Open 908: Aureal Is Hoarding All The Game Names | Game Over

[Black]

Yep I like 133 because him not seeing Bingle's naked vote was my guess for why he didn't find an issue with it if he's town

I think there's an air of honestly in his posts but that's pretty much just a gut read

[Black]

Klick I think your read is super nuanced and detailed and it feels a little unnatural

[Black]

I don't think it's particularly unreasonable that someone might see "aggressive and pushy" and think scum though.

this isn't the reason i scum read black

Isn't your scumread based mainly on meta?

[Dannflor]

it has nothing to do with meta

[Black]

It's based on you thinking I'm not trying to find scum. What are you basing that off of?

[Dannflor]

your posts

[Black]

How would you expect a townie to try to find scum less than 24 hours into a game?

[Dannflor]

you keep harping on less than 24 hours into a game as if that's a reason i shouldn't scum read you

i am continually evaluating your posting and i acknowledge that yes you have been posting content and yes you are engaging with people

however your posting reads to me like you're more focused on trying to look towny than actually sort people

[Dannflor]

I have a meeting in like 4 minutes but I can be more specific after that

[Black]

It's not scummy to want to seem townie

Your read sucks

[Dannflor]

what is your read on the worst?

[Black]

And I bring up the 24 hour thing because I think my posting was perfectly fine for the beginning stage of a game and I have no clue why you seem to have an issue with it

[Klick]

Klick I think your read is super nuanced and detailed and it feels a little unnatural

this right here is a very big reason why my standard approach is to be esoteric and obtuse with my actual thoughts

[Black]

what is your read on the worst?

Not too sure. Probably back to null. I've liked some of his posting since he left my wagon

[Black]

Klick I think your read is super nuanced and detailed and it feels a little unnatural

this right here is a very big reason why my standard approach is to be esoteric and obtuse with my actual thoughts

Are you switching your approach up to try and get townread?

[Klick]

Klick I think your read is super nuanced and detailed and it feels a little unnatural

this right here is a very big reason why my standard approach is to be esoteric and obtuse with my actual thoughts

Are you switching your approach up to try and get townread?

That seems counterintuitive

[Black]

I guess I'm just curious why you aren't going with your standard approach

[Klick]

I'm being more overt about my reasons for scumreading ceejay because I feel more confident than usual that he's actually scum based off them

[Black]

Your conviction in the read is a little alarming but I also rarely have conviction in mine so I guess that could be part of it

I just don't think your case on ceejay is that strong and I'm surprised you're so confident about it

[Klick]

I rarely have scumreads at all but I'm feeling spicy

[Klick]

I think I might be riding the high from last game somewhat but I also don't think ceejay has done anything to show me an 'air of honesty' like you're saying he has

[Black]

How would you expect a townie to try to find scum less than 24 hours into a game?

Dann I want you to answer this when you get out of your meeting

[Dannflor]

you're asking me what I view as townie behavior, and then I assume you will follow up by asking how your play doesn't fit that

it would be quicker to just cut to that question

43 makes it seem like you aren't really processing the game beyond a surface level. PC didn't make a case to be agreed or disagreed with beyond "implosions next posts will be alignment indicative," so your response to say that you're not inclined to believe in it feels like you're just posting reasonable sounding things for the sake of posting reasonable sounding things, not that you're critically reading for alignment

I think your scum lean on the worst feels like it was just thrown out there because I pressured you for reads, i don't really have an understanding of what made you feel better about the worst or why his vote on you being opportunistic became less bad

like in general, i see you going through the motions of solving and hopping from wagon to wagon but to me it feels pretty mechanical. 128 is like a decent case on Bingle but you slide off of it in 170 and it's not clear to me why those initial reasons ever stopped bothering you. it feels like you want to have trajectories because that's what townies do but they feel a bit too easy to me. that is what i mean by it looks like you're trying to look towny rather than sort people.

[Dannflor]

idk if im wrong and you are town arguing with me that my read sucks isn't really going to help, if you're town (and presumably you think im town) I think I will figure it out eventually

it's not like im about to eliminate you right now

[Dannflor]

fine with the ceejay wagon too