Cheese Thief | Game 1 Over

[DragonEater70]

I clearly can't type

[Silverclaw]

Okay you know what, screw this

I think my original gut vibe was probably correct

It's probably math+mallow as sidekick

VOTE: Math

Is it just because neither of them seem too interested in responding?

[Skygazer]

I'm kinda torn between Math and Snivy atm

[DragonEater70]

same

Is it just because neither of them seem too interested in responding?

partly

[Silverclaw]

I still feel like it's snivy. Mallow is giving me disinterested vibes, so I could see him being a follower for sure.

As for Math... honestly, I feel like I don't have a read either way. Like I'm not seeing enough, consistency wise to make a solid opinion one way or another. I don't explicitly read the first page and a half or so as a scumread, more as a state of general confusion.

When it comes to snivy, I feel like we haven't gotten anything that's actively helpful. What we

have

gotten is intent to pull us into multiple different directions and backtrack into discussions that have already ended in an unhelpful manner without adding anything new to it.

[Silverclaw]

How about this:

Mallow and NDMath, please give us sound reasoning as to why neither of you are follower or cheese thief. I would like at least a paragraph (4 sentences).

I feel like I need to see a defense I can tear apart tbh

[Skygazer]

My gut instinct is that Math is kinda townie but idk
mallow mechanically can't be cheese thief i think

[DragonEater70]

yeah mallow is confirmed not CT but could be follower

[DragonEater70]

UNVOTE:

[Silverclaw]

mallow mechanically can't be cheese thief i think

I mean yeah, so he can just skip that part

[NDMath]

tomorrow i'll think about how the various possibilities have interacted and if they make sense as partners.

tbh I'm gonna need this for your table / logic commentary to mean anything at all to me

How about this:

Mallow and NDMath, please give us sound reasoning as to why neither of you are follower or cheese thief. I would like at least a paragraph (4 sentences).

I feel like I need to see a defense I can tear apart tbh

I don't think I handle DE's early accusation/RT towards me as well if I were cheese thief, I'd also argue that I'm clearly not partnered with DE because of it. Specifically I believe I have town!logic behind all my reactions to it, and that just wouldn't be the case were I cheese thief. In my (obviously biased) opinion, I believe I've been more constructive to figuring out who cheese thief is than either of skygazer or ccs. If you believe mallow is follower, ccs definitely has more incriminating interactions with mallow than I do.

Part of that is abit more of a case against ccs than a defense for myself, although for your pov those are functionally the same thing if we assume DE is sleepyhead. As for follower: I can't be DE's follower, I can't be skygazer's follower, and I have a hunch that I'd be doing alot of stuff differently were I ccs's follower.

[Silverclaw]

That's ... pretty aggressively fine. I'm not sold on the meta read because I don't know what your meta is in games like this, but I think the rest of it makes enough sense.

I particularly like your reasons for not being a follower tbh.

[DragonEater70]

Silverclaw have you ever played mafia on this site or only mish mash?

[mallowgeno]

How about this:

Mallow and NDMath, please give us sound reasoning as to why neither of you are follower or cheese thief. I would like at least a paragraph (4 sentences).

I feel like I need to see a defense I can tear apart tbh

So as previously stated by y'all I cannot be the cheese thief unless both DragonEater and I lied (though math is claiming cheese was gone already so all three of us can't be lying). If I am a follower...does that matter at this point?

The question in my opinion comes down to did Math lie and they are just the cheese thief? Or is it Star Gazer? I'm leaning towards Star Gazer and I'm going to put my vote there

vote StarGazer

[DragonEater70]

Why aren't you considering Snivy a possibility?

[Silverclaw]

Silverclaw have you ever played mafia on this site or only mish mash?

I used to a long time ago under my old main. I was pretty bad at it, but it's been a decade and I've generally found my groove a bit more in social deduction games I think

[Silverclaw]

Honestly I feel like snivy is the thief and mallow is the follower.

That feels suspicious as fuck.

[DragonEater70]

I agree

I wish I had meta on Silverclaw because his posts are kinda sleepy but could also come from follower and meta would help me figure out which one it is.

Ugh sure let's just vote Snivy then.

VOTE: Snivy.

[camelCasedSnivy]

i know its statistically more likely that nd is thief but damn de didnt even mention how mallow could STILL be a follower but not just to me.

[Silverclaw]

That's because mallow mentioned Math but decided to not even think about mentioning you

[Skygazer]

VOTE: Snivy

also who is star gazer

[camelCasedSnivy]

ok can i at least tie it against de so i know he isnt pulling something here

[camelCasedSnivy]

UNVOTE: NDMath
VOTE: DragonEater70

[camelCasedSnivy]

if nd or skygazer is thief they deserve it tbh

[camelCasedSnivy]

someone else can vote me then 2 other people can vote de with me