Open 104 - The New C9 - Game Over

[zhaorx]

if you guys really are masons, bad guys won't kill you. you're no threat to them. this narrows down the other more powerful roles for the wolves. this is bad for the good guys.

if you are wolves, you guys are guaranteed to survive for a few more days. This is bad for the good guys.

conclusion: giving your line of logic, this is bad for the good guys.

[Stef]

Christ.. play newbie games before joining normal games. Behavior like this ruins games. I'm seriously considering asking for a replacement.

[zhaorx]

its too early for drama IMO

[Stef]

There's no drama. I simply can't believe that in mere hours since the topic has been unlocked people started setting up lynches and NK's and started claiming. It's no drama. It's a simple fact that such play is ruining this game.

[zhaorx]

could you go a little more in depth stef? i don't understand your angle on "setting up lynches and NK's and started clamining....it's a simple fact that such play is ruining the game"

[Stef]

hey guys,

stranger and siesta are the best wagons fir D1.

Setting up wagons based on.. well.. nothing and i doubt you could actually justify what you said as a joke or as something backed up by evidence since there is no way you could make such a statement based on how little we know. The reasoning you gave is clearly bullshit since SC has not made any statements about who he's going to vote today and siesta. Also, their posts don't appear to be forced at all. You also state that MIKE is probably not a villager when you have NO evidence of that. And how do we know that scott didn't "peek" ( which i presume means "investigate" ) siesta since scott hasn't even posted so far? Your posts are full of crap and mostly you make no sense. You are hurting the town and the game since your actions aren't justifiable even if you were scum.

Hi guys,

I feel like its best to just claim straight up and draw night kills as well as clearing myself and my mason.

Myself and oEJo are village masons.

How the hell is it best to just claim straight up? And how the hell is it best to draw night kills? Also, how does claiming anything clears you as town at this stage? It's simply mind-numbing.

It's clear that at least both of you have not studied what a forum based mafia is played like on this site. Also, what is the rush for anything? Don't you know that ONE game day on this forum can take up to a month and a half? Geez.

And you call these fact drama. Even more reason you should join a newbie game before joining a normal one. Also, try adopting the terms used on this site. I.e. it's not werewolf, it's mafia or scum.

[zhaorx]

stef,

are you retarted? (serious question)

[Stef]

I shall refrain from answering that question or from engaging in further insults. I hope it will not be necessary for the mod to step in regarding your last post. Keep it civilized.

[zhaorx]

my autistic brother probably plays werewollf/MAFIA/SCUM (happy?) better than stef.

[Stef]

Mod: please act on the repeated personal insults coming from Zhaorx

[zhaorx]

what personal insults? i read in the rules that criticism of game play is perfectly acceptable.

[StrangerCoug]

*grumble, grumble* I want to strangle omg_im_innocent_wtf right now. This happened last time I played The New C9 as well. I even voted the claimee that game (he turned out to really be the mason), but not without any objections to my move.

But omg_im_innocent_wtf, that was a really, really stupid move. There are some people that believe certain roles should be claimed outright, but a mason is not one of those roles.

zhaorx, Stef's been here longer than you have, so I would abstain from asking if he is retarded if I were you (especially since the mod's probably going to chew you out).

[zhaorx]

i didn't call anyone a retard. I asked stef if he/she was "retarted". Please do not make up things about me.

[omg_im_innocent_wtf]

I apologise if my play was not the best, as I said I dont think it was bad.

I really dont appreciate being called a newbie/stupid though. I only have about 20 or so posts less than Stef.

[StrangerCoug]

From what I can find on Google, "retarted" is an alternate spelling of "retarded", so they're one and the same insult.

[Stef]

I did not call you stupid under any form. Calling some1 a newbie is not an insult.

[omg_im_innocent_wtf]

It also appears Ive played here longer than anyone else that has posted so far.

If you disagree then fine, thats cool and you are entitled to your opinions. I just request that we keep it civil.

eg. "Omg I dont agree with what you did there, but I believe/dont believe you for these reasons."

[omg_im_innocent_wtf]

I did not call you stupid under any form. Calling some1 a newbie is not an insult.

You inferred I was a newbie.

Someone else inferred I was stupid.

Ive played longer than both of you. I think you are both out of line.

[ZazieR]

You perhaps have played longer, but that doesn't mean you're better. You shouldn't have done the claim. Now you've got to feel the consequences of that mistake.
Can we now continue playing?

[omg_im_innocent_wtf]

That is your opinion.

I believe I am better. And I believe my roleclaim was correct.

That is my opinion.

[zhaorx]

we're not here to argue about who is better at werewolf/mafia/scum. Scott Howard is the best LDO.

Let's find the wolves/mafia/scums.

[Stef]

I inferred that your mistake is a newbie mistake. I was not uncivilized nor was i insulting you. Just pointing out that a town claiming mason D1 without any pressure is a newbie mistake. Now that i come to think of it it might also be a scum tactic but even so i'm not sure it would be a very good one. The only mistake i made was regarding the following statement:

It's clear that at least both of you have not studied what a forum based mafia is played like on this site

I did not realized you hadn't just joined the site like Zhaorx. Me thinking that you had just joined the site + the mason claim was what lead me to include you in that sentence.

[Stef]

Can we now continue playing?

Ehm.. picking up from this won't be easy but we should try. Considering omg has been longer than i have i will presume he is not a newbie therefore i will not give him the newbie card for his claim. Town has NO reason to claim mason so early in a game.

FoS omg_im_innocent_wtf

[omg_im_innocent_wtf]

The fact that rookies think that it is a newbie mistake is what makes it such a brilliant play actually.

But anyway, lets move forward to scumhunting.

Vote: Zhaorx

for anti-town behavior.

[ZazieR]

Atak, how come you started talking about the Seer?