It embodies the 'Damn the torpedoes' kind of attitude that I expect from town ABR. He's not responding to being accused of baselessly wagoning by coming up with some convoluted post-hoc rationalization that raises the question of why he didn't say it in the first place - he's just like "Yeah, it's day one, he's scummy enough, and we can't piss about forever." Someone's probably going to try to paint that as scummy, but it doesn't seem like ABR cares that much. Town.
Just FYI, I really, really hate this kind of reasoning too, likely far more than you 'despise' mine. Again, ANY flip is a solid piece of information that is mod-guaranteed to be true. Plus if day one is a crapshoot, why are you now making this super detailed post-by-post account of the whole game? Alternatively, if this kind of very wordy analysis is pro-town, why weren't you doing it earlier?In post 588, Chevre wrote: Page 22 - I despise Tebow's 525. A lynch will give us an alignment which will let us see how other players treated the lynched player, thus there is more evidence. Also your argument that wagoning emogirl to get attention off emogirl is faulty, because wagons lead to lynches and then she won't be such a topic of discussion. Speaking of which, I feel as though since the heat has fallen off her she has posted less. Further, if two people have the same feeling about something there must be something acknowledgeable about it. Plus, the call out on "giving up" is just so so terrible. I truly do think Day 1 is a wash and nothing is convincing me otherwise. Thus I think a flip would be a solid piece of INFORMATION which is mod-guaranteed to be true.
No, you're misrepresenting me. Firstly, you say 'that's not the truth.' Well one, even if you're correct, I'm not fucking psychic. Secondly, that's not what I said. I'm notIn post 588, Chevre wrote:
Page 18 - Aegor's vote is reasonless AGAIN, this time on me. Tebow maligns my words and assumes that since my reason was defend-able, I had wanted to get off that wagon the whole time and was thus waiting for a reason, when that isn't the truth.
And you didn't even go 'She did these things that are unlikely to come from scum, therefore she's probably town.' You went 'She's still kinda scummy, but because of these things, I'm going to unvote.' That totally keeps your options open to return to emogirl later on. That does not say 'town motive' to me.