Mini Theme 2318: Cook's Kitchen Sink [Game Over]

[Flavor Leaf]

what are your thoughts on Looker, Drew, and Vander?

and what does Bloodhound do?

and what does Bloodhound do?

town/not town

Looker

am happy to scum bin
is playing different to the games I've played with scum!looker before but they are a few years old now

Drew

was scum leaning before the claim
I think the claim is probably town

Vander

no thoughts, head empty

what about ActionDan/Naerys?

Naerys town
Dan can go in the scum pile

How did you like my questions, Elements? I was making ya give all your reads before I claimed the guilty.

I feel like you mightve known it was towards you, but were really hoping I was faking it or something.

[Flavor Leaf]

Drew, Gamma, Roden, and I had a really good Round Table going for a decent portion of the game. I do think Drew's read on Yessiree and Elements were pivotal because I didn't agree with either of them, and it made me look at a lot of reasons for and against each of them, so the fact I was looking at all the reasons why they weren't scum actually ended up helping my reads towards the both of them.

I release my Notes PT, no redactions.

If anyone wants that. I think it's only a page, but there's some stuff there.

[Celebloki]

No redactions from me if there's anything waiting on posting the dead thread

[Celebloki]

I mentioned it in an earlier post, but when I got my frail modifier, that confirmed Roden for me. Vulnerable made sense considering what I got. If I had lived I'd probably be stuck between wanting to lim Looker or Drew the last day. I just couldn't give up that there was some sort of scum between Roden and Drew lol. I might have been hard tunneled on Drew, Looker was probably my second highest SR.

[Celebloki]

Everyone else was basically confirmed for me.

[Elements]

what are your thoughts on Looker, Drew, and Vander?

and what does Bloodhound do?

and what does Bloodhound do?

town/not town

Looker

am happy to scum bin
is playing different to the games I've played with scum!looker before but they are a few years old now

Drew

was scum leaning before the claim
I think the claim is probably town

Vander

no thoughts, head empty

what about ActionDan/Naerys?

Naerys town
Dan can go in the scum pile

How did you like my questions, Elements? I was making ya give all your reads before I claimed the guilty.

I feel like you mightve known it was towards you, but were really hoping I was faking it or something.

The moment you said you had a guilty I figured it was probably me because of the whole informed situation, but if it was me then we'd almost certainly lost so I may as well play as if it wasn't

[Roden]

Meant to post earlier but GG. I really wish I played the early game better but thankfully I got carried. Good job to Leaf for the soul reads and the pivotal guilty result.

Btw I would like to formally apologize to Roden because I asked the writer of the Procrastinating wiki page about how he’d resolve Yess’ claimed action and he said he would lean towards “no result” meaning Roden was right about the design intent.

I appreciate this, I'm sorry for being abrasive during that argument. You were ultimately right about Yess and I ended up focusing on the wrong detail.

incidentally due to how i counted the votes this time i can provide stats on them

There were 73 votes this game. 31.5% of them were on Aliens.

Here is a pie chart of everyone who cast votes. Below it is a pie chart of where those votes went.



Gamma Emerald, Doctor Drew, Roden, and Flavor Leaf together cast 52% of the votes this game.
Pages 1, 7, and 10 are tied for having the most votes on them, with 6 apiece.

This is cool as hell

[Roden]

Also thanks for modding Cook, the set up was fun

[Sleepy Dragon]

I spectated this game. I really wanted to rep in but couldn't because I ended up getting TMI'd on something (I did make sure it is safe for me to mention this, won't be giving any details though). Great playerlist and very interesting setup.

I also wanted to rep in, but Yess stole that rep opportunity before I could snatch it. Kinda glad though I didn't rep into that slot because this was a stacked town list and I would have had no chance.

[yessiree]

Nah bro. I blundered by post 4. That's when I assume FL picked up the soul read. Never recovered from there

[ActionDan]

Gamma vote was suspect at the time

[Vanderscamp]

That bus driver claim by Looker was kinda tech btw
Denied a clear that was actually legit

I really wanted to mechanically "punish" Looker for that claim though, since scum has huge incentive to make that claim and there was no real reason not to have claimed it the previous day. I thought Roden and Looker were both basically mandatory kills from how it played out,

[Vanderscamp]

Thanks for modding Cook!

[yessiree]

That claim didn't make much sense to me at the time, but maybe I'm looking at it knowing lookers alignment

Bus driver doesn't seem like a proper counter to modifiers, vannilaizer, or treestumps. Too many chances for game deciding swings. ie. redirecting vannila/treestump back to scum

[Gamma Emerald]

It was a one-shot BD claim

[Flavor Leaf]

Scum didn’t have any kills until N3, so i saw it as possible, and town’s lack of strength against it just made it solid on a power level, but I did start to think about how a Scum could get tree stumped with that ability, and that’s one of the main things that lead me to solidifying my vote on Looker.

I like to play Devil’s Advocate until something gets me to stick a lot of times, and even if wrong, it just makes me look at a lot of different angles.

[yessiree]

Aight one shot, hmm that's less swing, but still, night kill, tree stump, modifier, vanillaize. If any of these actions were redirected back to scum it would be a major swing

[Flavor Leaf]

We gonna get to see dead and scum PT?

[Looker]

Scum thread has been redacted in entirety, but dead should definitely be available

[Gamma Emerald]

vrej

[Cook]

oops forgot about that

[Cook]

yeah i'll post em tonight

[Looker]

Airplane food, amirite? What's up with that

[Looker]

Release the visuals, Giselle

[Cook]

Clearly I mean one day in Mafia time.

viewtopic.php?f=90&t=91920 - DEAD
viewtopic.php?f=90&t=91916 - MOD
viewtopic.php?f=90&t=91918 - ALIEN
viewtopic.php?f=90&t=91919 - HOOD
viewtopic.php?f=90&t=91930 - FLAVOR LEAF'S NOTES PT