Mafia with the Quickness 2 GAME OVER!
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
And I don't think continuing this is productive if we're going to go about it this way. We really should be lynching SleepyKrew.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
hi. back on D2 you had been calling every single push I was making "pretty legit".In post 2409, Desperado wrote:if jason is town i can absolutely see you two being scum, yes. now please stop putting words in my mouth (i'm not buying mollie's
pie isn't obvtown, sorry. and your play fitting your town meta to a T doesn't mean jackshit to me either, especially with you being the first one to say it.
was it really just our behavior re: Slan wagon that changed your opinion of our slot?
bc that is at its heart a bullshit BOP angle and you 180'ing your read on me based off just that doesn't make any sense at all. I can imagine if you didn't have a read on us before, or if there were more reasons than that, but there's none of that here. on the other hand, there's a metric fuckton of scum motivation I can think of for doing such a thing (buddying helium, posturing for a mislynch on us down the road, etc.), not to mention this is the exact same bullshit angle you pushed on me last time as scum.
and if you really believed all this, why vote Oversoul? from your POV you think jason is scum AND lynching him would solidify your read on us one way or the other. what makes Oversoul a better lynch than jason?
there is so much cogdis here it's not funnyHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
that is unrelated to my pointIn post 2444, Desperado wrote:yes
so you should be able to see why if jason is scum you are conftown to me, but if jason is town and you were dragging your feet on a slandaar wagon while pushing your jason mislynch that maybe i might think your push on now confirmed town jason wasn't so legit
when you called my push "pretty legit", you didn't know what jason's alignment was. thus you must have had some reason for thinking it was "pretty legit" that wasunrelated to jason's alignment.
however, you seem to have completely forgot about this, in favor of this jason dichotomy that at its heart is nothing but a BOP fallacy. this read progression makes literally no sense and on the other hand has a shitton of possible scum motivation.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
if you "had no intention of doing so before this conversation started", then what the hell was that entire discussion with helium all about? and if you hadn't 180'd the read yet, you wouldn't have said I wasn't obvtown, when you had thought so before.In post 2445, Desperado wrote:and again, you two being so concerned with me 180ing a readthat i haven't even 180ed yet and had no intention of doing so before this conversation startedis extremely weird
this is bullshit and I get the feeling you're trying to intimidate me in order to make me stop my push on you.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
his read progression on me doesn't add up. he originally said every push I made was "pretty legit" - however, now all of a sudden that devolved into "your push isn't pretty legit after all if jason is town" with no other explanation right when you were making a push on us.
Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
how would this mechanic allow me to fake either of those things?In post 2464, Desperado wrote:i was telling juls that the conviction behind your jason push was legitimate and that it was something you are known for. i also think you are capable of faking that as scum, especially in a hydra with f16 and especially in a game with this mechanic where your #s 1a and 1b weaknesses as scum (keeping your activity up and faking ~town wrath~) are nullified.
if anything I'd think short DL's would make it harder for me to fake activity, not easier. the standard of activity would be higher than in a normal game and I would end up standing out more.
and I don't see how day length has anything to do with 1b. this doesn't make much sense and I'm not convinced this response checks out.
I agree w/ you that if jason is town AND the scumteam was aiming for a mislynch they could have pushed through the jason mislynch. however, I'm not convinced that the scumteam wasn't just bussing Slan from the start, especially when we have other ppl in our POE pool (you) pushing this angle on jason down the road. this is even more so the case when I know you in particular to be one of those players who are inclined to bus and wouldn't put it past anyone in here to hard bus from the get go.In post 2464, Desperado wrote:let me ask you something: if you jason is town, why didn't you get him lynched d2?
mb I'm worrying about it too muchHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
SKrew: I don't see how your logic makes any sense whatsoever. saying helium is scum based on one post where they didn't mention NS is a huge stretch and makes way too many assumptions. (e.g. they could just as well be town who just didn't bring up NS in that post)
and another thing: why can't a townie miss the crumbs too? you say the scumteam didn't pick up on the mason crumbs, but you have the logic backwards. if we assume scumteam didn't figure it out then:
"jason is scum" -> "jason didn't pick up on the mason crumbs" is correct
"jason didn't pick up on the mason crumbs" -> "jason is scum" is incorrect.
and besides that, don't you imagine at least one scum would have figured it out? it was p fucking obvious. it's almost impossible that the entire scumteam missed it, especially if they did rolecop SS and got back mason. don't you imagine they'd try to figure out who the partner is in that case?
overall you're stretching way too much, unless I missed smthHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
why WOULD they mention speedy there? this is exactly why I think you're stretching way too hard here
the 2nd line was p obviously referring to jason. and my point was the first scenario is outright incorrect from a logic POV. you're saying that, since jason missed the crumb, he's scum. the problem is, the scumteam may have missde the crumbs, but that doesn't mean that, if someone misses the crumb, they're scum, since a townie could have missed it too - you're selectively applying this logic to jason but NOT any of the other ppl.
none of this makes any sense and I'm having trouble believing it's a genuine argumentHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
In post 2478, SleepyKrew wrote:Why DID they mention Speedy? I don't know. Ask them.
*NS
none of your other answers look legitimate either. it's still a huge fucking stretch to make p much all the assumptions you made and you saying "scum might do dumb things" isn't enough to justify it.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
We just have a day left and we need to consolidate our votes especially the one and two person wagons. SleepyKrew's latest posts felt scummy to me so I am not sure what you are seeing there as town, Arthur.
My initial worry about SleepyKrew came about when most of his push on Jason relied on rhetoric rather than any real substance. When the actual case finally came in Post 2399, it was incredibly weak. While a part of me hesitating in scumreading him for it since he prefers being scum and would supposedly put more effort there, this came much after it was pointed out by several people that he prefers playing scum so I am not writing it off as too bad to be scum.
I don't buy his commuter claim, and I don't like the timing of it. For all that Helium said about Arthur's claim being in response to the possibility of vengekill, SleepyKrew's claim seems to have accomplished just that.
His latest posts where he argues with Helium about the Mason claims are just bad and I don't follow his logic for scumreading them at all nor do I follow why he is scumreading Jason and Post 2451 makes literally no sense. I half get the feeling he is just trolling at this point.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I found Oversoul's jump on Skrew scummy and I asked Pie if he wanted to go that way. I'm again unsure which is the best lynch yet and I don't know what made OS suddenly place his vote on Skrew. It is possible he is bussing but I don't know.
I went through SleepyKrew's ISO and one of the things that don't make sense to me is why he switched from Jason to Slandaar here. With the wagons at close to the same strength, if he believed so strongly and so certainly in his Jason read, I assumed he'd want to push it through to completion. The switch to Slandaar feels more like resignation that the wagon will go through and not wanting to look bad by not bussing.
In post 1882, Zachrulez wrote:9th vote count of day 2:
Slandaar(6): Hoopla, helium-3, Ser Arthur Dayne, Desperado, Oversoul, Nobody Special
jasonT1981(4): Feu et Vol, Sugoku Sugoi, Speedy Saki, SleepyKrew
Speedy Saki(2): jasonT1981, Slice of Life
Nobody Special(1): Juls
Not Voting(2): Perpetual Nonsense, Slandaar
With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.
Day Two will end in (expired on 2014-06-23 09:00:00)Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
In what way?In post 2518, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:I still think his recent play is reminiscent of my play in reck's game that I linked where I was town.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
You should stop confbiasing us and realize that Skrew's rubbish attack on you not knowing the masons = scum is probably because he is scum.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Okay, Pie is on board with Skrew lynch so this is where we are going to keep our vote.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
he claimed right before shos got lynched and when there wasn't much of a chance he would get lynched although he did have a few votes on him. it was also up in the air and not obvious at all who would get vengekilled, so from a town POV there wasn't much of a need for him to claim - however, it makes a shitton more sense from a scum POV. commuter is also conveniently a rly easy fake claim for scum.In post 2511, singersigner wrote:What was wrong with the timing of his claim?
oversoul is a fine lynch but I still prefer a SKrew lynch. I agree with F-16 his jump on the Slan wagon came out of absolute nowhere and makes a shitton of sense as him-scum cutting Slan loose.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
>leaning town on speedy for "gut feeling"
>speedy is a masonHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
yeah but his was a gambit and had a lot more town motivationIn post 2534, helium-3 wrote:wrt bold: didn't sad do this too?
like SAD fake mason slipping to draw a NK seems like a plausible gambit someone would do. and it doesn't make any sense for him to fake gambit as scum considering he was completely off the radar for a vengekill in the first place.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I don't think I get your point re: 1st point?
I disagree w/ the 2nd point. shos's attention wasn't focused on SAD in any way - he was considering jason, SS, and skrew as venge targets without much mention of anyone else, nor was SAD under very much pressure at day end.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
We're done (or rather I am a person that thinks impatience is a virtue which is part of the reason I was so excited about 4 day deadlines).Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
To be fair, you had a whole day to let this sink in. When Sleepy flipped scum, Pie and I were high fiving each other in the hydra QT. Then we posted in the neighborhoods about it. Now the excitement has winded down and we are ready to move onto the next day. I don't get why you are excited at this point since you had a lot of time to let the flip sink in.In post 2585, jasonT1981 wrote:
Why would scum be gloating.....at the lynch of another scum.In post 2578, Perpetual Nonsense wrote:
^scum gloatingIn post 2576, jasonT1981 wrote:FUCKING YES! EAT THAT, SLEEPY!!
Stop stretching, you are sounding as bad as Sleepy.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
@ Singer, I am not sure why exactly you are scumreading us but wanting to recruit someone not in the other neighborhood was more out of a desire to interact with as many players as possible in both neighborhoods while also exposing more players to the content in both of the neighborhoods. I am surprised you are still scumreading us after Skrew's scumflip when we were a major reason for pushing the wagon back on track.
I don't get why people are still scumreading Fue Et Vol after Marquis's latest posts. His frustration felt genuine and his read on SleepyKrew is one that I can understand. It was a similar reason to why I was townreading Skrew early D1 as well.
I am conflicted on Jason but I think Oversoul is a better lynch. His votes on SleepyKrew and Slandaar were both naked votes that came late on the wagon. The lack of explanation for votes makes sense for scum bussing since scum don't feel the need to justify their votes on buddies as much as townies. That's part of the reason that made me think Skrew could still be scum even if OS was scum.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Mollie, Post 2718 was me (F-16).
The reason Singer neighborized Desp instead of you was because I suggested it. She read the game and said she'd probably neighborize either Helium or Desp. I suggested Desp. I don't think she was scumreading me at that time. I also think she thought Fue would neighborize her but I wasn't able to persuade Fue to do it, so Desp ended up in both neighborhoods.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
And as to why Desp wasn't killed, I suppose scum don't want to lose daytalk.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Marquis said that he didn't want to because he preferred an "all-town" neighborhood and chose Desp. This was late last night and I didn't have a chance to respond or persuade him.In post 2724, helium-3 wrote:
so how did this happen?In post 2718, Sugoku Sugoi wrote:@ Singer, I am not sure why exactly you are scumreading us but wanting to recruit someone not in the other neighborhood was more out of a desire to interact with as many players as possible in both neighborhoods while also exposing more players to the content in both of the neighborhoods.
I mean where both neighborhoods recruited desp?
you suggested it to singer, and she followed through but what happened with feio?
Neighborize list:
Singer/Juls
N1: Juls neighborized Sugoku
N2: Juls tried to neighborize Hoopla but Hoopla got nk'd
N3: Juls neighborized JasonT1981
N4: Singer neighborized Desperado
Fue Et Vol
N1: Speedy Saki
N2: Perpetual Nonsense
N3: Sugoku Sugoi
N4: DesperadoHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
But their last few posts in their ISO felt incredibly genuine and Marquis doesn't strike me as the type of player who is manipulative to that extent. I don't see why apologizing to us is contrived if he invested his time and the game and now needs to leave.In post 2719, singersigner wrote:My point about AtE was that it was completely unnecessary as a hydra to give us any explanation. He said he didn't want to replace out but if beast kept going who cares? Apologize to your hydra partner not us. It felt like a really contrived way to make us more sympathetic to his pressure/stress.
I'll look back at SKrew but pushing a wagon back onto a scummy player isn't really that town-telling?
Mollie, all of your interactions with this slot from now on are going to be with Pie. I don't even know why I try being civil with you. Don't bother responding to this. I am done here.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Why would he claim encryptor in his first post though? If he is scum, then he would have to have information about town neighborhoods existing and I'm not sure why he would be given that information.In post 2743, jasonT1981 wrote:Depends on the mod I guess. Zach and I sometimes go with 1 scum and 1 town neighborizers in my games when we use them (though that is not aways)
Encryptors I have never used for neighborhood. I have never even come across them for them.....neighborhoods are usually talk any time hence neighborhoods I have never ... encryptor is usually a scum role, and serves to allow scum to talk and only scum.
The BS SK threw at me, well he spent 4 days screaming I am scum, riling up everyone trying to get my lynch without doing any work himself, when he finally was forced to put his case, it was weak as hell and bullshit.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I haven't discussed with Pie who we want to get lynched today but we're probably going to vote Oversoul or maybe Jason as a second choice. His suspicion of us was opportunistically timed.
I feel like we are distracting ourselves away from Oversoul who I can't see as town at all.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
This is probably going to be the last wall I make since I'm going to be somewhat busy irl tomorrow onwards for a month or so. I'll still probably be able to check in every night but I suspect most of the time I have will go just for catching up with the thread so I'll address some of my reads and thoughts.
1) Desperado: The way he claimed encryptor in his first post felt really town and considering that we are now aware that a scum encryptor exists, I find it unlikely that he is SleepyKrew's buddy and decided to just claim his role. I suppose it is possible but it just makes sense for him to be a town encryptor considering there are multiple neighborhoods and a masonry and I doubt he would know the layout of the game in a way that makes him claim make so much sense.
2) Helium3: Obvtown, don't have much else to say about my read there. Mollie, there is a reason I don't want to interact with you and it is not because I'm scum. You started this game by complaining about Wicked, said you liked Pie and that you wanted to talk to him. I told you I was fine with that and stayed away from you. That didn't stop you from continuing to insult my posts claiming they caused you to "vomit" and posting more stuff about Wicked and complaining about my play. Also, I need to tell you this, everyone that doesn't interact with you aren't scum. I read a few games that you were in and you went down this same rabbit hole with Bulbazak in Chain of Command, Waffles in The Recknoning, Chamber in Wicked, and Ffery in the game I modded, in Song Contest, and in some other large game I don't recall. None of them were scum. Hoopla made a really good point in that your playstyle basically involved pissing people off to try and get a read on them and that's not somewhere I want to go in this game. Your playstyle involves saying stuff like "F16's posts make me wanna vomit they are just like the crappy vacuous wishy washy meta reads as he did in wicked that every1 bought hook line and sinker" and then complaining that people are "marginalizing you" based on your playstyle. But playstyle is kind of the reason I don't feel into getting into a back and forth with you that will lead nowhere and caused Juls to go "high school fucking drama" and replace out. It should be rather obvious to anyone that can read me that I'm town here. If you think I fooled Tammy who's played a dozen games with me into townreading me, you are way off and you should probably listen to the read of someone who has a near perfect track record. Also, there is no reason I would push the SleepyKrew lynch back on track after Arthur went after Oversoul if I was scum here. Don't you see the difference between my bus on Ossy and my pushes here? Nacho and I were forced to bus Ossy, we had no other choice. Here, we could have swayed the direction of the wagons, we could have gone after OS and Jason, even you were saying Skrew could likely be town. I wouldn't have tried to consolidate votes there and try to get everyone back on track as it would just be a suboptimal scum move. Why do you think Pie abandoned our Jason push and turned around and voted Skrew at a point when Jason lynch was possible? We just had a realization that everything Skrew was doing felt scummy and we couldn't see him as town and wanted to lynch him first. Anyways, my best guess at scum right now is probably Jason and Oversoul especially Oversoul who is really doing nothing at this point. Quit letting the fact that you don't like me distract you from actual scum.
3) Arthur: I'm reading Arthur as town for several reasons not least are his pushes on SleepyKrew and Slandaar. Until about D3, Arthur's reads with mine overlapped quite well but I don't get the whole "one of Helium or Sugoku" thing in Post 2577. I agree that from your POV, it is unlikely that Helium and us are scum together but I'm not calling Helium scum at all. We're town and Helium's one of our strongest townreads. We're not asking you to re-evaluate Helium even. I think you ought to re-evaluate your other reads because we're both town. I am decently sure you are right on Oversoul although I really have no idea who the other scum is and Pie and I just wondered if it was that simple and it was Jason/Oversoul after all. We could be wrong somewhere in our townreads but we are reading everyone as town to some extent so I'd rather actually get those lynches first and see where we went wrong if town hasn't won the game by then.
I'm worn out at this point, will probably post later.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Singersigner, I am somewhat disappointed in your posts towards us since the point you replaced in. In that short space of time, you claimed that we were manipulative, whiteknighting, and didn't try to understand our POV at all.
I don't understand why the first thing you did is look at who else is the other neighborizer and tried to find a way to scumread them rather than looking at the game as a whole. And when we said Fue was town, your automatic reaction is that we are whiteknighting. I develop reads mostly through POE, and try to form townreads and most of the time, I focus on who is not town as opposed to develop scumreads with first establishing who I think is town. I sometimes have really strong townreads as well that I'd defend to the death and it is demotivating to be told I'm whiteknighting everytime it happens. I "white-knight" when I'm scum because I try to mimic my town playstyle but you are not even asking why we have a townread on Feu.
We weren't trying to manipulate you in the neighborhood by saying that we'd prefer different people be recruited into both neighborhoods. I said this already but we wanted to talk to as many people as possible and expose them all to the content there. For instance, it doesn't really help us all that much that we can talk to Desperado in two different private threads. It felt redundant from my POV. I guess it doesn't from yours and that's fine but it is not because I'm trying to manipulate you.
As for Fue, I explained what happened. I told them to add you to the neighborhood and they refused. I didn't think they would since Beast had brought it up as a good idea before but Marquis decided not to. I wish they didn't since I was townreading both them and your predecessor and I wished you could see what they posted there so that you both don't go after each other.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I know and I am not saying Mollie is scum for thinking I am scum for that reason. I just want her to see she's wrong and not get distracted by pushing us and let Jason/OS get away.In post 2780, Desperado wrote:
hey remember when you thought mastin saying this about rancid made him the scummiest scum to ever scum?In post 2779, Sugoku Sugoi wrote:If you think I fooled Tammy who's played a dozen games with me into townreading me, you are way off and you should probably listen to the read of someone who has a near perfect track record.
cuz i remember thatHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I'm not sure what you are getting at since Mastin was town. Rephrase that again.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I obviously don't think it is always scummy now that Mastin flipped town but it depends on the circumstances.
I don't think about whether something is "scummy" or not when I post it as town. Mollie is making a show out of how she correctly scumread me in a single game (which wasn't even based on alignment-indicative stuff, the things she said were scummy was stuff I would have probably done as town anyways and is more based on our playstyles being so different and clashing) so I pointed out that someone with a much better track record (Tammy) was reading me as town.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
This is a decent point but it doesn't mean that one of them have to be scum. It would actually be horrible game balance to have a scum and a town neighborizer since the first inclination for most players would be to lynch one of them especially if there are also Masons. I'm not buying doubled up neighborizer claim as a reason to lynch them.In post 2757, helium-3 wrote:a doubled up neighborizer claimIn post 2757, helium-3 wrote:>a distant and weird beastcharizard
I don't know what you mean by this.
It is possible Slandaar rolecopped him considering he made hints about knowing that Speedy Saki was town. Hoopla is likely the other person that was rolecopped. Imperium kill was obvious. I doubt scum would kill anyone else N1.In post 2757, helium-3 wrote:>NS mysteriously keels over once it leaks in their neighborhood that he's a mason
Why would scum-Fue burn towncred by hammering someone that a whole ton of people wanted lynched just to end the day quickly?In post 2757, helium-3 wrote:>a less-than-awesome looking hammer of Slice of LifeHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
VOTE: Oversoul
Someone hammer so we can get this flip and move on with quickness.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
UNVOTE:
I have no clue at this point. Maybe it is Singer after all. I need a break from this game. Will check back in when I feel like thinking about it.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
vote: oversoul (L-1)
we have townreads of some degree on everyone besides oversoul and at this point idk who could be scum if it's not him. I have no idea who the other scum is.
I hate oversoul's recent posting. his reaction to the votes on him was "they're not voting me for things I did", as opposed to refuting the arguments against him. 2844 is complete bullshit and I feel like he's twisting evidence around to suit his argument - he didn't join the wagon till it was the L-1 vote.
jason looks really town recently.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
@desp:how sure are you D2 couldn't play out the way it was if jason is town?
bc I read everything you're posting and while I agree with what you're saying, I still get the feeling it's possible scum was just bussing slan. for an example of what I mean, take a look at (sigh) this game: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=32587
for reference, BRO, zmuffin, and Psychlone were scum. ISO the mod and look at the D1 vote counts. BRO was the leading wagon with both scum votes on it near the end of D1 - if they wanted a mislynch on TNE, they could have easily got one, but they didn't bc they were hard bussing BRO the whole time.
the whole point of bussing is to fly under the radar and get towncred and I don't see why it necessarily couldn't have happened here.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I doubt it is Arthur because he was the driving force between two scum lynches.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
I don't know, I am less sure about Jason, at least part of it is based on Tammy's meta townread on him.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
what I'm wondering is why it's not this one. SKrew was pushing jason really hard which basically shows there was at least some initial scum push for jason. but looking at the VCs, I could potentially see scum choosing to bus jason late as opposed to going for a jason mislynch. this would make me look at oversoul and one of {juls/singer, PN}.In post 2855, Desperado wrote:or the scum bussed slandaar late (oversoul and ???; the last scum in this scenario could be pretty much anyone)
like in that game I linked, neither of the other 2 scum got any towncred from the BRO lynch when he finally was lynched, and I still don't understand why your entire team in playing card bussed each other.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
SKrew said this and he wasn't even on the Slan wagonIn post 1874, SleepyKrew wrote:Ugh but I'm digging this Slanderous lynch and don't want to divert and I'm really really lazy
Can jason wait till D3?
this basically proves that scum decided to cut Slan loose at whatever point, but I can't figure out if it's bc they were stalling and trying to figure out whether it was worthwhile to bus or if it's bc both wagons were on scum.
also, do you mind giving me a quick rundown on your Juls/singer scumread again? bc looking at the D4 VCs both Juls and feu were off the SKrew wagon. we agree singer has been p underwhelming so far and now I'm thinking we might have been wrong about Juls.
but on the other hand she had some really genuine sounding notes and I agree w/ your point about feu. idk how to make any sense out of thisHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
who, if anyone, do you think bussed SKrew?
if PN is scum they went from late bussing Slan D2 to bussing SKrew from the start D4 and then unvoting for some reason. but idk how this is affected if jason is scum with Slan.
oversoul's late vote makes a shitton of sense as a bus vote especially when you factor in the Slan vote D2.
plus, if oversoul was the only one bussing:
In post 2354, Zachrulez wrote:7th vote count of day 4:
SleepyKrew(4): Perpetual Nonsense, jasonT1981, Sugoku Sugoi, Oversoul
Oversoul (2): Ser Arthur Dayne,Desperado
jasonT1981 (2):Speedy Saki,, Feu et Vol
Sugoku Sugoi (1): helium-3
Feu et Vol (1): Juls
Not Voting (1):SleepyKrew
that would mean there's a scum vote off the SKrew wagon and it makes me think one of the neighborizers is scum.In post 2573, Zachrulez wrote:Final vote count of day 4:
SleepyKrew(6): jasonT1981, Sugoku Sugoi, Oversoul, Perpetual Nonsense, Ser Arthur Dayne,Desperado
jasonT1981 (3):Speedy Saki, Feu et Vol,SleepyKrew
Sugoku Sugoi (1): helium-3
Feu et Vol (1): singersigner
Not Voting (0):Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
this is a good point and the main thing making me think they might be scum. that, and the fact they make sense from a voting POV.In post 2890, helium-3 wrote:apparently the only thing marquis knows how to do is push pushpushspuskhpush jason even though it's beoming increasingly apparent he's not scum. static scumreads that just PLOP sit there.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
>I am trying to surviveIn post 2902, Oversoul wrote:Well yes I am trying to survive. Would it be better town play to just lay here and let you all lynch me?
>I was about to self-hammer out of spiteHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
if you were trying to survive you wouldn't resort to making comments about self-hammering
it's a typical scum play - "oh look at me, I have all the emotion town has", without actually showing any of it. and now that you've said you're trying to survive bc it's "good townplay", that makes it look even worse.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
You are wrong on us but probably right about Oversoul so hammer.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
hi. can you tell marquis to get in here and walk me through his scumread on jason?
also I think jason's been p obvtown recently and I wanna know his thoughts on 1. why he thinks SKrew/jason interactions are bussing and 2. his thoughts on jason's reactions to oversoul and him. plz and thxHydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
Hopefully oversoul flips scum but I seriously don't like Singer's posts. Singer, I've heard about your reputation and that you can obvtown yourself as town. So far, I've been underwhelmed.Hydra of F-16_Fighting_Falcon and pieguyn-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014
-
-
Sugoku Sugoi Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 514
- Joined: June 11, 2014