Mini Normal 2314 - The Mafia Have a Cop [END]

[Firebringer]

i am not a fan of the setup but ive had complaints about normal setups a lot lately. I think i am more upset by my night actions than if this setup was screwing me over.

[geraintm]

Oh, three more things...

Geraint...why would you never claim that informed part of your role....?

Drew, great hiding of role. Played that very well. I knew something was weird about you being Informed of that, and Geraint being informed making the entire Neighborhood informed of it is something that would have eased that so much.

Una....your paranoia was out of control this game and it was like the basis of your entire play.

I didn't think it was relevant, we all knew there was a traitor. I was happy to be a vanilla neighbour in this game and felt vouching any extra info might have brought more notice onto me. Once you had me down as town I was thinking

A) I could slide through to end game safely
B) you might have been townnreading me sonstrongly because you were the mafia cop and had checked me and gotten the wrong answer

I was happy sitting there trusting my neighbour who I was 99% sure was town (I couldn't beleive a scenario where I was miller and theybwere scum, but scum might have thought I was the traitor. I reacted strongly day one to your miller claim to see if they kightbhave checked me.....but no one ever visits me in any game

[geraintm]

Was there a way of scum finding me with their roles?

[Dannflor]

Also @Dannflor - I love that we were both Traitors at the same time, and both part of both games.

you were the better traitor for sure!

[Firebringer]

dann did u pick up my signal that i thought u were traitor. i wasn't being very subtle about it

[Dannflor]

I was very limp this game I apologize fire

Definitely not one of my better scum performances but it was fun

[Firebringer]

ill ask my scum buddy then

dannflor, is marcistar a loyal neighborizer

[Alisae]

Was there a way of scum finding me with their roles?

not unless the cop could act (it couldn't but it just as easily could)

[Dannflor]

ill ask my scum buddy then

dannflor, is marcistar a loyal neighborizer

magic 8 ball says try again later

Yes

[Firebringer]

i don't see how this setup was scumsided to you alisae
but i could see how it could easily flip to scum flavor if drew was killed super early on or masons got outed and died.

[Firebringer]

ill ask my scum buddy then

dannflor, is marcistar a loyal neighborizer

magic 8 ball says try again later

Yes

I WASNT SURE IF U WERE JUST MEMEING ALONG!!!!

[Dannflor]

I think this setup is effectively 2 goons + 1 traitor
vs.
2 masons
Drew’s role

and then a lot of WIFOM

which i think is like balanced enough technically

[Dannflor]

ill ask my scum buddy then

dannflor, is marcistar a loyal neighborizer

magic 8 ball says try again later

Yes

I WASNT SURE IF U WERE JUST MEMEING ALONG!!!!

I couldn’t be too obvious!

[Firebringer]

yeah i don't think its like super townsided or not. I think it played out that way but in a normal run it probably is pretty fair. I def don't like the no day chat which is hard to figure into balance and hurts scum imo but tbh i don't know how much me and marci would have chatted

[Alisae]

i don't see how this setup was scumsided to you alisae
but i could see how it could easily flip to scum flavor if drew was killed super early on or masons got outed and died.

Reviewers thought it was scumsided but could swing via traitor

[Dannflor]

I think no day chat is just kinda unfun for scum usually

Idk how it figures into balance

[Alisae]

I opted for no day talk because most wolf players don't rly get the most use out of it.
I didn't realized it bled into the neighbor and masons not having daytalk tho LOL

[Gamma Emerald]

*sigh*

[geraintm]

Was there a way of scum finding me with their roles?

not unless the cop could act (it couldn't but it just as easily could)

Ah, I assumed I could have been found so (having justvread the dead thread and flavour asking why I didn't say I was informed) it was why I wanted the Hood to remain undeclared for as long as possible so that the Mafia Cop might find me.

Ended up not being relevant at all

[Firebringer]

imagining how this game turned out if you had someone who picks competent night kills. If only dannflor was in the scum chat

[Firebringer]

btw the answer to why i killed flavor is because i thought it would be hilarious

[Firebringer]

viewtopic.php?p=13979415#p13979415
me selecting flavor. A crazy plan was hatched to justify it after. Too bad on the guilty was really interested in seeing the possibility of this line of reasoning working to convince anyone.

[Alisae]

Was there a way of scum finding me with their roles?

not unless the cop could act (it couldn't but it just as easily could)

Ah, I assumed I could have been found so (having justvread the dead thread and flavour asking why I didn't say I was informed) it was why I wanted the Hood to remain undeclared for as long as possible so that the Mafia Cop might find me.

Ended up not being relevant at all

I had a hard time deciding on if the cop should be able to act or not fwiw

[Flavor Leaf]

it was hilarious.

I half figured a scum you would kill me too, but it was still probably better not to kill me

I was so ready to die this game.

[Alisae]

btw fire i'm unsure on if I would have claimed the backup mailman in your position