Open 903: IC Basic [Game Over]

[Nora.]

Yay!!

Thanks for being amazing gypyx!

Bad luck town GGs

[TemporalLich]

I should point out that I unfortunately forgot to include the ability text for the doctor's doctor ability in the Role PM

I doubt this mod error has influenced the game, but this mod error is visible in the setup info so it needs to be pointed out

[TemporalLich]

Some PTs have been released!

Mod PT
Dead PT

All other game PTs (Mafia, Mason) have 48 hours for its members to request redactions before they are released.

(expired on 2024-02-29 09:00:00)

[Enchant]

Wait i did really guess huh

[TemporalLich]

The Mafia PT has been released!

Mafia PT

[Gypyx]

Wait i did really guess huh

we had to murder town exemplary enchant before he could expose us all

[gob]

what a terrible game

[TemporalLich]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

[gob]

this setup is shit

[Enchant]

Wait i did really guess huh

we had to murder town exemplary enchant before he could expose us all

Enchant ego rn:

[Nora.]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

I think it would’ve gone very differently if we hadn’t role copped bingle N1… hard to say balance-wise

I did enjoy the game, thanks for running it ^^

[Gypyx]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

i feel like the setup works pretty well and is certainely something i could see myself signing up for once more

the only potential problem with this run was that we (and no offense to gob when i say that) didn't really get to see the IC slot at it's full potential i think

[Gypyx]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

I think it would’ve gone very differently if we hadn’t role copped bingle N1… hard to say balance-wise

I did enjoy the game, thanks for running it ^^

eh i mean, if you don't know who the doc is you can always just shoot the IC

[Enchant]

This is townsided lol

[Nora.]

IC was protected N2 >.> but yeah, it would go to melo instead of elo

[Gypyx]

true

[Enchant]

Killing IC N1 is meta in this setup.

Protected: It's confirmed mafia attacked IC. It gives nothing. Rolecop checks someone for being mason, IC totally sure dies next night.
Not protected: IC dead. Rolecop still checks someone for being mason.


It's really really really boring.

[gob]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

i feel like the setup works pretty well and is certainely something i could see myself signing up for once more

the only potential problem with this run was that we (and no offense to gob when i say that) didn't really get to see the IC slot at it's full potential i think

I played great. Its the town and specifically Bingle who played poorly

[Aureal]

GG; thanks for modding, TL

I just could not get into this one for various reasons, but I did briefly have the solve. And Gypyx was canny enough to see that I was close to voting her and started talking to me and was winning me back, so well played there.

[Gypyx]

anyways my main takeaway is that i really need to get better at interacting with partners

[Bingle]

Killing IC N1 is meta in this setup.

Protected: It's confirmed mafia attacked IC. It gives nothing. Rolecop checks someone for being mason, IC totally sure dies next night.
Not protected: IC dead. Rolecop still checks someone for being mason.


It's really really really boring.

Unironically: agreed. It’s a very-near vanilla setup with a role I’m not a fan of.

On the other hand it’s a pretty balanced near vanilla open and I KNOW there are other people who enjoy that kind of thing. Having played it, (and gotten stomped), I think it’s a fine recommended setup.

[Doctor Drew]

anyways my main takeaway is that i really need to get better at interacting with partners

See? Told you this was nowhere near my scum game.....lol

GG to you and Nora though

But I did not expect Gob to vote me

[Bingle]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

i feel like the setup works pretty well and is certainely something i could see myself signing up for once more

the only potential problem with this run was that we (and no offense to gob when i say that) didn't really get to see the IC slot at it's full potential i think

I played great. Its the town and specifically Bingle who played poorly

Are you actively trying to be unlikeable?

[Bingle]

No redactions.

There were some questions about why ms doesn’t do vote locking: it’s not a thing that ever happened when site was new, and it has the potential to confirm scumteam size in games where that isn’t desirable.

Isis has a method I think is the most elegant which is if every scum player posts after a post where they can qh for the win, she will accept a qh by pm for the whole team.

[gob]

Do you believe IC Basic should be a Recommended Open Setup?

If you believe this setup is one you'd play again (and thus should be a Recommended Open Setup), let me know.

If you believe this setup is unbalanced or unfun (and thus should

not

be a Recommended Open Setup), also let me know.

i feel like the setup works pretty well and is certainely something i could see myself signing up for once more

the only potential problem with this run was that we (and no offense to gob when i say that) didn't really get to see the IC slot at it's full potential i think

I played great. Its the town and specifically Bingle who played poorly

Are you actively trying to be unlikeable?

Huh? No...

It's just a game. I think your play on day 2 quick hammering Enchant is what lost the game. My play on Day 3 was based on that partly. It also outted yourself as doc.