGB

[OopsieDaisy]

@oopsiedaisy

you can do it in different ways, and this felt like you were performing the whole slot is going to get voted off and woe is town

Well from what I gather, that means you think I'm scummier but you also think Hu Tao is townier because of my post, so I guess that's still a win for me getting people off of that wagon lmao.

[HighPrincessErinys]

VOTE: HPE

if it wasnt for this vote i would have switched wagons

VOTE: DGB

This one is... mystified.

[Elements]

VOTE: HPE

if it wasnt for this vote i would have switched wagons

VOTE: DGB

This one is... mystified.

I do my best

[Morning Tweet]

I'm really not sure why HPE is the uberscum to so many people

Emperor and Tao are both better options HPE feels hit or miss

Tao and Emperor i think are both lacking and also are kinda dipping

I think gera is town for switching his suspicion around so much it's like he's not trying to follow a goal it's more just he finds something he votes he finds something he votes . Even though i think he's completely wrong about Daisy

Hu Tao hyperfixating on DGB smells to me, just to drop it

Emperor just prod dodged the wagon on him

The worst crime from bri was awkward defensive posting combined wit hghosting. I guess. I don't really know how to read HPE but it is sort of notable that so many people had snap scummy reactions to it entering the game

[towwl]

My big gripe right now is that people seem to be allergic to elaborating on their reads/making cases in any way because this one is apparently the uberscum but no one will really fucking tell me or anyone else

why

.

Phoneposting in the office rn. I’ll write up a case once I’m home

I think town would more easily brush off making a post like 374. Honestly I didn't even find the post that "bad", I just didn't really understand it. But instead of just letting it go, HPE further digs a hole in 375 and 376 in a weird "haha silly me" act that I'm interpreting more as self-imposed flailing in a strange overabundance of caution, rather than town embarrassed by a bad post. It's a really bad entrance.


380 pings me as a weird distancing from the slot's previous inhabitant. I don't even really find it that bad when somebody agrees with reasoning for scumreading them and I never really took to that part of Daisy's case, but HPE takes that part at face value and postures as being baffled by bri's agreement. It feels performative, as there really isn't anything to be baffled by, but 380 makes it out to be a much bigger deal than it is.


417 and 444 are kind of interesting, as we see a scumread on DGB building up, but in 444 we see HPE is "displeased" to see that we can't necessarily scumread DGB for her strange playstyle, as that's just the way she is. At first I found this kind of towny as I find meta dives kind of towny, but on the other hand this contradicts with 376 where HPE says "this one doesn't put much stock into meta it has not directly played with". So then why the disappointment at a meta dive invalidating a possible scum push? It just doesn't add up for me.

Also I can pretty easily see bristar just being flakey scum.

[HighPrincessErinys]

I think town would more easily brush off making a post like 374. Honestly I didn't even find the post that "bad", I just didn't really understand it. But instead of just letting it go, HPE further digs a hole in 375 and 376 in a weird "haha silly me" act that I'm interpreting more as self-imposed flailing in a strange overabundance of caution, rather than town embarrassed by a bad post. It's a really bad entrance.

This one literally just read the post wrong after sleeping horridly late, waking up and having to deal with my idiot grandpa's shit which isn't appropriate to talk about here. Which it also mentions in that chain of posts. If you wanna read some weird scum defense strategy or whatever from this one talking about that at length like that, sure go ahead! Just know you're kinda missing the entire deal with my first day.

380 pings me as a weird distancing from the slot's previous inhabitant. I don't even really find it that bad when somebody agrees with reasoning for scumreading them and I never really took to that part of Daisy's case, but HPE takes that part at face value and postures as being baffled by bri's agreement. It feels performative, as there really isn't anything to be baffled by, but 380 makes it out to be a much bigger deal than it is.

Correct! It's kind of minor, even discounting differences in if you think it's weird or not to agree with scumreads, because this one is now aware that it's basically just "hey you're alot more sensitive this game compared to the last" "yea", but this one was again, kind of having a bad day and was skimming at best.

417 and 444 are kind of interesting, as we see a scumread on DGB building up, but in 444 we see HPE is "displeased" to see that we can't necessarily scumread DGB for her strange playstyle, as that's just the way she is. At first I found this kind of towny as I find meta dives kind of towny, but on the other hand this contradicts with 376 where HPE says "this one doesn't put much stock into meta it has not directly played with". So then why the disappointment at a meta dive invalidating a possible scum push? It just doesn't add up for me.

It's a really basic metadive to make and one that doesn't really infringe on my already not like

hard

rule of meta this one has observed being the main meta it cares about. Like, go ahead and read some of her games yourself, you'll pretty quickly find her posts are usually in the same laconic "X is Town." fashion as this game. This one isn't going to erroneously push a slot it literally fucking knows is Just Like That even if it wanted to prior, because it has no reason to keep that scumread at all.


Conclusion: damn dude. thats some industrial grade assumption of scum intentions. ouch.

[Morning Tweet]

I agree that HPE's reaction didn't fit with what bristar had admitted to ("You're more sensitive" "Yea", but HPE interpreted it as something worse prior and said something along the lines of "I don't know why he'd admit that")

But i chalked that up to not having read what it was yet, plus Daisy had made it seem like a pretty big deal. If HPE had been fully aware of everything i dont think it would have reacted the way it did

as much as I think bri could be scum i think you're confirm biased when reading HPE. If i squint rlly hard then saying something like "Why would he admit to that" without having read back is almost towny because it looks superficially kinda bad and id maybe expect more careful posting