Newbie 2129 - Mafia PT

[Alianna]

Newbie 2129 - Mafia PT

Welcome, TheHoldSteady (

Mafia Goon

) and humaneatingmonkey (

Mafia Roleblocker

)!

You may talk here at any time.
Night actions are to be submitted here as well. Please specify which mafioso will commit the factional kill.
The Mafia Roleblocker must submit or approve of their own personal roleblock action.
You may quote posts from the game thread into this PT, but you may not quote posts from this PT into the game thread. You may draft posts in this PT to copy and paste into the main thread, but if you are going to do that, avoid using [post] tags as they will not link to the correct posts.
This PT will be released unredacted after the game ends.

Access List

- Alianna (moderator)
- PenguinPower (Newbie Queue listmod)
- TheHoldSteady
- SlowthePoke
- SevenEyes
- humaneatingmonkey

[TheHoldSteady]

Oh boy lol, scum again. Confirmed

Received.

- Alianna

Day 1 starts after this post. ↓↓↓

[Alianna]

SevenEyes replaces SlowthePoke.

[SevenEyes]

haha, my first game and i'm already scum

Confirmation received.

- Alianna

[TheHoldSteady]

Hoping they don't lim you here, but if you're about to be hammered, you probably already know, just claim cop or doc...

Bulge is unintentionally setting up some partner tells with you, which will be good for later if needed...tried to set up some with Steve but I might've come on too strongly to ever bring it up again...

[TheHoldSteady]

Funny how they keep mentioning the possibility of PT coaching going on but we've hardly even used this.

[Alianna]

Night 1 begins.

[TheHoldSteady]

Here are some of my thoughts on night actions for tonight. If you have any ideas who might be a PR or a good kill, feel free to share.

I don't think anyone's town play is standout in a way that's threatening to us. So we should probably aim to kill who we think is PR.

Bulge's thing about being afraid to die tonight is odd, but I don't think a player with his experience would put himself out there if he were a vulnerable PR. Could be a cop softing for doc protection.

IAmVeryHappy has mostly stayed in the background, may be a PR trying to avoid attracting attention to himself.

Let's say we were to kill Happy and roleblock Bulge...what would you think?

[SevenEyes]

Hoping they don't lim you here, but if you're about to be hammered, you probably already know, just claim cop or doc...

Bulge is unintentionally setting up some partner tells with you, which will be good for later if needed...tried to set up some with Steve but I might've come on too strongly to ever bring it up again...

ok, noted. just hope that nobody counterclaims or it doesnt go terribly wrong if the time comes.

[SevenEyes]

Here are some of my thoughts on night actions for tonight. If you have any ideas who might be a PR or a good kill, feel free to share.

I don't think anyone's town play is standout in a way that's threatening to us. So we should probably aim to kill who we think is PR.

Bulge's thing about being afraid to die tonight is odd, but I don't think a player with his experience would put himself out there if he were a vulnerable PR. Could be a cop softing for doc protection.

IAmVeryHappy has mostly stayed in the background, may be a PR trying to avoid attracting attention to himself.

Let's say we were to kill Happy and roleblock Bulge...what would you think?

i think keeping the bulge and civil scum alive is a good idea, since they're both kind of suspicious/acting mildly scummy, which could be good for us.

killing happy and roleblocking the bulge is a idea that i can get behind. i don't have any real idea as to who is pr, but when i've played with my friends outside of mafiascum, usually we kill the person who contributes or just talks the most.

[TheHoldSteady]

Kill: IAmVeryHappy

Thanks to your Roleblock, you have more ability to deal with PRs. Therefore, I'm committing the factional kill. Feel free to submit your roleblocker action whenever you can. Good luck

Received.

- Alianna

[SevenEyes]

Roleblock: The Bulge

good luck! hope we survive until tomorrow night

Received.

- Alianna

[Alianna]

Day 2 begins.

[SevenEyes]

and happy really was doctor . lol

[TheHoldSteady]

To whoever replaces SevenEyes:

I started bussing her a bit in case she was limmed so that I could point to other players in future days as her partner but my plan is to hopefully switch later on to CS. Leek has suspected SevenEyes fairly heavily but otherwise she's mostly flew under the radar. I've gotten mixed reads on me. I have had a couple townreads but I haven't done well enough to avoid the solid PoE that a couple people are putting out, so my name is coming up as a potential scum today. We hit Doc night one which is good. Still Cop to worry about.

[Alianna]

humaneatingmonkey replaces SevenEyes.

[humaneatingmonkey]

give me a rundown on the situation

Accepting this as confirmation.

- Alianna

[TheHoldSteady]

It's been a very slow game with a lot of replacements and lurky players.

You're replacing into a slot that was low activity and posted some inconsistent thoughts about IAVH which went noticed by town. SzmarzLeek has wanted to lim her since around the later half of day 1.

BrassHerald was suspected early on, but The Bulge replaced him and managed to switch the lim to MagicalSteve, who was a VT.

SmileyDude1 has emerged as a town leader, having been the most consistently active and substantial with content. But his reads aren't perfect.

Doc is dead, cop not out yet.

There's a trio of unanimous townreads that's formed between Smiley, Leek, and The Bulge which has me bit worried.

Your slot and CS are the leading candidates for lim right now. Bulge said he wanted CS or me and then went quiet the past few days. Smiley is between CS and your slot but leaning more towards CS.

Overall not an unwinnable game for us

[humaneatingmonkey]

what's your plan from here

[TheHoldSteady]

I was going to try to push lims of Civil Scum and then CCGeek but with those spots just replaced I really dont know right now if that'll hold

[humaneatingmonkey]

so, pushing Civil Scum... yeah?

[humaneatingmonkey]

you got it from here, bud? i actually have no time. i think a merlyn elimination is no sweat here.

let me know who are your top two choices for town cop, and I'll see if i agree with you.

[TheHoldSteady]

Not too sure on cop

One possibly is Patchwork because of CCGeeks last post

The other theory I have is that Leek is cop,.checked Bulge overnight and cleared him, explaining why Leek was suspicious of Bulge at the end of day 1 but then suddenly town read him the next day

[TheHoldSteady]

I think I finally found a way to transition my vote to Merlyn without making it too obvious that we're partners.

[humaneatingmonkey]

you're doing great