Moderator: heipizhu
Player List:
- Klick
- biancospino*
- Doctor Drew
I think the idea behind this was to explicitly claim a scum role that isn't the scum role in this game to make us think he doesn't have the scum Role PM
It would take *some effort*. More effort than I devoted early this morning when I initially thought your post was scummy.In post 17, biancospino wrote: The reasoning you did offer is quite linear. As long as you start assuming that 8 did likely come from scum, even if it was actually on gut which I don't believe, surely it wouldn't take any effort at all to notice how it contradicts the setup and to produce a reasonable-sounding explanation for why that's scummy.
Gotta love the charged question thou. You do understand that it's not possible for me to both have held that (1) yours is an obvious conclusion, and (2) I did that with any amount of intention, right? Because, as it turns out, nobody save maybe a Jester may intend to induce the obvious conclusion that they're scum
Is reaching scummy in this gamestate?In post 18, Doctor Drew wrote: I really feel like Klick is reaching here.
To clarify: I don't see a reason for you to assume this over any other given reason for me waiting for you to arriveIn post 21, Klick wrote:I don't see a good reason for you to assume me waiting for you to arrive = 'Klick!scum thinks I'm more likely to be swayed than bianco'