NY Mafia 155 - New Age Mafia II - Game Over!

[bv310]

Well, I was hoping my initial post would have a bit more bang, but I'm typing this via tablet. Gonna read through and make a real post when I have access to something with a copy/paste function

[bv310]

Can't read the thread tonight, but will do tomorrow.

^

[bv310]

Okay, first things first,

unvote

With that out of the way, here's the result of my super-awesome 17-page reread!

First off, Tierce/Umoms are scummy as all hell early. Posts like 74 and 94 are useless as all hell. Nhammen's worse though. His reactions in the first few pages feel fake. Especially post

On page 7, RedFF is worthy of a good wagon. I am in fact quite surpirised he seems to have gotten off with only light suspicion. BBM nails it in post 131


And that's where I am leaving part 1 while I drive home from work. More to come in about an hour. Sorry. Underestimated how long reading 17 pages would take.

[bv310]

Probably should have cut that third line out, in retrospect.

[bv310]

UNVOTE: Rhinox
VOTE: UT

That's stupid.

I suppose. My initial reaction to the claim was that it was town, but it's faded. I'd feel like a bit of an ass jumping back onto Rhinox though, so I'll wait.

This is bad and needs stabbings ASAP.

I agree with AGar that its bad. Except, why would scum say this either? Seems more playstyle than scummy.

huh

What he said. If you feel that a certain player's alignment is anti-town, you vote that player. Doesn't matter whether your vote was there before or not.

Can we just lynch Umoms like we wanted to ten pages ago? This is ridiculous.

I support this sentiment as well. Umoms has switched from stifling discussion to hardcore lurking, which bothers me.

this is pretty much the dumbest shit ever, as a note~

^My feelings about the Quag drama summed up.

I'm

fairly certain

I'm not scum.

I don't get it...

It makes me sad that you're scum in this game, singer. I really wanted to be involved in a game with you that didn't require me lynching you, or being called a cunt for you.

vote: Singersigner

Also, are we still doing the MC thing?

[bv310]

Seems like we're still doing the mass-claim. I am a one-shot Gunsmith.

[bv310]

Iiiiinteresting. I could go for a nhammen lynch based on that alone.

lol@bv voting for me...and then claiming...

Explain

[bv310]

Not while a mass claim is going on please and thank you.

then you came back and claimed when it was pretty much agreed that the MC was dead at that point.

wait what

How do you reach the conclusion that it is 'pretty much agreed that the massclaim is dead' when everybody has claimed but you, umoms and Quag?

Because no one was calling for claim, it had been established that it was a bad idea, and the concept was a dead one being pushed along by other/better things going on. For being caught up on the thread, it seemed silly that he was so eager to jump onto the MC train--looked like he was trying to "fit in" with all the other Cool Kids who thought it was a good idea to claim.

Singer, why haven't you claimed yet?

Did I ever give you the impression that I would? If so, I'm really sorry about that, and I'ma let you finish, but this mass claim idea was the worst idea ever.

It's k, though, Glork learned from his mistake. Now you can either lynch me or let scum decide if I'm important enough to kill, or worth saving for a mislynch later. ... Nannynannybooboo.

So you don't want discussion during a massclaim, but you won't participate? That's your argument here? (Also, I loved the taunting. Very in-line with the quality of your posting so far)

[bv310]

The amount of prod-dodging makes me sad. Also, the fact that this singer lynch is unlikely to happen makes me sad. Deadline is Sunday, and I'm willing to vote Nhammen just to ensure we don't no-lynch.

[bv310]

Fwiw, that's the list I intended to choose from anyway. My first thought was Godfather on Singer too, but I'm starting to think it's something dumb like a Named Townie.

[bv310]

Hello Daisy, what would you like from me? I've stated my beliefs about the current wagons, and given my next preferred lynches, with reasons. Would you like me to expand on those? If so, which ones? Do you just want me to post more?

[bv310]

Willing to trust you, glork.

unvote, vote: Nhammen

[bv310]

2 things:

1) Tierce is NOT CARRYING A GUN. I chose to use my one-shot last night on one of the more contentious people to try and get things out in the open. She may still be Godfather or Serial Killer, but I'm going with Occam's Razor and saying her VT claim is on the up-and-up. Figured with all of Singer's grandstanding over her role's ability to prove itself that she'd, you know, have PROVED HERSELF.

2)

vote: Singer

.

[bv310]

Spoiler: Massclaim list, since I got sick of going back to find it. Now with shiny night results added in!

Living (19/19) [/b] (bold is confirmed)
1.

Hoopla

-- VANILLA TOWNIE
2.

Glork

-- VANILLA TOWNIE, NEIGHBOR WITH RHINOX
3.

Quagmire

4.

Tierce

-- VANILLA TOWNIE
5.

singersigner

_{rep. Untrod Tripod D1}
6.

Bella -

Innocent Child

7.

Rhinox

-- BULLETPROOF TO MAFIA, NEIGHBOR WITH GLORK

8.

nhammen

--

VANILLA TOWNIE

9.

scooby

-- VANILLA TOWNIE
10.

Psyche

-- SANE COP (Used. Guilty on Singer)
11.

AGar

-- 1-SHOT VIGILANTE (Used. Shot Quilford)
12.

Staeg

-- ROLEBLOCKER (RB'd
13.

bv310

_{rep. Thestatusquo D1} -- ONE-SHOT GUNSMITH (Used. Tierce is NOT carrying a gun)
14.

redFF

-- VANILLA TOWNIE

15.

Quilford

--

VANILLA TOWNIE

16.

Simenon

17.

Primate

--

BODYGUARD

18.

Flameaxe

-- VANILLA TOWNIE
19.

JDodge

-- VANILLA TOWNIE

Okay, based on this and what we know now, I'm willing to vote for Scooby, Singer, and Rhinox. Rhinox is sub-optimal for today, since I personally feel like there is more to see there, but I will support his lynch if we need it. If I've missed anything in the above, please let me know.

[bv310]

Oh ffs

[bv310]

I'd love to hear an explanation for that vote, considering that bv claimed gunsmith and cleared me N1.

I cleared you from being scum, but not from being Serial Killer. That said, I really doubt that scum +SK shot the same two nights in a row

vote: Simenon

[bv310]

So, first things first while I have time to sit and read, I had Simenon and Nhammen's actions backwards in my head. My vote was a mistake.

unvote

[bv310]

/prodded. Read through the ISOs of the major two wagons. Scooby is scummier.

vote: Scooby

For reasoning, I'd like to point at basically everything from before his ISO 36/37.

[bv310]

Sorry guys, I'm asking to be replaced. I'm heading back to school in 2 weeks, and the amount of time I'm going to have available for anything is going to be drastically reduced. I'm not going to have the time to keep up with a game this size. Sorry.