Mini Theme 2318: Cook's Kitchen Sink [Game Over]

[Gamma Emerald]

I feel like I would vote Drew because something has just felt off since Day 2. Ngl, I think there’s a timeline where he is a Delayed Treestumper, and targeted me N1.

[Flavor Leaf]

That’s kind of what I was thinking.

Kills feel a little too specific for it to be Looker here.

[Looker]

I've pushed Looker as scum all game.

Why?

He hasn't given any reasons for why he doesn't think it's me or why he'd prefer Naerys over Drew.

Spoiler: Irony

Looking at the reasons given for voting Wheme, the one I think is the weirdest is Roden's. It's not the only weird one, though.

VOTE: Star

I can't get behind a Wheme wagon yet, he was recently instrumental in a town win in Guns & Roses and I just have to give him a chance here. He just might be an expert mafia player after all.

He does seem like lim bait though, so many there's some opportunists on his wagon.

How can you claim that Star is lim bait when literally nothing has happened yet and I'm pushing their wagon based on the alignment of the stars

Who do you think is looking for town cred? I'll vote them.

Say less

VOTE: Drew

I think you may have been honest and voted your scum buddy for town cred

VOTE: Star

VOTE: Kitty

I feel another soul read coming on

What am I missing about the KittyTack wagon? I don't want to drag the day out if there's a consensus, but I don't see why everyone's jumping on it. Is there some slip that I missed somewhere?

Naerys->Roden->Looker->Drew

Is probably the path i would go on.

If I'm going today, I would say [Naerys/Doctor]->[FL/Vander]

[Flavor Leaf]

I hard pushed both dead scum members. Without me, they’d both be living and town would be destroyed atm.

It’s that type of complete unknowing of the gamestate that has me feeling Looker is probs town. But it could just be fake, I guess.

If it is, it’s working a little

[Roden]

Why Leaf and Van??

[Gamma Emerald]

I've pushed Looker as scum all game.

Why?

He hasn't given any reasons for why he doesn't think it's me or why he'd prefer Naerys over Drew.

Spoiler: Irony

Looking at the reasons given for voting Wheme, the one I think is the weirdest is Roden's. It's not the only weird one, though.

VOTE: Star

I can't get behind a Wheme wagon yet, he was recently instrumental in a town win in Guns & Roses and I just have to give him a chance here. He just might be an expert mafia player after all.

He does seem like lim bait though, so many there's some opportunists on his wagon.

How can you claim that Star is lim bait when literally nothing has happened yet and I'm pushing their wagon based on the alignment of the stars

Who do you think is looking for town cred? I'll vote them.

Say less

VOTE: Drew

I think you may have been honest and voted your scum buddy for town cred

VOTE: Star

VOTE: Kitty

I feel another soul read coming on

What am I missing about the KittyTack wagon? I don't want to drag the day out if there's a consensus, but I don't see why everyone's jumping on it. Is there some slip that I missed somewhere?

Naerys->Roden->Looker->Drew

Is probably the path i would go on.

If I'm going today, I would say [Naerys/Doctor]->[FL/Vander]

Why is Dan off the table for you?

[ActionDan]

I'm going with Naeyrs "never" scum.

I am prone to severely underestimating people whom I don't perceive to be playing in a sophisticated manner, but I can't help but think the reaction to kitty's wagon is coming from town. And I see nothing to suggest their play overall or on any individual posts look more scum than town.

@vander drew is town as I think town is too weak if he weren't.

[Naerys]

For me its decisions between Drew and Looker as scum.
I need to reread a bit, but i am leaning Looker is the last scum

[Vanderscamp]

Dan thinks it's never Drew because of mech power, which I understand. Yeah, 3 town PR's is all there is, and that's only if Looker and Drew are both town. If one of them are scum, then that's even less.

Roden is actively taking out possible misfades and doesnt make sense to cut out Naerys.

@Roden - do you think it's possible they were trying to distance from Naerys?

It's possible, but Yess was definitely trying to survive, and Elements was a deep wolf and had me pocketed. Their play and the game state makes me think it wasn't distancing.

Yes might have been trying to survive but Elements was also voting them the whole day, right?
So why wouldn't distancing have been on the table for a pair including Naerys?
I don't understand that read

[Vanderscamp]

I'm going with Naeyrs "never" scum.

I am prone to severely underestimating people whom I don't perceive to be playing in a sophisticated manner, but I can't help but think the reaction to kitty's wagon is coming from town. And I see nothing to suggest their play overall or on any individual posts look more scum than town.

@vander drew is town as I think town is too weak if he weren't.

I agree this is the best reason to think Drew is town

I think their response to pressure today has been quite weird, I agree with FL that their response to FL basically considering that they could be scum seemed very overdone.

[Flavor Leaf]

Looked being able to Bus Drive a Tree Stump ability doesn’t sit right with me, so I’m kinda okay with that not fitting right.

[Roden]

Dan thinks it's never Drew because of mech power, which I understand. Yeah, 3 town PR's is all there is, and that's only if Looker and Drew are both town. If one of them are scum, then that's even less.

Roden is actively taking out possible misfades and doesnt make sense to cut out Naerys.

@Roden - do you think it's possible they were trying to distance from Naerys?

It's possible, but Yess was definitely trying to survive, and Elements was a deep wolf and had me pocketed. Their play and the game state makes me think it wasn't distancing.

Yes might have been trying to survive but Elements was also voting them the whole day, right?
So why wouldn't distancing have been on the table for a pair including Naerys?
I don't understand that read

What's the scum team's plan at that point? Vote out all of their scum buddies? And then what? Like what do they gain?

[Vanderscamp]

Dan thinks it's never Drew because of mech power, which I understand. Yeah, 3 town PR's is all there is, and that's only if Looker and Drew are both town. If one of them are scum, then that's even less.

Roden is actively taking out possible misfades and doesnt make sense to cut out Naerys.

@Roden - do you think it's possible they were trying to distance from Naerys?

It's possible, but Yess was definitely trying to survive, and Elements was a deep wolf and had me pocketed. Their play and the game state makes me think it wasn't distancing.

Yes might have been trying to survive but Elements was also voting them the whole day, right?
So why wouldn't distancing have been on the table for a pair including Naerys?
I don't understand that read

What's the scum team's plan at that point? Vote out all of their scum buddies? And then what? Like what do they gain?

I don't know, but evidence of the scum real hard bussing doesn't make me think that lesser distancing between the other scum members is impossible.

[Vanderscamp]

*team, not real

[Flavor Leaf]

Looker is just on a complete other level of mind sync than the entire game, and I feel that’s probably just Occam’s Razor scum disconnect.

[Looker]

I don't see it as an extreme disconnect. I see it as a disagreement. Only difference is that I removed Roden.

[Flavor Leaf]

Not really what I’m talking about, unfortunately

[Cook]

VC 4.02

Looker (2,

E-2

):

Roden, Flavor Leaf

Roden (1):

Vanderscamp

Naerys (1):

Doctor Drew

Not Voting (3):

Naerys, Looker, ActionDan

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to eliminate someone.
There are (expired on 2023-12-07 00:24:37) left in the deadline.

Prodding Doctor Drew and Gamma Emerald.

[Naerys]

after comparing Drew and Looker i believe Drew looks much better than Looker
so i believe this is the right vote
VOTE: Looker
Should be e-1
I honestly believe that looker isnt really engaged in the game. Drew tries to solve, but Looker lurks while occasionally leaves some remark here.

[Doctor Drew]

Ahh, I wanted to take some time away from this game, not this long though lol.

Should I just hammer Looker?

[Flavor Leaf]

Yeas

[Doctor Drew]

VOTE: Looker

[Flavor Leaf]

Naerys/Roden/Drew all on the wagon, though, is kinda rough, but if aliens have another kill, ta ta.

[Cook]

VC 4.03 (final)

Looker (4):

Roden, Flavor Leaf, Naerys, Doctor Drew

Roden (1):

Vanderscamp

Not Voting (3):

Looker, ActionDan

With 7 alive, it took 4 votes to eliminate Looker.
There are (expired on 2023-12-07 00:24:37) left in the deadline.

Acknowledging hammer. As per my ruleset, you get (expired on 2023-12-02 19:19:00) of twilight.

[Gamma Emerald]

Let’s see what happens